We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I spent the day in Vail Colorado earlier this week, and visited several high-end stores who carry glass and wood art. There was one store in particular that caught my interest, and seemed to be just the kind of place where my turnings would fit in...loads of very nicely turned wood boxes and vessels, jewelry boxes and blown glass. Asked the shop manager if they would be interested in a wholesale or consignment arrangement, offering him my product brochure...his reply: "No thanks; we get all our goods from Asia much cheaper than we can here in the USA."
On closer inspection of this shop's goods, virtually every piece was marked "made in Taiwan, China, Thailand, etc...", all fairly high quality, attractively designed and high priced. This shop's mark-up could easily have been 6 to 10 times the Asian wholesale price. Looks like there is a move by some "galleries" to improve their margins by importing all of their "art". And perhaps more important, the quality of this "art" is getting pretty good.
If this small sample is indicative of the rest of the country, my thinking is that the Wall Mart model is spreading to smaller scale retail markets, and may some day put all but the very best crafts-people out of business. What do you think?
I agree that is probably what is going to happen.....our worst enemy China is swallowing up everything and we are going to wake up someday and find that they have taken our place as the world leader in industry, art, military might and everything else you can think of thanks to our government leaders for the past 20 or more years. It is going to be the 2nd big Al Queda surprise.
What do I think? I think there will always be a market for the things we make. We may have to search for it, and work for it, but it is there. I started my woodworking business over 12 years ago making custom furniture. In 1993 I bought a lathe to turn table legs and chair legs. I did not turn a single table leg until 1999 when I was on my seventh lathe and third shop! I took a detour or two, and was one of the first five people on the internet selling wood pens. Now look how many are selling them! I don't do pens anymore, but I am in a bigger shop and doing custom work again.
The market is always in flux, and we need to fluctuate with it. Right now teaching and custom work are bringing in more money than turnings sold at shows and other venues. Craft show sales around here seem to be in a slump going by what others are telling me plus my own experiences. But repair jobs are also picking up, but I am sure that the turning market will come back at some point.
I got a call from a gallery owner yesterday that confines her purchases to local "artists", local being defined as an area roughly 60 miles long and 30 miles wide. She wants to check out my furniture. She doesn't even really know that I do turnings yet, but will as soon as she gets to my web page.
All this is a long winded way of sayng that if we are going to make money at doing this stuff, we need to be flexible and adaptable. We need to stay ahead of the curve, and that takes some work. It reminds me of the artists who complain of others copying their work instead of developing new things. There is always going to be someone copying what others are doing, whether it is a local person with no imagination of their own or the People's Republic of China (who seem to have no imagination of their own either). The best way to survive is to innovate and adapt.
As I read back over this it rambles a little, but all the essentials are here. It was a long but enjoyable day in front of the lathe.
The Rosen Group is trying to combat this. They ONLY showcase American or Canadian artists. They are trying to elevate the American Craft movement and combat the influx of imported low priced items. My advice is to tell people how this gallery hurts American artists and have the last thing that gallery sees of you is your back!
George
P.S. I highly reccomend their forum for craft artists.
>Sounds like a Lou Dobbs ( CNN),kinda story. I'm not even thinking of adding the usual for laugh out loud ...That really stinks.. Same here in Canada..We loss out via the NAFT thingy all the time.. But its the politicans that steal us blind and when they get caught, they get house arrest....If you or I stoled millions( 300-$400) I'm sure we wouldn't stay at home....
>well I think not all craftmans are alike no? IO have my turnings copied all the time, by peruvians and taiwan guys ,just today I got nearly 30 from taiwan in my web page each for nearly one hour each and they do not are there to buy anything just to copy something in there I know I had big trouble with them here in peru ,here there is no copyrigths or anything like that everybody steal from everybody,even a jean co.like levis could not do anything,down here
but to segregate turners (the real ones )I think is wrong
>I have to comment on the comments about copying...
It's been a loooong time since somebody built the first table and chairs...or used a rock to hollow out a chunk of wood. I'll go out on a limb and suggest it'd be near impossible to do anything 'original' today.
>The gallery owner is in business to make a profit. If s/he can make more profit selling items from Asia that's the way it's going to be. Let's face it, if I can sell a widget made in the USA and make 20% profit or sell the same thing or better made in Asia for 100% profit, it's a no brainer. Like it or not, the business world is shifting to a world market and we, as artists/craftspeople are not going to change that. Even Wal-Mart used to promote their business as made in America, but no more. While there will always be "niche" galleries only selling items made in a certain area or country, the majority are going to go where the profit is. That's not right or wrong, it simple is.
I believe if we are going to sell as artists, then country will be irrelevant. But our products will have to truly be art...not just one more beautiful bowl or vessel...and be able to compete for sales with other art from all over the world. Juergen really nailed it...we from the US are certainly not the only artists in the world.
I have always maintained that selling woodturning has nothing to do with art...it has to do with marketing. Let's face it, most galleries do not sell original art...you see the same stuff in gallery after gallery. That is especially true in jewelery, wood, pottery, textile, basketry, etc. So, to answer Ed's question: "Yes, the arts and crafts market is changing. The owners are waking up to how they can make more profit and actually stay in business (which the big majority fail to do) by selling products from all over the world."
>I am given to understand that approximately 35% of the exports coming from China alone are actually U.S. companies who have moved their production to China to avoid taxes and regulations in the U.S.
Along with this obvious lack of ethics and morals they have also taken the jobs away from U.S. citizens and hence huge amounts of disposable income.
It's not just the U.S. that is getting a whuppin it's Canada, Great Britain the the E.U..
I am not suggesting isolationism but realistic tariffs on good coming in from non compliant, "greenhouse gas" emitting countries would be in order.
We could all make a conscious effort to detach ourselves from fossil fuel gas guzzlers and direct that surplus energy into production instead of a vulgar display of opulence.
Eventually, the disposable incomes should rise and the crafts heritage could return.
In the meantime hang on to you hat and don't expect to make a living competeint against a 24hr/365day non union, non social benifit communist country.
>We're seeing U.S. companies and the U.S. government trying to compensate for a big economic mistake made in the late '80s and early '90s: the failure to open up the Japanese market in particular, and to a somewhat lesser extent Europe's market, to American exports. This created problems for U.S. companies that if you are going to try to maintain an open world trading system, which was the goal of the U.S. government, U.S. companies had to find a cost advantage somehow to compete against the Japanese and Europeans. And the way that they did [that] was they went to Mexico, and they went to China. So it's critically important to understand, they didn't go to Mexico and China to serve those markets. They went to Mexico and China to try to hang on to their markets in the United States.
Why China? ...
China provides multinational companies with enormous advantages over industrialized countries as a manufacturing base. It's got a very large pool of very cheap workers. It also has a very large pool of very smart folks who can easily be trained and who work hard. In addition, China has no labor unions. There are no labor rights in China, so that when Chinese workers have problems, they have no option of going to management or going to their union to get help. ... China also has an enormous unemployment rate, so there is a big surplus of labor in China, and that alone keeps workers well-behaved because everybody is afraid of losing their job.
And the Chinese government has also provided many incentives for foreign multinational companies to come to manufacture in China. Many business costs are very lavishly subsidized. Land costs are very lavishly subsidized. Taxes are very light or nonexistent. Fuel costs, which are a big problem for U.S.-based manufacturers now because oil prices and gas prices have been rising so steeply lately, these are largely subsidized in China, so the manufacturers don't have to pay them at all.
So China has used its own government and government policy to lure manufacturers from all over the world to China on top of these natural advantages that it enjoys from its enormous population and its huge glut of workers.
>The galleries I sell to use local artists. There is no import stuff. If you are selective you too can make it happen. Galleries have a tough time making a living. They are many business factors out of their control. For me, I try my best to purchase tools and equipment that is not made in Tiawan or China. Women are my best customers without them I think we would all be in trouble when it comes to selling woodturned items.
>If and how much the market is changing depends on what market we are selling in. I see there being 6 markets where I can sell turned wood: art, craft and gifts, wholesale, architectural, furniture, and specialty items.
These markets will always vary with changes in the local and national economy, the price of gasoline, the stock market, the phase of the moon, personal preference and how much competition there is in that market. And some of these markets are more sensitive to these factors than others.
The "art market" is for those things that sell for $300 or more. That market is always there because the people with money will always have money. The only thing that changes here is personal taste and preference.
The "craft" market is for those items that sell for less than $100. This one is suffering right now because of economic pressures. I can always judge this one by the price of gasoline and what I see on the TV News. This is not a good time to be selling anything at a craft show.
I have always found those items that are priced between $100 and $300 to be difficult to sell. They are too expensive for the "craft market" and not expensive enough for the "art market". Yet, this is where the majority of woodturners are trying to sell.
The "wholesale" market is the realm of the production turner who sells pens, bottle stoppers, boxes, and other gift items in quantity to retail stores at a 50-60% discount from retail prices. This is the market that has disappeared to foreign imports. Personally, I don't see this as a great loss because this has always been a difficult market to serve while trying to make a profit. You have to be very good and very fast at the lathe to meet the demands of the wholesale market, and I have never been able to do both at the same time.
All of these markets are sensitive to competition from other woodturners. There was a time when I had the only turned wood at an art fair or craft show. Now there are usually 5 or 6 who are selling similar things, and often at lower prices. This has definitely hurt the craft item ($100 or less) sales enough that I no longer try to sell these things.
The "art market" (over $300) is less sensitive to the numbers of woodturners because "quality sells" to the buyers in this market. If I can keep my quality better than the competition, I will always be able to sell more items and at higher prices. The only difference is that I have to work harder to do it.
The "architectural market" is the home and building construction and restoration. This market is always there, and it seems to be immune to the factors that change other markets. There is never any competition because woodturners as a group don't want to turn spindles. As the numbers of woodturners has multiplied several hundred fold over the years, the number of those who do architectural work has not changed.
The "furniture market" is that of restoration. Floods are the woodturners best friend in this market because standing water makes for a lot of table and piano legs that need replacement.
The "specialty" market are the presentation platters, pens, bowls, etc.; or the turned piece of historical wood for a public institution. Engraving or carving are often required. This is often where we have to create a market where none existed. An example would be the bowl from the historical tree that was removed for the new Library addition, or something of historical value for the art displayed in government buildings.
That is how I see the changing market. The changes depend on where we are and what we want to pursue. Others will see it different.
>Hi Bob, this is off topic, but the big corporations are setting our national agenda...our goods are produced in China, who is loaning the US funds to stay afloat. There is a HUGE conflict of interest here. The end result is the rich will become incredibly rich, while the rest sink deeper into poverty...as our national soverignty is compromised.
>Funny, when I look around this country I see the "poor" with one or two cars, two TVs, free medical care, food stamps or help from both government and private charities, who live better than the middle class in two thirds of the countries of the world. When I look at those countries which have no significant income spread between its citizens I find that the poor are living in squalor, never have sufficient food, have never seen a doctor or dentist, own only the rags on their backs. For us to have any kind of a life there must be some wealth in the country. The government produces no wealth' it only takes it from thse who create it. The rich in this country are wealthy because they produce the wealth, and someone has to do that if the poor are going to be taken care of.