We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>Depending on what actions I've taken during my photo editing, the software I'm using (Gimp - photoshop open source clone) will either want me to Export the image before saving as a .jpg or flatten the image. Obviously there are multiple layers involved with flatten, but I can't figure out why I'd need to export something I'm working on. I don't generally use transparency filters. When it prompts me to "export" or "cancel" I usually go back and choose flatten, but for no other reason than that is what I'm familiar with.
>Whichever one of you suggested I move from aperature priority mode to fully manual mode is a genius! WAY better photos coming off of my memory card since taking you up on that suggestion. Thanks!
I don't really get the exposure compensation setting though, it seems to make no difference in the photo cube.
>Mike The exposure compensation should give you some overand or under exsposure depending on how you had it set. However you may not notice the difference once you start changing it in Gimp or whatever your using. If you went to extremes with it then you might have some shadow detail with noise or some loss of highlight detail but most of your photos don't have extremes in either of those ends.
I'm a manual mode fanatic. I just think I can control everything so much better.
I'm personally not familiar with Gimp although I did try it out a few years back.
In the same situation (saving a layered image to JPG or other nonlayered format), Instead of "Save", Photoshop requires you use the "Save As" command and save as a copy, assuming you will save as a PSD later if you want to keep the layers. (It does this in a somewhat annoying fashion, puting the word "copy" in the file name, but I digress.) It has to flatten to save, but it does that automatically without bothering you. The flattening done nondestructively behind the scenes, i.e., the image in your workspace is not flattened, just the copy being saved.
It sounds like Gimp might actually have to flatten the image in your workspace before saving. I can see why they might do this, from a programmers viewpoint, since it could simplify memory management, but it would not be as useful to the user as the PS method.
If the Gimp Export command saves the file in a native format or some layered format, the only think I can imaging is they are making an attempt to preventing you from accidentally losing the work in any layers. If so, it seems poorly thought out. Can you save the file first in a native for other format, before saving the JPG.
MOST software will do the JPG compression as part of the save and not mess with the data in the workspace. This lets you save the image with a variety of options (for example, different JPG compression levels or as a TIFF) with no further degredation of the image. The image will only suffer from compresion when it is loaded from a JPG file. What worries me a tiny bit is if Gimp is not handling this correctly, the image could suffer. Do the docs or your experience prove this something not to worry about? (A simple test would be to save a very small JPG with the worst possible quality, then immediately save it again as the highest quality and examine the differences in the files.)
I think you once posted a link to a free Gimp download. Do you still have this handy? I'd like to install it and see about this myself. It would be good to know what it will do and I'm interested in seeing just how it compares to Photoshop.
>Mike -this subject matter requires manual control for optimum results. The exposure compensation would be another step up in guality control, whether on manual or auto. Have you tried locking exposure taken from an 18% gray card, then adjusting for reflectance of subject. This is a priority for understanding and using Ansel Adams Zone System, giving the shooter greater control over the shortcomings of a dumb machine!
>Paul Automatic mode is best described as an average mode. If you want average photos that's what you use. I prefer to have control of the camera functions. I want enough depth of field to make the piece completely sharp. Therefore I select an F stop that will give me enough depth of field to get there. This may require a long shutter speed so I select that and use a tripod.
Now focus is really critical for maximum sharpness. I focus 1/3 of the way through the piece. The auto focus rarely does this. Then I take a meter reading of a Kodak Gray card. When I remove the gray card the meter almost always changes. The gray card reading is usually closer to correct. If I was using automatic settings the camera would set the exposure incorrectly.
If you have a digital camera and it has a histogram you can adjust the exposure so the histogram doesn't have any information outside the boundaries or if you have a gray card you adjust the exposure so a shot of the gray card will be dead center in the histogram.
That's roughly the steps I might go through when shooting and using manual settings lets m have control of what I'm doing, not the camera.
>...we were trained that way! Every good shooter had a Zone dial on their meter and a gray card in the bag-right??!! The basic knowledge of how a light meter operates and is calibrated means a LOT to any serious photographer, and its almost like a big secret today!
>Thanks John, I have been shooting in aperture priority, manual focus with a Canon Digital Rebel. I'll try the manual mode next time I shoot photos of my work.