Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Clueless in VA

Posts

Clueless in VA

#1

Clueless in VA

Carole in VA

>OK, so now that I have my new lathe, I have decided I want to try a platter. Have never done one before. The maple blank is about 14" and about 1 1/2" thick. Right now I have it mounted on a faceplate (to what will be the inside of the platter) and am pondering which method to use to chuck it to turn the inside...tenon or recess? Does one hold better than the other? I know that in his video, Bill G says when turning bowls, it is much easier to crack the wood when using a chuck in expansion mode. Does the same hold true when doing something like a platter? I haven't turned a recess before and the chance of me getting the dovetail for a recess just right is probably not likely since I don't have a dovetail scraper. How important is it for the dovetail to be exactly right? On the other hand, would a 2 1/2"x 1/4" tenon be enough to hold this blank? Don't relish the idea of a frisbee chasing me around the shop! I'm starting a whole new learning curve here with larger pieces.

Re: Clueless in VA

#2

Re: Clueless in VA

JamieDonaldson

>Bill G. is right whether it is a bowl or platter- the chuck compression mode is more reliable than splitting by expansion. A 1/4" tenon should be plenty big enough for stable wood- without defects. Use the tailstock with a piece of wood over the point to apply pressure while mounting the tenon in the chuck jaws- more reliable than holding it by hand. And leave the tailstock in place as a safety aid as much as possible.

Re: Clueless in VA

#3

Re: Clueless in VA *LINK*

John U - Charlotte, NC

>Hi Carole -- You can chuck it either way. For a simple platter, I often turn a shallow recess for chucking, and often start out with 4/4 lumber - when I reverse turn, I try to hollow more of the bottom so it makes a shallow concave. I also do a footed platter, where I cut a grove, instead of a full recess, and chuck on the tenon part of that groove, then reverse turn to shape the foot and remove the tenon.

If you want to preserve your wood thickness, you can true up the "bottom" face, and attach a glue block, then turn a tenon on that.

Frank Penta with the Woodturners Guild of NC has an article on their website on turning platters - check it out as a good reference (link below). From their home page, go to Turning Notes, then select the folder with Frank Penta's handouts.

I've turned multi-center bottoms on platters that started as 1-1/2" thick. Frank Penta has a variation on this theme in his handout section also.

Of all the variations of platter feet and rims you can dream of, the best advice I was given for "the perfect platter" was to avoid any and all ripples in the dish itself.


Woodturners Guild of North Carolina

Re: Clueless in VA

#4

Re: Clueless in VA

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I like to use a recess for plates and platters. It lets me keep and use the full thickness of the wood. I usually use a larger jaw set so the recess is closer to the outside edge of the foot/base and it becomes part of the recess in the base. The diameter of the recess isn't critical, but the closer to the nominal jaw size, the better (less marring from the jaws). And you'll probably be surprised at how shallow of a recess you can get away with on some hard woods like maple. Platters don't put nearly as much stress on the chuck and recess/tennon as bowls because they aren't sticking out very far from the face of the chuck.

In some ways platters are easier than bowls -- no real end-grain problems. But on the other hand, any ridges or ripples on the surface really show up!.

Good luck and have fun!

Re: Clueless in VA

#5

What a great resouce!

Carole in VA

>Thanks so much, John! Great site!

Re: Clueless in VA

#6

Re: What a great resouce!

John U - Charlotte, NC

>Carole -- in the WoW "file cabinet", the article I put together in Feb 2004 shows a photo step-by-step process for the multi-center feet. A 14" blank with 16" swing (without swiveling your headstock) is a perfect fit for you!

Re: Clueless in VA

#7

Re: Clueless in VA

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Carole,

On the topic of flattening platters, there is a good article in the Fall 2004 issue of Woodturning Design. King Heiple takes you through the whole process of turning the platter, including chucking in a recess.

Gary

Re: Clueless in VA

#8

Re: Clueless in VA

Barry Irby

>Carole, I personally usually use a tenon. I started with a midi chuck that used tommy bars to tighten and had very poor luck with chucking into recesses. If the rim left by cutting the recess were too narrow, I found it would rip right off. What I mean is that if you tried to cut a recess let's say about two and a half inches in diameter in a three inch diameter piece of wood, leaving about a 1/4" of wood all around, it did not work well. It worked better if there was say an inch of wood left.

A skew seems to make a perfectly adequate dovetail cutter. The angle on mine appears to match the angle on the dovetails on the chuck. (Nova Jaws) I just lay it flat and horizontal on the rest and use it for a scraper for the final cut.

It seems that matching the angle of the tenon or recess to the angle of the jaws. If the angle is not right and the tips of the jaws contact the wood first, they seem to be like "teeth" or chisels and cut right into the wood and cause a split. So you want the angle to match up pretty well or be a little off so that the shoulders come into contact first and compress the wood slightly in stead of biting it.

Also, you want a flat surface for the face of the jaws to ride on.

Something I just learned. I made some walnut stools that had slight concave surfaces. Think platters or bowls 14" in diameter with a 3/8" depression in them. Had a terrible time getting the bottom to be ripple free. There were knots and curly grain and splits and the wood was not fully dry. It would ripple after I took it off the lathe. (No, Really, It was not my fault. My imaginary helper messed them up after I had them perfect.) Once I put a gloss finish on them, they looked worse than I expected. In desperation, I sanded them with a Random Orbital Sander (ROS). Mine is a five inch Quick Sand. It was like a miracle. Started with about 120 grit and progressed in seconds to 220 and then 320. I did three of five and they are clearly better than the others. An amazingly easier way of doing flat or slightly concave surfaces. Once I tried this, I did them on the lathe with the ROS.

Re: Clueless in VA

#9

Re: Clueless in VA

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Hi Carole

I saw my name mentioned here, so I thought I would jump in with my procedure on plates, even though you have gotten some very good info so far. It is easier to crack a blank in half, but that doesn't mean it will happen every time. When I am turning a plate, I will sometimes use a recess because I can then turn a large sweeping curve across the bottom, thinning the plate out and making the edge where it rests very wide and stable.

I do not have a dovetailed scraper either, so if I want that dovetail, I lock the shop door, turn out all the lights except the one over the lathe, cover the windows, look around to make sure no one is near, and then (gasp!) turn my skew chisel over on its side and scrape out the dovetail that way! It only takes a few seconds to form a nice little lip, and it does no lasting harm to the skew.

Good luck with it, and I will be that you are really enjoying that new lathe. I know I was impressed with it when I turned on it a couple of times.

Bill

Re: Clueless in VA

#10

You creep!

Jorge Castaneda

>I do the same, don't even bother closing the door...

Did I get that from you? He, He

Jorge

Re: Clueless in VA

#11

Hah!

Jay in TX

>Bill,

I came to the same conclusion at Ray Thompson's EOP picnic 2 or 3 years ago (Yes, you were there... No, you didn't show me ;~). Dave Smith was looking over my shoulder providing step by step (exhaustive or exhausting, you decide) instruction when it came time to cut the recess on a small walnut plate for reversing. No square or dovetail scraper was within view, but a skew was. I leveled it off as Dave says, "Is that a scraper?" I said, "It is now." and the rest is history.

~Jay... when the only project you have is a nail, everthing begins to look like a hammer (or something like that) in Saginaw, Tx [tmds]

Re: Clueless in VA

#12

Something Different...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Well I'm going to go against the grain and suggest my way of turning platters. For a lot of years I've turned platters using double faced tape. Haven't lost one yet. My largest is 22 inches. One advantage in using DF tape is that you can turn platters from thin material. No recess or tenon. When turning platters at demos I often will invite the biggest muscle-guy there to try to pull the blank off the faceplate. I don't think that even Bill G. could do it.

To use tape you must have the right kind. Carpet tape won't do it. Permacel tape from Craft Supplies and others is the best. I mount the blank, true up and complete the foot area, including sanding and a turned design, and install the faceplate, complete with tape. Clamp it for a minute or two, mount it on the lathe and turn the platter. To remove the finished platter I insert a small small wood plug in the faceplate opening and install it on the spindle. The plug easily pushes the platter off. No muss, no fuss.

A couple of things to remember...When using tape, don't leave an unfinished piece on the lathe overnight....it may end up on the floor in the morning. Also, DF tape won't work with wet wood.

Wally

Re: Clueless in VA

#13

Steven Antonucci

Can't use a skew for anthing else...

steve antonucci

>I own three of the silly things, and someday, I might figure out what good they're for in a face plate turners tool rack. My 1/4" even cuts dovetails with the tailstock in place.

Doors wide open in Byram, NJ

Steve

Re: Clueless in VA

#14

Re: Something Different...

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Wally makes a very good point here Carole. Plates, and even some bowls can be held with tape. However, they require a flat smooth surface, and if you are starting from a board that has been planed, that is fine. I often start with a chainsawn piece of wood. You could put it between centers and smooth the one side that way, and then just chisel the nub left over off the lathe.

Bill

Re: Clueless in VA

#15

Exactly

Carole in VA

>I was starting fron a chainsawn slab. In fact I had to use a hand plane to smooth an area reasonably flat for the face plate. I hate it when I get those chainsaw "steps", but it seems that whenever I have to cut from both ends of the log I end up with them. Guess I need to hone my chainsawing skills. :(

Re: Clueless in VA

#16

Re: Something Different...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I also use DF tape for a lot of small things, such as attaching a piece to turn the underside of a collar before gluing it to the vessel. Using the wood plug to remove it from the faceplate makes it very simple and easy.

Wally

Re: Clueless in VA

#17

Re: Something Different...

Carole in VA

>Yep! I got that technique from you for the collars. Works well, but I only have cloth carpet tape. That seems to be OK for the small stuff. I am rarely working with stock that is smooth enough for tape except for collars.

Re: Clueless in VA

#18

Re: Something Different...

tdaniel

>You can screw a faceplate to what will become the inside of the platter or plate using short screws; then turn the bottom and sand it; then turn it around and use the DS tape to hold it while turning the inside. This works well with chainsaw sawn blanks.

TD

Re: Clueless in VA

#19

Re: What a great resouce!

Jill

>Hi Carole,

Just got back for the SWAT conference were Frank Penta was one of the demonstrators. WOW!!!!! He did a great job showing us how to turn a platter and his instructions seem really great. I can't wait to try my hand at platter. Let us know how yours turns out.

Happy Turning,

Jill