Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Trees to stay away from for turning purposes

Posts

Trees to stay away from for turning purposes

#1

Trees to stay away from for turning purposes

Brian McInturff

>So what trees do I stay away from. I'm wanting to "cash" in on free stock like a lot of you guys do but which trees are not great for turning. I'm looking at smaller items in a 10" andless diameter but plan on having one of my other lathes up and running soon. I'm gussing all fruit trees are good for turning as well as oak, walnut, cherry, elm, and maple. But how about Pines? I live in Myrtle Beach, SC and don't have a lot of local trees to choose from. Wish Palm trees weren't in the grass family.Thanks, Brian

Re: Trees to stay away from for turning purposes

#2

Re: Trees to stay away from for turning purposes

Ron in Drums PA

>The most important tree to stay away from is the one growing on your neighbors land. Sometimes they just don't understand...

Otherwise if it's wood, it turns!

BTW - You will get splattered with pine and with wormy wood.

Re: Trees to stay away from for turning purposes

#3

Re: Trees to stay away from for turning purposes

John Lucas

>Wet pine is probably the only tree I stay away from. I don't like the sap getting all over me. Other than that I've turned a little bit of everything. Hardwoods like locust just take longer to turn but I still like them.

Re: Trees to stay away from for turning purposes

#4

Re: Trees to stay away from for turning purposes

oldgriz

>Also any standing tree in a public park or state forest preserve..

For some reason the local governments have a problem with that.. LOL

Re: Trees to stay away from for turning purposes

#5

Re: Trees to stay away from for turning purposes

adrien

>cryptomeria. It crumbles instead of slicing

Re: Trees to stay away from for turning purposes

#6

Re: Trees to stay away from for turning purposes

JKJ in East TN

>The basswood I turned once was extremely soft and prone to end grain tearout, as did buckeye. Some eastern red cedar I've had did the same but some other did not.

I haven't turned any dry hickory, but someone in our club called it the most "cussed" wood he ever attempted. Maybe he didn't have sharp tools. Another guy gave me a Lyptus blank since, in his words, it turned like granite. However, I enjoyed making a bowl from it although it did need razor sharp tools.

Also, some woods (such as oak) are more pleasant to turn when green than dry. Others, as mentioned, are messy when green! Others are reportedly prone to crack and split when drying, depending on the wall thickness, geometry, and drying technique. I understand wood such as apple, peach, and pear are like this but all I know about them is from what I've read.

You may want to avoid woods you are sensitive to. I (and others) break out in a rash when turning eastern red cedar and cocobolo. However, it's difficult to know exactly which without trying them.

JKJ

Re: Trees to stay away from for turning purposes

#7

Re: Trees to stay away from for turning purposes

stacey s

>Brian,

Dont stay away from palm just because it is in the grass family. It is a pain to turn and very difficult to keep on the lathe but it is worth the effort. I have had several that turned out very nice. Do a web search for Dewey Garrett he is known for his palm pieces. Just be forwarned palm doesn't like to be held on the lathe with a scroll chuck use a glue block or another method( I learned this the hard way) Other than that whatever you can find. I haven't found anything yet taht wasn't suitable for turning. Some just required a little more work than others.

Stacey

Re: Trees to stay away from for turning purposes

#8

Link to Dewey Garrett *LINK*

stacey s

>Here is the link to Dewey Garrett where I have seen his work.

Stacey


http://www.guild.com/artist/5234.html

Re: Trees to stay away from for turning purposes

#9

Re: Trees to stay away from for turning purposes

John Lucas

>Brian I turned some barn wood once. It dulled the tool so fast you had to sharpen it after every pass. Once you got down about 1/4" it cut like regular dried oak but man was that stuff hard on tools for the first 1/4"

Re: Trees to stay away from for turning purposes

#10

Re: Trees to stay away from for turning purposes

Kevin Turner

>I have 5 burls that have caught the eyeball. most are large. 3'x2' spruce and black ash. But the graveyard attendant won't let me in the yard with a chainsaw...I guess , the occupants don't like the noise??

Re: Trees to stay away from for turning purposes

#11

Steven Antonucci

Trees with vines...

steve antonucci

>Pretty good chance you'll have poison ivy at the end of your turning...

Also, poison sumac is probably a bad idea. Never had it, but it's probably better that way...

steve

Re: Trees to stay away from for turning purposes

#12

George Balock

Re: Trees with vines...

George Balock

>Brian,

The only wood I've disliked turning was red oak. It was difficult to dry without checking. I've been told to stay away from pin cherry (smooth bark). It is prone to ring shake. The ones that have surprised me were some of the ornamentals--arborvitae and japonica.

George

Re: Trees to stay away from for turning purposes

#13

Re: Trees with vines...

Brian McInturff

>Isn't Japonica a bush? Also another question: How about the "root ball" of trees like fruit trees, dogwood, box elder, and so forth. Are these good sources of beautiful grain. Thanks, Brian

Re: Trees to stay away from for turning purposes

#14

Re: Lyptus

Ned Bulken

>Lyptus should turn like iron(wood) as it is harder than rock maple on whatever the scale is for that aspect of wood. (hardness?)