We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I've been experimenting again. On my last few spoons I've used Minwax Wipe On Poly (yes I know it is just thinned down regl'r old Poly). I use a sanding sealer and then maybe 6 or 7 coats of wipe on. After the 3rd coat I knock it down with 4/0 wool, then continue till I'm pleased with the build.
I let it sit for a couple of weeks. After that I sand it with abralon, 500, 1000, 2000, 4000, then buff it on all 3 wheels.
The gloss is absolutely amazing. Stunning, completely free from sanding scratches. Gorgeous, proud to have achieved finish right from a wipe on can.
Why can I not achieve this same end result with lacquer without tons more work, expensive spray guns, even more sanding, and buffing? It takes me exponentially more work to get to the same point with lacquer and I grew up in an auto body shop. I've wrapped more power cords up in buffers than I care to recall.
The most amazing thing is complete lack of visible scratch marks. Why? Is the poly softer than the lacquer? Buffing and sanding out more easily?
What are your thoughts on the use of poly vs. lacquer? From what I'm seeing, I may have found a new finishing regimen.
I have become a big fan of Abralon recently too. I have been using it in in parallel with some MM and the finishes I am getting now are my best ever!
Keep it Simple and then it's not only repeatable, but not a chore either.
By the way, the Minwax wipe on poly got top ratings in the FFW survey not long ago. I do make my own home made wipe on though...and it's pretty good if I do say so myself.
>Frankly , being gassed one too many times with lacquer and the body can't handle it anymore. Being able to suck in air is partical to the lungs...They like air... Poly, waxes, or Hippo varnish is grand with me...Cheers Kevin T
>Got the receipe(sp??) Willing to share it? but don't use brand names please, as here in the UK many are not obtainable. So just generic names and quantities please. Many thanks!!
There are 2 short answers to your question...... surface build and hardness.
There are more solids in the poly finish than the lacquer and they build up faster. Given enough coats, you can get to the same film thickness with lacquer. You can get a coating thickness with 3 or 4 coats of the wipe-on Poly that would take 27 to get with a lacquer.
The poly resins form a suface film that is harder than the lacquer. On a scale of 0 to 10, with 0 being nothing and ceramic being a 10, lacquer is somewhere around a 5 and the polyurethane resins are a 7.5. (We could argue the exact numbers, but their relative ranking would be the same.) That surface hardness equates to being able to put a higher shine on the top surface.
However, there are some negatives to using the Poly. One is that it will turn very "Orange" with age, while there are lacquers available that will remain clear as they age (Deft is not one of them).
Another is the difference in the finishes. Lacquer is a solvent finish, and the Poly is a thinned finish that is impervious to almost everything, even itself and its own thinners. The bond between coats of the Poly is strictly a mechanical one, while the thinners in subsequent coats of lacquer will soften the finish alread there and form a single thicker film. This layed finish with the Poly creates both application and long term endurance problems. Abrading the surface is an absolute necessity when applying multiple coats of Poly because the only bond between coats is a mechanical one, and mechanical bonds are always more difficult to achieve on a harder surface. Long term, there is always the possibility of separation between the layers in the film from the reaction to heat, light, and atmosphere as it ages.
There are 3 attributes to a clear gloss finish - surface gloss, brilliance, and depth. A Poly finish of the same thickness will never achieve the brilliance and depth a polished lacquer. Brilliance is a matter of clarity; and depth is the difference between several reflective layers and one single film. This will give the lacquer more depth and brilliance than we could ever get with a Poly finish.
Being the harder finish, there is also a greater possibility of surface cracks in the Poly because of differences in expansion between the wood and the surface coating. The problem of brittleness with aging can be resolved by adding plasticizers to the lacquer, and there are lacquers available where this has been done for us. I don't know of an easy way to plasticize a poly finish, and none of the manufacturers are doing it for us.
Lastly there is the "feel" and appearance of the finishes. A Poly coating will forever and always make the wood appear that it is encapsulated in plastic, and have the cold feeling of a plastic. The clarity of a proper lacquer finish will not have the appearance of plastic, and it softer surface will have a warmer "feel" to it.
In the end, these finishes are as different as apples and cucumbers, a greater difference than between apples and oranges. They both have their problems and attributes. The resistance to all solvents and acids, and its hardness and resistance to abrasion will always make the Poly the preferred finish for a table top or things that will be handled and abused. The brilliance and depth, and warmer feeling of the lacquer, will always be the better finish for the piece of wood that invites us to pick it up to caress its surface and form.
>Russ, that was excellent information, as always, and thanks. However, I might not have been clear in my initial post, but the main thing I was curious about is why I am able, with a notable decrease in effort level, to create a glossy, defect free surface gloss that is extremely difficult to achieve with lacquer.
I've been staring at my best lacquer jobs and my simple poly jobs and the surface of the poly work is definitely superior, using the same tools and techniques that I've used for many years to finish automotive and marine paintwork.
Now I learn that poly has a harder surface than lacquer, which shoots my reasoning to hell. I figured it was going to be softer which allowed the buffing compound to do its job more easily. Now I don't know what to think.
>Mike and Russ I haven't played with Poly in a good while but I remember it being blue as compared to a lacquer or shellac finish. The last project I did with it was a dining table out of Walnut. I brushed the finish on so obviously it built up in just 3 or 4 coats. I did find that I had to wait at least a week between coats to be able to sand it affectively as it would just sort of roll off little balls and quit sanding if it wasn't completely cured. It did buff up really well using pumice and rhotenstone after I gave it a few weeds to cure. I'll be interested in playing with Mikes technique but I'm starting to prefer a more satin and natural look to the wood.
>John, the poly I used when poured into a cup is clear. I have to admit, it does give the look of being encapsulated in plastic, but the gloss is really eye catching.
My finishes have also turned to satin/low sheen on most of my items lately as well. Must be a trend. I don't believe I would finish a bowl or platter this way - but maybe a platter.
However, I can't help but notice that the spoons I make definitely have more eye catching appeal when they're glossy. I do think they'll sell better this way. Will see.
David Marks had some turned pieces with an incredible gloss finish over wood and gold leaf. The finish looked deep and transparent and flawless. I asked him what he uses and he took me to the shelf at Woodcraft and picked up a can of General Finishes "Seal-A-Cell Clear" and a can of their "Arm-R-Seal Oil and Urethane Topcoat", Gloss. I don't know what's in it and don't know if he uses it for everything, but that's what he told me to use.
I don't like gloss for everything but I do for some. I bought some of the General Finishes and plan on trying it the next time.
Well, many of the names here in Canada are not the same as in the United States either, so the UK may be in the same boat.
I use essentially a 1/3 boiled linseed oil, 1/3 oil based gloss poly and 1/3 mineral spirits finish. I start with a new empty paint can and blend in 1 litre of each to make my host batch.
When ever I use it I extract what I need for that application from the host batch to an empty container, usually a 500 ml plastic margarine container. Depending on where I am in the finishing process I apply as I like.
If it's a first coat of application I add about 20% more mineral spirits to the working solution. This first coat is a foundation coat anyway and I like to get down at least one thin coat or two before I start to work on building Up the finish coats.
After the foundation coat(s) have cured out I then build up the top coats with the host concentration. I some times add in two or more coats, then I rub out the finish.
I always use a secondary container from my host container to avoid contamination of the initial blend. I always use gloss poly as I have been told it produces a harder finish. I make sure to shake up the solution before dispensing to make sure the mix is homogenous. Dispose of the oily rags with care.
Depending on the finish I want I either use 4x0 steel wool for a satin look or sand with abralon or micromesh and Beall to achieve a finish I like.
I use this mostly on my furniture work, but recently started to use it on my turning work as well.
>Where do y'all buy these pads? I haven't done much looking other than local suppliers, but they sound like an interesting material for the occasional rubbed out finishing.