Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Tool Choice Spigot vs. Collet Chuck

Posts

Tool Choice Spigot vs. Collet Chuck

#1

Tool Choice Spigot vs. Collet Chuck

TomW in SouthJersey

>I am looking to purchase a chuck that will easily hold small pieces for making wine bottle coasters. It looks like a small MT2 collet chuck will do the job. However, I have a Oneway Stronghold chuck and it looks to me as though the spigot jaws would do about the same thing for what I'm looking for. Can the spigot jaws hold if only drilling a recess in 3/8 inch or so?

I haven't used either of these and would like to make the best choice. Any opinions from those with experience with either or both would be appreciated. (also I noticed every online and catalog source for the small MT-2 collet chucks is at about $40 the same as the spigot jaws. All except Lee Valley which shows one for about $18 for the collet chuck. Am I reading something wrong?)

Tom Wright

Re: Tool Choice Spigot vs. Collet Chuck

#2

Re: Tool Choice Spigot vs. Collet Chuck

John Lucas

>Tom Having just turned a bunch of wine stoppers using a couple of different methods I like the collet method the best. You have less mass to get in the way of using the tools. Of course it depends on the shape of the stopper to some extent but I find that the chuck even with extended jaws still gets in the way of some cuts.

I've started using a homemade pin chuck to cut down on vibration and dowel breakage. It's a 3/8" steel bar with a cutout milled near the end and then I use a cut off nail to lock the stopper blank in place. I chuck this up in my chuck or in a collet. I would like to try the Craft Supplies jacobs chuck that is ground to accept the dowels. I'm also thinking about making a dedicated pin chuck that is a #2 morse taper with the tip turned to 3/8" I would think this would give the most stability and a lot of clearance. I would probably put a draw bar on it to lock it in place.

Re: Tool Choice Spigot vs. Collet Chuck

#3

One possibililty *LINK*

Fred in NC

>There are ready made Morse taper to Jacobs drill chuck adaptors. They even come with the threads for the drawbar. All it needs is a little turning of the shank to size and cut the flat. Link to pic below.


Morst taper with stub and drawbar thread

Re: Tool Choice Spigot vs. Collet Chuck

#4

Re: One possibililty

John Lucas

>Fred That's what I was thinking I would buy and then turn it down to 3/8" and mill a flat for the pin. www.travers.com has a lot of choices.

Re: Tool Choice Spigot vs. Collet Chuck

#5

Re: One possibililty

TomW in SouthJersey

>Whoops. I guess I wasn't clear. I use a 3/8th inch stopper chuck I got from Arizona Silhouette that works very well for my stoppers. What I was looking for was something to hold a piece of wood to make a coaster for the bottle. I ended up taking a ride to Woodcraft today and bought a small MT2 collet chuck. I've turned one coaster and it seems to hold pretty well.

Here's a photo of what I got. To use it you drill a 1 3/8 hole 3/8 inches deep with a Forstner bit in the bottom. The piece mounts on the chuck and clockwise rotation tightens the piece to the chuck.

Tom Wright


img

Re: Tool Choice Spigot vs. Collet Chuck

#6

Brad Vietje

Re: One possibililty

Brad Vietje

>That ought to work just fine.

Another possibility is a piece of scrap wood on a faceplete (or held in your chuck jaws) and gluing on the blank with either CA or a hot glue gun. Double-faced tape holds very well for these shallow pieces, too. You would then pry it off slowly and gently, then reverse (tape again) to finish off the bottom.

Depending on the design, you could turn (or drill) a 2" recess, just 1/8" deep, and use the standard #2 Onewway profile jaws, or the smooth jaws. There are a lot of ways to do this, and your little collet chuck ought to work fine.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT