Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

AAW Exhibits...

Posts

AAW Exhibits...

#1

Keith Tompkins

AAW Exhibits...

Keith Tompkins

>I'm attempting to think of a project to make for next year's AAW symposium...the theme is "Step up the the Plate".

Here's my problem: 1. Like last year, no real interest in the theme. 2. While the title suggests makers of plates and platters will have a field day, turning platters really isn't my cup of tea.

3. Many of the pieces displayed in past exhibits have nothing to do with the theme, or at best are a real stretch of the imagination.4.I suspect many turners feel the same way I do, and don't submit pieces to be juried.

Here's my solution: Do away with the "Theme" exhibits, and choose from the instant gallery the "Best of the AAW" each year. Those pieces selected will be displayed at the AAW gallery (among others),and receive recognition in the American Woodturner Mag.

That way, everyone is free to do their best "signature" work with no strings attached...and receive recognition for it. What do you think?

Re: AAW Exhibits...

#2

Re: AAW Exhibits...

jeff jilg

>It's definitely food for thought Keith. The theme on the 2006 exhibition is a bit open. Pieces can be about baseball or about stepping up to the plate (in an imaginative sense).

About your 3rd bullet, the rules were changed this year to get pieces which will conform to the theme. Additionally, the statement which accompanies the piece must also conform to the theme.

...Jeff

Re: AAW Exhibits...

#3

Re: AAW Exhibits...

John Lucas

>Keith I agree it is tough to come up with ideas, but not so much ideas about the theme, I already have 3 ideas I'm "batting" around. The problem I have is working on something that says this was made by John Lucas. That is a lot tougher because I don't have a recognizeable style.

I do like your idea of "The best of the AAW gallery" Whether or not that is part of the show during the symposium or simply an assemblage of the best to either travel or create a book.

I did agree that some of pieces stretched the boundaries of the last show and I'm glad Jeff and the others have answered that problem. Some of the themes chosen like "Nature takes a turn" are much more open and I think I like that better than a theme that seems based on a topic.

One of the pieces I have designed can be interpreted many ways and the statement will be crucial to being accepted into this show. That's not really how I want the piece to be, because I want each person to relate to this piece personally with their own interpretation. We'll see what I come up with. Right now I'm having to work through a serious construction problem. Why do I always have to make something difficult.

Re: AAW Exhibits...

#4

Missing the point?

Bob Hackett

>I would think one of the points of having a topic would be to have an artist move in a direction other than his normal work.

Your idea of a traveling show or annual design book from the best of the instant gallery is a great idea though.

Mainely,Bob

Re: AAW Exhibits...

#5

Re: AAW Exhibits...

Mike Schwing from Md.

>For the most part, I like the "special exhibit". It is special! The things that I did not like about it are being (thanks!) addressed by AAW this year - pieces that had nothing to do with the theme will (hopefully) be rejected.

I like it for a few reasons that may get a bit wordy.. I talked to a couple of big name turners during the past year and asked them for advice on the exhibit as I had it in my sights. A couple of them told me that they wouldn't be submitting work because the theme would have put their work so far outside of their norm and "signature" that they wouldn't be able to sell it and it would take time away from their business to make it. That told me that an artist really had to stretch in order to submit a work (other than the invited ones that submitted their signature work and stretched up a theme/statement).

It also helps new artists get recognition, which I of course particularly enjoyed. I learned new techniques just for the piece I submitted, and really stretched my imagination and skills. I wouldn't have done that without the exhibit as it was designed, but rather, those skills would have been learned as time and desire presented themselves. Without that goal out there, it would be many years before I had a piece of work sitting in the AAW gallery in St. Paul, and who knows how long before folks would recognize my work by "that crazy bug thing" or whatever they call it. No way, for me, that exhibit was priceless.

It was extremely special for me, Dave Bowers, and the other first time juried artists to be in that exhibit, and we really put time, sweat, effort, and risk into getting there. We kind of banded together in KC as "the new guys" and that made it even more fun. Imagine spending all weekend feeling like an impostor in a Wayne's World "We're not worthy!" kind of situation. I'd be sad if no other new artists got to experience that same thing as I did.

I'm trying to imagine how the award might be given out in the instant gallery and coming up blank. I cannot conceive of a judging method that would suffice given the amazing variety of work present. I spent 2 full days walking around in that gallery bewildered and bewitched by the work there. Picking one as the best? No way. Not me. Not even going to try. I like the idea that the instant gallery isn't a competition, and also wonder if it would change the feeling/aura of it so that turners who weren't so sure of themselves might not want to include their work. One of the things that I found so nice about the instant gallery is that everyone's work was not just welcome, but welcomed and appreciated. I wonder if it would be the same knowing there was a judge walking about?

The 2006 special exhibit theme is wonderful for me. I have oodles of great, completely off the wall ideas (no bugs though), but I have big conflicts of time in my life right now - Ironman in July, training now, could be called up by FEMA for NO duty at any moment. Don't know if I'm going to be able to submit anything this year at present.

Re: AAW Exhibits...

#6

Out of the comfort zone.

Jay in TX

>I think "Bob's your uncle" on this one Bob. The themes are put in to stretch the submitters ability in doing and thinking. If we all just stayed in our comfort zones and did what we do best, there would be a lot of the same thing over and over again. Then you get firey debates over plaguarism, secrecy in design and technique, and other less than fully acceptable behaviors (IMO). Some will argue "there's nothing new under the Sun". Well, combining the old items into a new item holds elements of the old contributing to the birth of a new something.

Keith, you're signature pieces (ie. Merengue) are lovely. The challenge may be to incorporate that within the theme, or stick to the instant gallery and the auction to gain the notoriety you seek and deserve for those accomplishments.

Re: AAW Exhibits...

#7

Merengue would make an interesting baseball bat!

Mike Schwing from Md.

>

Re: AAW Exhibits...

#8

Mike, that wasn't the part I was thinking of...

Jay in TX

>I imagined "Merenque" as the visual vortex behind the screwyest fast ball headed straight toward a Mark Sfirri style bat made of cork oak . Not just on topic of the theme, but (IMO) a political statement worthy of Gerrit Van Ness; however, the point may be a bit obtuse to conjure that line of thinking. And no, if this idea shows up as a piece I wouldn't be upset in the least.

Re: AAW Exhibits...

#9

Re: AAW Exhibits...

Greg in Oshkosh

>I really think that there is already a "contest" as part of the instand gallery at the symposium. It is the critique. What pieces are selected for the Critique and make the gallery video every year.

However the selection is interesting in its purpose. Items may be selected to show a form or techinique rather than a finished product. And of course it varies from year to year depending on who the judges are.

Re: AAW Exhibits...

#10

Steven Antonucci

Thinking out of the (batter's) box...

steve antonucci

>My first thought was baseball. I'm willing to bet you'll see a lot of bat-like objects, and baseball themed platters.

Maybe a fancy wooden T-ball set? If I was going, that's what I'd make...

Hmmm...

steve

Re: AAW Exhibits...

#11

Re: AAW Exhibits...

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Keith,

Based on what I saw last year, if you have an established name in turning, your piece does not have to have anything to do with the stated subject and you will be accepted.

You Qualify - so do what you want. ;>)

Mark

Cynical in Alabama.

Re: AAW Exhibits...

#12

Re: AAW Exhibits...

Russ Fairfield

>There is nothing inheirently wrong with having a "theme". People who put together art exhibits like to think in terms of a "theme". There is nothing wrong with that, and I can understand the AAW wanting to present a challenge to the woodturners. The problem is not the "theme" itself, but rather how it is being applied by the judges, and those "invited artists" who choose to ignore it, or stretch its definition beyond credibility.

Why not accept the challenge of the "theme', but make it just that, a challenge. Get rid of the "invited artists", and judge all entries on an equal basis.

Re: AAW Exhibits...

#13

Re: AAW Exhibits...

Mike Schwing from Md.

>I believe it was Keith who suggested something very similar recently. Whoever it was suggested that along with getting rid of invited turners, (paraphrase) submitting the photos to the jury without names attached to them. I really liked that idea! Some of the work will be readily evident, but not all.

Re: AAW Exhibits...

#14

Devil's Advocate (again)

tdaniel

>Keith, I see two approaches to a turner advancing:

1. Challenge turners with these themes and make them stretch

2. Reward turners who take the slow approach and methodically improve their skills and forms and finishes, gradually becoming highly skilled turners (maybe even artists)

I find the AAW to ignore this second approach, although it repeatedly produces the best turners. Skills must come first, in my opinion, then the stretching can begin.

TD

Re: AAW Exhibits...

#15

Re: AAW Exhibits...

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Keith my first thought wasn't a plate or platter at all but something along the lines of baseball. Hopefully if there are plates and platters in the exhibit, they are somehow related to the "baseball" theme. I'm assuming that's what the AAW was looking for when they came up with this title? Louisville Slugger? My second opinion is to have the "invited" turners required to stick to the theme. I think it really takes a lot away from the exhibit if some of the work doesn't relate. It would be my hope that the artists who are invited would be even more inclined to turn something related to the theme rather than use the exhibit to show something from their "normal" work. I had never been to an AAW symposium and I didn't realize that some of the turners were "invited" to participate, and so when I was wandering through the exhibit I was saying to myself..."why is that in here. It has nothing to do with the Wizard of Oz"? It just didn't make sense to me to see some of the pieces there along with the ones from turners who really put a lot of thought and effort into making something that stuck to the theme. Sticking to the theme to me, is the challenge.

Jen

Re: AAW Exhibits...

#16

A vision?

Jack Savona

>Keith, I have a vision. I see a bat that Pete "Rose" might use. What are the odds it might happen?

Re: AAW Exhibits...

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: A vision?

Keith Tompkins

>Jack, that's a good one!

Re: AAW Exhibits...

#18

Keith Tompkins

Re: AAW Exhibits...

Keith Tompkins

>Good replies! Yes Mike, it was me who suggested having no invited turners.....that would level the playing field! Everyone should have a chance based on the merits of their piece submitted. How many deserving pieces don't get included because an invited turner submitted a "boilerplate" turning? Besides, there are plenty of invitation only exhibits already.

Yes, I probably could have submitted a "signature" piece for the "Oz"exhibit, and had it accepted, but didn't feel comfortable doing so. I would rather see someone deserving get a break. (Mike,I know how excited you were, and you earned a spot in the exhibit!) Also, the big galleries all push turners to produce a recognizable style, and usually won't accept work that takes off in a new direction (sales). So the theme exhibits seem a bit contradictory t

Last, someone mentioned the critiqued pieces make the aaw video....which is correct. Why not take it one more step and include them in a special AAW exhibit? That would really further the career of turners who are striving to reach the higher levels of the craft.

One thing REALLY interests me however....from day one, baseball and turning have been linked...the bats are TURNED!hmmmmm

Re: AAW Exhibits...

#19

Re:Baseball bats

JamieDonaldson

>So have you been thru the Louisville Slugger plant? I think the behind the scenes tours next AAW Symposium will be well attended.

Re: AAW Exhibits...

#20

Re:Baseball bats

John Lucas

>Jamie I was a little dissapointed in the tour. 1st there was an artshow upstairs that they wouldn't let us see. I could see Mark Sfiri's piece up there and really wanted to go see it. Then I was a little dissapointed that they didn't have someone turning a bat by hand. I knew it was all done by machine but was hoping on the tour they would demo a bat the old way. I did enjoy the display of old golf clubs however.

Re: AAW Exhibits...

#21

Keith Tompkins

Re: AAW Exhibits...

Keith Tompkins

>You bring up some good points, Mike. Can you imagine, however if your bug didn't make the cut....you would think it just wasn't good enough. In reality, an invited turner, who didn't even try, prevented you from being included. I say let's at least level the playing field.

The instant gallery would be easy...the pieces that are critiqued will be in the aaw exhibit and on the video.

Re: AAW Exhibits...

#22

Keith Tompkins

Re: AAW Exhibits...

Keith Tompkins

>Mark, That's my point exactly....too many pieces should not have been included in these exhibits. I don't want to "qualify"...I want my pieces juried in just like anybody elses. If it's good enough, great, if not, better luck next year.

Not sour grapes on my part, I didn't even submit pieces due to lack of interest in the theme and too many other projects. I did, however help out a couple of people who did make the exhibit.

Re: AAW Exhibits...

#23

Keith Tompkins

Re: Out of the comfort zone.

Keith Tompkins

>Thanks, Jay. It's hard to predict what I may eventually come up with!

Re: AAW Exhibits...

#24

Re: AAW Exhibits...

Pascal Oudet

>that's the way it works with the AWGB: they selected a "TOP 50" in the instant gallery, and these pices become their travelling exhibition

Pascal

Re: AAW Exhibits...

#25

Re:Backstage bat tour

JamieDonaldson

>Way in the back of the turning area is a regular lathe(I've forgotten what brand- maybe an Oliver?)for the single hand turner. He does only custom work, like special sized grip knobs. The AAW tour will go thru parts of the plant that the public doesn't see, including the upstairs gallery where a reception will be held for the Symposium show.