Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

live center stuck in extender

Posts

live center stuck in extender

#1

live center stuck in extender

GaryG in MD

>OK, how do I get out of this one?

I use a Jet 1236. The worthless banjo extender broke in half, and at "your" recommendations, I have not replaced it. I bought a MT extender to use in the tailstock to make more room to maneuver the banjo between the workpiece and the tailstock. It works great, and I'm very happy with it. Except for one little problem. My MT live center is now permanently stuck in the extender. Normally, to remove it from the tailstock, all I would do would be to back up the tailstock and it would pop out. Now I can't do that (it just pops the extender out). The extender is hollow and has oval holes on either side, but not longitudinally, so there's no obvious way to poke out the center from the rear. Is it in there for good, or is there a trick? I wouldn't mind leaving it in there permanently, but sometimes I like to take the center point out, and now I can't do that either. Ideas? TIA, Gary

Re: live center stuck in extender

#2

Suggestion...

Peter Teubel

>Apply some heat via propane torch the the extender. It should expand enough for the center to pop out. Of course, you will always have this problem, so you might want to cut off the end of the extender so you can use a knockout bar in the future.

Re: live center stuck in extender

#3

Re: Suggestion...

GaryG in MD

>Thanks for the thoughts, Peter. Interesting idea about cutting the end off. I wonder if that might not compromise the stability? Perhaps not. Depends on the wall thickness. I'm no expert at that kind of thing. It has a plug in the end now -- I can't tell if it's pressed in or screwed in. It's black and has a small hole (~1mm) in it. Further comments along these lines would be of interest. ...Gary

Re: live center stuck in extender

#4

Re: Suggestion...

Bill Crommett

>If warming the combination with a torch gets it too hot without results, try putting in the freezer over night and then warming up the outside without getting the live center hot.

Re: live center stuck in extender

#5

Re: Me too. Please post here what actually works.

Al Crandall- NE of Indy

>My Jet live canter from my mini lathe is "permanently" in an extender like yours. I never noticed that the center's shaft was too short to reach the drift slot before I banged it in place. When it gets too much of a hassle, I might find out how hard the extender is by trying to drill a knock out hole through its tang.

Re: live center stuck in extender

#6

Re: Me too. Please post here what actually works.

Arch

>Often rapping very hard on the extender shaft will losen the mating tapers. A short length of rod can be inserted thru the drift slot and into the hole so that the drift will reach. Worked for me.

Re: live center stuck in extender

#7

Re: live center stuck in extender

Bruce in Saint John, N.B. Canada

>Gary I don't believe you will be able to get it out with heat. The two pieces are no doubt made from steel and thus have the same rate of expansion. It might work but I have my doubts. You say there are two oval holes in the sides of the thing. Sounds to me they are there for a reason. That being the removal of the extension. Are the holes large enough to get a steel wedge in there to force the extender out? Not sure if I make myself clear or not but is it like the quill on a drill press? You know when you have to remove the jacobs chuck from you drill press one has to extend the quill and then place the steel wedge in the oval hole and then a little tap with a hammer and out pops the chuck. Just a thought, good luck anyway.

Bruce in Saint John, N.B. Canada

Re: live center stuck in extender

#8

Re: live center stuck in extender

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Is the end of the live center taper visible through the oval holes on the sides of the extender? If so, use a screwdriver or two to press against the end of the center's taper. It should pop out.

My socket adapters (#3 to #2 MT) came with a wedge shaped bar to knock the center out of the socket.

Re: live center stuck in extender

#9

Re: live center stuck in extender

George Van in WI

>I did the same as Arch. I put a small nut in the slot to contact the bottom of the live center, I then put the tapered drift bar against the other side of the nut and drove the bar through the slot. the nut pushed the live center out.

Re: live center stuck in extender

#10

Re: live center stuck in extender

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>I have the same problem every time I use my estender. Did it yesterday. The way to get it out, is to open up your bench vice just enough so the the extender will fit in between, and drop the pair through it from a couple of feet up The outside of the live center will catch on the jaws of the vice, since it is wider, and the momentum will drive the extender off the live center. Works every time for me.

Mark

Re: live center stuck in extender

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: live center stuck in extender

Keith Tompkins

>A hydraulic press will remove almost anything if all else fails.

Re: live center stuck in extender

#12

Re: live center stuck in extender

woodspinner/ Bill Hale

>Pack the center in dry ice. Give it 45 min., or so, to get cold and then heat the body with a tourch. Use a drift pin and all should be well.

Need to find out why it stuck so tight.

Clean and oil for the next time.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: live center stuck in extender

#13

Re: live center stuck in extender

JKJ in East TN

>That the two pieces are the same material should not matter much - apply the heat to just the outer piece and it will get hotter than the inner piece and expand more. This is done all the time in auto work and industry.

However, I hate to heat precision parts unless necessary due to the possibility of warping (and damage to bearings). The dry ice method should work, or use water ice or water to keep one part cool while applying moderate heating to the other.

If there is enough clearance and something to grab on the center (besides the bearing), it might be easy to make a puller. For example, my steel vise has replaceable steel pads held with screws - a couple of pieces of stock, a drill press, and a grinder could make inserts for pulling the two pieces apart.

But for a permenant solution I think I'd try drilling an end hole, or if the side holes were not positioned to allow a tapered pin for extraction, it might be possible to enlarge them for next time.

JKJ

Re: live center stuck in extender

#14

Re: live center stuck in extender *LINK*

Randy Privett

>If I'm understanding this right, you need a drift to insert into the oval hole as you call it and hit the drift to remove to #2MT live center.

Look at the link, to find what I think might help you

Randy


http://www.use-enco.com/CGI/INPDFF?PMPAGE=305

Re: live center stuck in extender

#16

Re: live center stuck in extender

GaryG in MD

>Thank you all for your excellent suggestions. I 'get the drift', so to speak. I'm sure I'll be able to handle it now. Regards to all, Gary

Re: live center stuck in extender

#17

Re: live center stuck in extender

Arch

>Gary, before you 'drift' into more complicated methods, to humor me, put some WD40 on the mating surfaces, then a series of hard blows to the extender body with a heavy hammer. I'm betting the tapers will fall apart without damage.

Re: live center stuck in extender

#18

Re: live center stuck in extender

Bruce in Saint John, N.B. Canada

>Morse tapers were never designed to be oiled before using, they are a dry fit. Its a good practice to oil them when in storage to prevent ozidation but the oil should be removed before it is put to use. Like I said above the oval hole is for removal, a wedge is ment to be place in there and a little tap with the hammer and it pops out. GOOD LUCK

Re: live center stuck in extender

#19

Re: live center stuck in extender

Bruce in Saint John, N.B. Canada

>I hate to tell you Hawaii Turner but those tools are designed for removing tie rod ends, pitman arms and idlers in the automotive (front end) industry. Much to large to rectify Mikes trouble.