Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Band Saw Recommendations

Posts

Band Saw Recommendations

#1

Band Saw Recommendations

Stephen DiCenso

>I am a turner and am in the market for a band saw. I would like to be able to cut a 12" log as well as do some resawing and other things too. I have been pointed at the Laguna. I have been told no go look at the Delta. Then others say the MiniMax is the way to go. I saw a Rikon in Woodcraft for less money than most of these other saws but don't know much about it. Any thoughts or recommendations?

Thanks in advance.

Re: Band Saw Recommendations

#2

JL

Re: Band Saw Recommendations - partial hijack

JL

>To throw another saw (or two) into the mix. I have been looking at the Jet JWBS-20 and the Jet JWBS-18. The JWBS-20 has a resaw capacity of about 12" listed.

Re: Band Saw Recommendations

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: Band Saw Recommendations

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Stephen, I don't think the Rikon is heavy enough...My personal choice would be the 20" General, designed to be used in heavy production work. I use one of these at the school where I teach...lots of cast iron.

the Jet or Grizzley will both work as well...I won't rec'd Delta, overall, I think they have QC problems.

The Minmax and Laguna are heavy duty although expensive.

Re: Band Saw Recommendations

#4

Re: Band Saw Recommendations

Bob Hackett

>I happen to know that The Center for Furniture Craftsmanship in Rockport recently traded thier Delta "18 for a General 14".

Pete said they were very disappointed in the performance of the Delta.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Band Saw Recommendations

#5

Re: Band Saw Recommendations

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>For the money, I like the 17" Grizzly for $825 which is the same as the Harbor Freight for $749. It has a 12" cut and a 2 HP motor.

Re: Band Saw Recommendations

#6

I have a 14" Jet ....

Jim K in Trappe PA

>I have a 14" Jet (bought used - about 10 years old) with a riser block that I bought on Amazon, and am happy with it. I cut blanks up to about 11" thick. My lathe is a 12" Delta, so this is plenty of capacity for what I do.

The first question is how much are you goin to use it? If only occasionally, one like mine will probably do. Jet has one now for about $600 with the carter style quick release and carte style bearings (at least I think it has both - check Amazon). You would need a riser block, but that would give you 12" clearance for about $750. If you are just a hobbyist, and on a budget, I think it would do.

If money is no object, skip the bandsaw and buy a Oneway lathe ;-)!

Re: Band Saw Recommendations

#7

Re: Band Saw Recommendations

tim mathis

>hi , i received the new wood magazine today. they rated 6 bandsaws.the rikon was the top tool ,it got 5 a's and 1 a-. they loved it .the griz g0513 got the top tool value award.so check out the new wood mag november issue. i am to looking for a bandsaw for resawing purposes.most saws tested made in taiwan, rikon made in china. i know the mini-max is top notch and high dollar.

saws that were tested #1 bridgewood- bw-17wbs,$950.#2 grizzly g0513-$795. #3 grizzly 0514 $1,040. #4 jet jwbs-16 $900. #5 rikon 10-340 $1,000. #6 shopfox w1707 $925.check out www.forums.woodnet.net . you can findout more than you want to know .most there bought the griz 0513 and love it. the ones who bought the rikon swear by it .but use the search , and ask a question or two you will get owner replies.i would rather buy usa but the price is up there. that is why i am still looking. i hope this kinda helps. tim from centerville ohio

Re: Band Saw Recommendations

#8

Re: Band Saw Recommendations *LINK*

matt fallon, li ny

>I too got the WOODmag review.

i too scoured the net for more info on it

i too found more than i wanted at woodnet hehe...

i too am drooling the Rikon after viewing the pics and reading numerous reviews on it. wood,fine woodworking and American woodworker have favorable reviews on it.

one interesting thing i found at woodnet is that there is another company marketig the "rikon" it is teh same saw,its about same price(less) and different color,includes a mitre-gauge($30 value) and the shipping by ups said $12 (!?)


img

"Pioneer" INDUSTRIAL 18'' BANDSAW

Re: Band Saw Recommendations

#9

Re: Band Saw Recommendations

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Hi Stephen

Confused yet? ;-) I upgraded this year from a Jet 14" to the Mini Max 20. It has 19" between the blade and the column and 15 3/4" under the guides. This saw has some serious muscle, and will go through wet end grain blanks that are as thick as its capacity without even grunting. I have done some grunting though, as blanks of that size have been well over 100 lbs! It ain't cheap, but I will most likely never need another saw.

Here is a picture of it sititng next to my Vega bowl lathe.


Bill

Re: Band Saw Recommendations

#10

Re: Band Saw Recommendations

Stephen DiCenso

>I'm not really confused but most of you guys do a lot more turning than I do. I barely get time to turn on the weekends. I need to retire to get enough time. Really though, I don't want to spend a fortune on a saw right now. After reading the article in the November 2005 issue of Wood Magazine, the Rikon or the Grizzly would work for me. THe Woodcraft in my area has a 10 or 15% discount on the Rikon until the end of the month. That means around $850 to $900.

Thanks for all the info...............

Re: Band Saw Recommendations

#11

Re: Band Saw Recommendations

Guy

>I used to own a 14 inch Grizzly and it served me well for a long time but last year my wife asked if I wanted a new bigger bandsaw so I did my research and ended up with the big Rikon. To me Rikon is along the same lines as Grizzly products. They are a good product, not terribly fancy but very functional. I put a Timberwolf blade on it and did some tuning and it is sweet. Cuts through 12 inch thick wet oak logs with no problem. It has been very solid and blade tensioning is no problem either. The fence is kind of cheap but then they all are. My wheels were balanced and straight right out the box and they are cast iron which I prefer. Vibration is nill. So far I haven't had any problems. For me it has been a good reliable saw and the money I saved helped me get other things for the shop. Have fun, Guy

Re: Band Saw Recommendations

#12

Re: Band Saw Recommendations *LINK*

Ed Moore

>Stephen,

I recommend LeNeave Machinery in Charlotte, NC. I bought their Northstate 21" bandsaw over a year ago and am extremely pleased. Others have accepted my recommendation and are also pleased. I paid under $1100 for the 21" with 3 HP, a heavy duty mobile base, and two blades. I recently spoke to Greg LeNeave and he said that steel prices have forced the prices up some. If you call them, tell them Ed Moore recommended them so that they know that turners are interested.

Recently I put a 3 tpi blade on it and cut some 6" dry oak like it was butter.

Bandsaws are under saws on the website.


LeNeave Machinery

Re: Band Saw Recommendations

#13

Re: Band Saw Recommendations

AnthonyY

>I have the Rikon and couldn't be happier. 10" vessel blanks with no problem!