Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

Posts

Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

#1

Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

Ed Kelle

>I've had this tool for a while, even done a few projects with it, but as time goes by, I seem to be getting WORSE with it. And I have no clue why. I seem to be following the instructions, having the tip at center height, and I discovered I have less twisting going on when I place the straight part of the tool on the rest rather that the curved part. Their instructions for sharpening, putting the topside of the cutter flat on a stone, sure did not seem to make any difference. I did however touch up the bevel on the grinder which made some difference in its ability to cut.

One of the main problems is that I am getting a good deal of bouncing going on with the tool, particularly towards the bottom of the vessel in through a little farther up the cut as it begins to slope upwards. When I have reached say the halfway up point of the vessel to the top it isn't nearly as bad. I even tilt the tool slightly downwards like a real scraper which helps a little. I am trying to be as gentle with this as possible, so it is not a question of me trying to take too big of a cut at once, at least I hope not. I have tried switching the position of the cutter, placed it in the holder both with the cutter on the inside edge of the curve, and also with it on the outside of the curve. Not much difference.

I've tried varying the angle of the cutter in the holder as well, can't really figure out where I should be placing it. Here is where it is at right now, so any suggestions from those who have used this tool successfully would be appreciated.

I am starting to think that paybe having this option of changing the angle of the cutter might not be as good as a hollowing tool that has it in a fixed position, like most of the tools I see out there.

I'm open to any suggestions that will keep me from saying more bad words tonight. Thanks


img

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

#2

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

Carole in VA

>I had an awful time learning to use that tool. You definitely need the straight part of the shank on the tool rest. My toolrest is 3 or 4" from the vessel rim. This reduces the tendency for the tool to roll on you. I also keep the toolrest slightly above center and tilt the tool down slightly. I also reground the cutters so they don't have as steep a bevel. I think this regrinding was the key...they were just too aggressive. BTW, I have never been able to sharpen them as Sorby suggests by doing the flat edge. I thought it was just me!

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

#3

Brad Vietje

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

Brad Vietje

>Ed,

I don't have this particular hollowing tool, but a number of others that are similar. As Carole writes, do keep the rest back under the straight part of the shaft. Don't worry about staying at center -- you can cut way above center with this sort of scraping cutter, with a rotation CCW (left), but don't let the tip go lower than the center -- that can be exciting.

I also find it easier to get used to this sort of hollowing tool on an end-grain piece, so you don't get the cyclical transition from end grain to side grain, etc... I also find that harder, finer grain woods like Sugar Maple or Beech scrape better than softer, more open woods like Butternut.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

#4

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

JamieDonaldson

>Ed-I don't know what Sorby recommends for sharpening, but I have found over the years that a grind angle of about 60 degrees at the tip is the best cutting angle. The tip you show doesn't indicate the angle, but I recommend rounding the point into more of a semi-circle. I have posted a view of some of my hollowing tools, and as a student of David Ellsworth's long ago I still follow his procedures in my own toolmaking and sharpening because they work!


img

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

#5

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

RK in Milw

>Carole's is on the right track. You should never,never,ever have the curved part of the tool on the tool rest. Only the stright part should be on the tool rest. Otherwise the tool will whip around inside of the vessel once you get inside. This means that the tool rest will be a good distance from your turning at first.

I found these tools to be easier to use if the cutter bit is as sharp as possible, but you have to go in with a light touch at first. The cutter is very efficient. I sharpen the cutter at the same angle as a scraper, which is essentially what it is.

As Carole mentioned, Sorby's method of sharpening is not very good. I made a bit holder out of 1/2" square bar stock to hold the bits which I sharpen on a Tormek.

In the beginning, use the tool to hollow out a bowl. This will help you get a good feel for the tool while you can see what you are doing..

Holler if you need more info.

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

#6

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

Ed Kelle

>Nope, its definitely not just you. Their "instructions" leave quite a bit to be desired. Guess my first project with that tool was just blind luck, cause I seem to be getting worse with it.

I will try to regrind it a bit and see what happens. Grinding it is just as much "fun" as trying to use the tool ;)

Enjoy your new lathe, I'm getting jealous

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

#7

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

Ed Kelle

>Thanks, and I'm hollering! Could you show a pic of that holder you made?

Actually I am working on more a bowl with the tool so I can see what I am doing. I see it bouncing all over. Even with nice light touches. Got the straight part on the rest with a few inches overhanging... I'm wondering if I have the cutter itself turned at too much of an angle to the tool. Do you try to keep it in line with the flowing curve of the tool itself?

Here is the bowl I am working on, maybe this will show what I am doing wrong


img

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

#8

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

Ed Kelle

>Higher than the center? really, I will try that. I think one of the problems with this tool is that the end where the cutter goes has a lot of stock which has seemed to hit the top inside curve of my turnings, preventing the cutter from contacting. I might grind a little off it to see if that helps as well. Thanks

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

#9

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

Ed Kelle

>I'm not sure of the angle, I just tried to keep it as it came. Yes I did round the tip a bit as well but I will try to round it even more.

I've been thinking about getting Davids tools, I have a friend who hasthem and showed me those home made long handles to use with them. do you just sharpen them on a grinder or do you use another method? thanks

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

#10

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

Carole in VA

>Can't really tell from the pic, Ed, but it looks like your toolrest is a little low. I use mine like a scraper (which it is) cuttin edge on the center line but with the toolrest high enough that the tool is angled down slightly.

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

#11

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

Phil Joines Krum, Texas

>I always sharpen those type of cutters on the sides using a diamond hone.

One reason to have the cutter above center in hollowing is so that a catch, even a small one, will tend to move the cutter away from the wood rather than in to it. It's the opposite from turning on the outside.

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

#12

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

RK in Milw

>The bit holder for sharpening is attached. 1/2" Square bar stock. 9/32" drill about 1/2" deep from the end for the bit. Drill and tap top for 1/4-20 set screw.

Your cutter bit is on the wrong side of the tool and so it is not on the centerline. Move your tool rest back even more. See the 3 photos that follow for tool and bit positioning. Note that cutting should be done off the tip only. Hope this helps.


img

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

#13

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

RK in Milw

>Pic One


img

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

#14

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

RK in Milw

>Pic Two


img

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

#15

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

RK in Milw

>Pic three


img

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

#16

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

Mac

>Ed, You might try shortening the amount of cutter exposed also.You only need enough to clear the bar,any more and you are throwing the whole thing out of balance.The further out the cutter sticks,to the side,the further it is beyond center.Once you get the hang of it, its a great tool.Also,its only meant to be used up to about 8" deep.Take care...

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

#17

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

Ed Kelle

>RK

Thanks a bunch for all those photos. They are a big help. I'll try to build a holder like yours, it will be much easier than trying to swing the tool on the grinder. I'm going to switch the cutter to the side you suggest. Thanks

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

#18

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

Ed Kelle

>Thanks. I will shorten it up a bit. At least this piece is a throwaway so I can try to experiment with the tool as much as I like

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

#19

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

Ed Kelle

>Thanks, I will try slightly above center. But do I keep the tool itself level or slightly angled down even though it is above center?

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

#20

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

Ed Kelle

>More than likely it is a little low. I will try raising it a bit. Thanks!

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

#21

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

Phil Joines Krum, Texas

>Keep it tilted down.

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

#22

Re:Grinding hollowing HSS tips

JamieDonaldson

>I made a special bit holder to grind 3/16"HSS and a number of other special gadgets which turned sharpening into a drawn out chore. While taking an Ellsworth workshop, David revealed the no hassle secret sharpening trick- DUH!! Slightly round the edges of your regular 60 grit AO grinder wheel with a dresser, then simply lay the tool (with bit installed!) on the grinder rest at whatever angle you prefer. Sharpen the L side to tip of the cutter by moving slightly back and forth on the rounded R edge of the wheel, then switch sides! The flat center of the wheel is not used at all- so quick and easy that you're back to the lathe with a fresh cutting edge in seconds!

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

#23

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

Ron in Drums PA

>I have this tool. It is not one of my favorites.

When I first used it, I practiced on a open bowl so I could see what I was doing.

I use this tool with the tip slightly above center, with the flat on the tool rest, and the handle slightly higher than the tip.

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

#24

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

Vicmarc.fan

>Any chance of a picture of the jig?

Ron

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

#25

Re: Need help with Sorby Hollomaster

Craig Daymon

>One of the instructional (and FREE) video CDs from Sorby might help. I think it is the first one on 'Specialty Turning Tools' that features the Hollowmaster. It is also the best of the 3 CDs avaiable (personal opinion). Though when you ask Sorby, you might as well ask for all 3. They play on your computer, I don't think they'll play on a DVD player.

-Craig