Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Catches

Posts

Catches

#1

Catches

DD

>I was attemting to clean up the inside sides of a vase (vase was about 5" in dia, 8" high, with a wall thickness of about 1/4" with fairly straight walls), using the side bevel of my bowl gouge. Wood was box elder (or Manitoba maple, as I know it). The gouge has something like an "Ellsworth: profile to it. I was pulling the gouge out towards me cutting with the side bevel (very fine but broad cuts) when I had a horrendous catch, just before the lip of the vase. Pulled the gouge out of my hand and ruined the piece. The tool rest I was using was one of the Robert Sorby rectangular plates that gets inserted into the hollowed out piece to reduce the amount of overhang the tool has when trying cut the inside of a vase, box, etc.

I was definitely rubbing the bevel, but given the force of the catch, it's pretty clear I was doing something wrong and potentially unsafe. Cutting with the side bevel to me is somewhat tricky, but I was surprised at the forces generated by the catch. How should one use a tool rest in conjunction with a bowl gouge side bevel cut?

I was trying this type of cut because when trying to use my scrapers, the finish was quite poor and rough. I was one my final cut when - BANG. I am sure there are many lessons to be learned here, but need some help in making sure I identify the right ones. Any advice appreciated.

Doug D

Re: Catches

#2

Re: Catches

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Hi Doug,

If I'm understanding what you were doing, I think you were cleaning up the inside of the vase with a bowl gouge, on a flat box making tool rest, and using the side of the gouge, with the flute up? I think this is what you described? Forme this would be a catch everytime. I have a feeling that the tool rest didn't help either. When you got the catch the tool rest didn't allow the the tool to go anywhere, so it was an even more violent catch and I have a feeling the piec was ruined.

Everybody has their own way of doing different tasks when it comes to turning. When I clean up the inside of a small hollow like a vase or a box I choose a round nose scraper. I think it's much safer than using a bowl gouge. For the final pass I tilt the scraper on edge so that it's actually shear scraping the wood and it gives a cleaner, smoother final cut. It can be done with the bowl gouge but it's not the safest tool to use for this job. You would want to use it with the flute facing the side of the vase and touching only the upper cutting edge. In other words, using the gouge as a scraper of sorts. And very light contact. Your post said that you pulled the gouge out of your hand? Did it really puncture your hand? I hope you're okay.

I hope this helps a little.

Jennifer

Re: Catches

#3

Catches

Terry Quiram, Roanoke Illinois

>Doug

Your gouge against the vase walls produces harmonics. As you neared the outer edge the vibrations caused the gouge to catch. The thinner the wall the more vibrations. You didn't do anything wrong, its physics. Jennifers advise to use a scraper is right on.

Terry

Re: Catches

#4

Re: Catches

Rick Allen

>Hi Doug

You didn't mention if the wood was spindle orientation (endgrain) or face orientation.

If it was endgrain then a ring or hook tool is a good choice. You can also use a steady rest to help support the thin wood.

If it was face orientation then the side grain endgrain cutting has a different resistance to cutting and there is a difference in the flex of the wood. You could try a bowl steady but it is better to work in stages from the rim in. Maintain mass and support to finish all cuts before moving deeper into the piece.

Good Luck

Richard

Re: Catches

#5

Re: Catches

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Doug, I would like to understand what you were doing better as I'm not sure I understand your technique. It _sounds_ like you were flutes up, handle down, bevel rub, pulling out from the center. If this is correct - a catch was almost assured. I'd drop that habit like a hot potato. Just a little bit of bowl warp and BANG! OUCH! DAMN! Sounds like Jennifer is correct on the toolrest, too. When the flute got pulled down and into the work, the toolrest presented a very firm barrier, no "give" was available and the force went into the tool and the blank.

The thing that occurs to me first is that when properly turned, no clean up is needed when you get to the bottom. The Ellsworth signature gouge video demonstrates the proper bevel rub interior cut that will allow you to progress from rim to the center with no tool marks remaining, and rarely any tear out that needs tending.

Worked the day Ellsworth demonstrates, the left tip of the gouge comes into contact with the work and just a tiny bit of bevel rubs, but enough to provide support, control, and a clean cut. If much more of the bevel is allowed to rub, the workpiece invariably vibrates and produces a less than desirable surface. This can be mitigated somewhat by use of a bowl steady. Work the surface down from the rim about an inch or so at a time, and then never go back over it again, as it has invariably warped just a tiny bit, but enough that any further attempts at toolwork will be frustrating and unrewarding. Flutes up on the interior is somewhat precarious work, but it can be done safely.

By taking care to learn David's techniques well, you can get to the point where you almost never need to clean up the inside of a bowl with a scraper or other tool. I would suggest that you rent or buy his video from one of the turning catalogs. I've never seen him demonstrate any sort of a pull cut on the interior with that gouge profile.

Hope this helps some.

Re: Catches

#6

Re: Catches

Barry Irby

>I have used my Ellsworth gouge inside hollow forms to clean them up, but I turn the flute horizontal toward the surface I'm scraping and use it for a scraper. Since it almost fills the hole in the vessel, I cannot see exactly what it is doing, but I roll the flute to the front and tilt the tip down slightly.

On more open vessels or bowls I intend to sand, I finish up with one of the Sorby scrapers with the rounded cutter that is sort of tear shaped. I move the rest above center and tilt the tip down, turning he cutting edges nearly perpendicular to the rotation, sort of like a forward slash "/" if you get my drift. Seems to cut well and avoid violent catches if there are any at all. With the rest high and the tip down, cutting just above center, if it catches it kicks out into "air" rather than driving the tool into more wood.

I think your mistake was that you had the gouge so well supported that there was no place for it to go. The angle and contact area changes with the shape of the vessel. On the outside of a form, you are touch two convex surfaces together, but on the inside one is convex and one is concave. If the shape were just right, you could pull the gouge into a position where the majority of the cutting edge was cutting rather than just a small fraction. The rest prevented the gouge form kicking away. You might want to give some thought to exactly where the rest was. There may have been just en ugh space between the rest and the vessel for the gouge to jamb in there. That may be what dislodged the vessel.

I attended a seminar by Richard Raffan. He said you couldn't avoid catches until you understood them. He was doing spindles at the moment, but he demonstrated that he could make a catch over and over. Once you understand why it catches, you can avoid that.

You are doing the right thing to try to understand what went wrong, rather than just take another whack at it.

Re: Catches

#7

Brad Vietje

Re: Catches

Brad Vietje

>I agree with the advice given about gentle shear scraping with support to minimize vibration (I often use my left hand for this), and the idea that whenever possible, we'll get the best results from working the top down to final thickness, leaving additional mass for support toward the base, and working down in steps -- leaving each area alone once it is finished.

I'm left with a question about Jennifer's advice on shear scraping with the bowl gouge on its side, flute facing to the left ... When I do this, I try to get a little shear angle by lowering the handle a bit (can't do this well with a flat box rest), scraping a little above center on the inside, but I'm scraping with the lower edge, while the upper edge is opened up just a tiny bit -- less than 1/8", to just clear the spinning wood. Should I be using the upper edge for this ? That would be scraping with the ground/honed surface of the bevel, and not with the flute side, no? I've never tried that -- should I ?

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT

Re: Catches

#8

Re: Catches

Carole in VA

>I also scrape with the lower edge on the rare occasion that I use a gouge in there. Looks to me like you wouldn't get any cutting using the upper edge, but then I have not tried it.

Re: Catches

#9

Re: Catches

AndiWolfe

>You might have better results with a negative rake scraper. You can convert a half-round scraper by grinding a slight bevel on the top side of the scraper and then add the burr as you would normally do. The negative rake is much more forgiving on hard-to-reach surfaces such as the side wall of a vase. A bowl gouge with the flute up is definitely a bad idea for this type of cut.

Re: Catches

#10

Re: Catches

John Lucas

>I think Terry is right about the vibrations being the major cause. I would use the shear scraper method or a good round nose scraper. A negative rake scraper would be great. I support the outside with my fingers and turn the speed of the lathe down if necessary to keep from burning my fingers. I've watched some of the pro's who turn really thin, and they use this technique. One was turning Hat's and one was turning really thin lamp shades. They both used the shear scraper technique both pulling and pushing the gouge and supporting the outside with their fingers. This has also worked well for me on thin vessels.

Re: Catches

#11

Re: Catches

Russ Fairfield

>This is my opinion, for what it's worth. Others are free to disagree.

Brad is doing it the right way for using the gouge as a scraper on the inside of a tall open form or a box. The flute should be facing the wall of the vessel, and then rolled back just enough for the upper side to clear the wood. Keep that lower cutting side of the flute above center with the shank of the gouge slightly downhill. I define "Slightly" as just enough that you know for sure that it is pointed downhill. And, never use a support that will prevent the gouge from dropping down and rolling away from the wood if you get into trouble. That means, get rid of the boxmakers rest and use a conventional toolrest. This scraping cut is best done with a gouge that has a thinner angle between the inside wall of the flute and bevel than the 65-degree of the "Ellsworth" profile.

Riding the bevel on the inside of the vase or box is a finesse cut that should be left to the experts. It takes a lot of practice and a light touch. Again, the cut is best done slightly above center because this allows the tool to drop and roll away from the wood if there is a catch. Riding the bevel is best done on a tool with a heavy bevel angle like the 65-degree "Ellsworth" tool profile. It would be ideal if the tool were rolled while grinding to make the tool angle greater then 65-degrees, and 75 would be a good goal. If you can visualize the gweometry, you will see that the gouge is approaching the position of the scraping cut, as described above, while it is riding on the bevel. Making such a grind on the tool is one of the advantages of free-hand grinding.

I have no idea how to do the transition from the tip into the heavier 75-degree angle along the sides of the grind with any of the jigs. But, if you learn to grind it free-hand, and are willing to learn how to use it, you will be rewarded with finishes on the inside of a vase or box that look like they were made with a skew chisel. That is assuming that you have a wood that is cooperative.

Re: Catches

#12

Why tools catch

Bob Hackett

>As pointed out in a previous post once you understand what makes a tool or cut catch you will have far less of them.

Most(shear cutting) catches occur because the area of the tool which is cutting is not DIRECTLY supported.Catastrophic catches occur when the tool is pushed more deeply into the wood instead of being kicked out into the air.

It sounds as though you set yourself up by A-cutting too far back on the wing(a danger with a pulling cut) when the support was toward the center of the gouge(look at the gouge end on while on the rest to see what I mean)B-using the wrong tool rest and tool for the cut and C-returning to a thin,unsupported, and vibration prone wall at the end of the project.

You may find it worth your while to pick up all the pieces you can find and attempt to reconstruct what went wrong and why.Understanding what and why is the first step to not repeating the things that caused the piece to be ruined,a lesson I learned(and sometimes relearn) the hard way.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Catches

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: Catches

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Doug, lots of good advise here...here's my take on what happened. You were cutting with the flute down, and the long bevel against the wood. Too much of the edge contacted the wood; you are not strong enough to prevent the tool from being rotated right into the cut. I bet you were also cutting near the centerline....with all that support from the tool rest, the tool had nowhere to go but deeper into the cut. Also, the long side of the grind should curve inward, not be perpendicular. This makes the tool less likely to grab and catch.

I agree with Brad and Russ, that is the way I shear with the Ellsworth grind also, don't be afraid to turn the rpm down when you do this.

the Ellsworth grind is not the only tool! A conventional grind bowl gouge, with the flute facing away from the wood with the bevel rubbing is much easier to control, and will make a clean cut all the way to the bottom. It can also be rotated with the flute downward for an even finer, although more risky cut.

Re: Catches

#14

Re: Catches

DD

>Thanks for all of the feedback. As all of you have surmised, my technique didn't match the application and resulted in the catch. It was as Jennifer described it, almost to a "T". The piece is indeed ruined(unless I cut it down signficantly). The gouge ended up on the floor without even a blemish to its cutting surface. Can't say the same for the vase or my demeanor when it happened. Scared the living daylights out of me!

The catch occured at the lip of the vase. One can see where the cut (catch) into the lip started and then grew in depth and width to the point where the wood started to tear away. If one was to measure the complete event in terms of degrees of a cirle (representing the lip of vase), the catch started at 0 degrees, cut smoothly and progressively into the wood for another 160 degrees at which point the wood started to tear and finished about another 90 degrees later for a total of about 250 degrees, not even a full rotation of the vase.

The reason I was trying this cut was because my round nose scraper was leaving such a poor finish on the internal surface of the vase. I will definitely have to try some other techniques as everyone has described above and master those. Have trashed this technique, however for this application. Too scary!

Thanks again for all the feedback.

Doug