We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I am in need of some wood identification books. I have Bruce Hoadleys book on wood Identification but it is hard to use. What books do you guys and gals suggest. People assume that because I turn wood I know all the woods and I do a know a lot but over the years I've forgotten a lot and find myself either stumped or in doubt and need to verify the wood. I'd like to buy 2 or 3 books that will either make it easy of at least help me get close.
You are searching for the holy grail! I did the same thing and decided there is no easy solution. I have Hoadley's books and I also use "World Woods in Color" (Lincoln) and "The Woodbook" (Hough) and several web sites. (I have lots of links if you want them.) The Woodbook is nice since it has photos of slices of three different orientations - end grain, radial, and tangential, but it is a very old resource and doesn't have some woods commenly found today. (It's real expensive, too)
But unless you can get the leaves and perhaps the bark I think a positive ID is hopeless unless you use Hoadley's methods. I find the smell helps a lot since some woods have a distinctive smell regardless of their appearance, especially when green. I don't know of a "scratch-and-sniff" wood ID book, though!
I think the problem with all the resources that have photos of pieces of wood is the natural variation in the trees. Cut 10 slices from a yellow poplar tree and get 10 widely different views. Even with Hoadley's methods the natural variation makes things confusing. I use a 15/30 power binocular microscope and am amazed (and discouraged) by what I see, even with woods that I'm sure of the ID.
What I'm trying to do is collect samples of known woods as I come across them and try to learn as I go. I'll be watching this thread for other good ideas.
BTW, do you know that US citizens can get free professional wood ID on five samples per year as a public service? I haven't tried it. (Even they say they can generally ID only to the genus and not the species.)
>>You might try 'A Guide to Useful woods of the World'
From the sample pages, I like the looks of that book.
One thing mentioned on the "Sweet Birch" sample page brings up an interesting point about buying and identifying wood: "It is difficult to identify the specific species when confronted with the wood alone.... A lumber dealer may have between three and five different species combined in stacks labeled birch. It is essential when seeking a specific species of birch that it be identified before it is harvested." I ran into that when I took oak logs to the local large commercial sawmill. I was told they sell all oak as either "red" or "white".
>You guys think wood ID is confusing up there you should be here in the Amazon. As I see it several years ago everything was named and everyone was happy. THEN came the internet and everyone from all corners of the world started sharing information and as a result many woods had been named by a couple of dozen people in different locations. We have some species that in the USDA tropical ID info site have over 30 scientific names. We are now srarting a study on the species we have in cooperation with the USDA and the U of South Carolina sending them photos of leaves, bark etc. and sending samples for pore and chemical studies. In about 500 years we should be done. There is NOBODY in the world who is an expert in tropical woods. We just had three 20 foot shipping containers of turning blanks held up for two weeks by the USDA for species ID and the final result was $3000 plus in inspection fees and I finally sent them the scientific names I thought were correct as they did not know..
Internatiopnal wood ID database. Good for commercially traded woods if you can learn the anatomy of wood and use a hand lens and a microscope.
Normally you can't go beyond red or white in Oaks with a hand lens. The easiest is to ID while you still have leaves. Another problem with oaks is they hybridize so you can get charactoristics of either parent.
I had wood ID in a wood technology course in forestry school but I call them wrong all the time and am totally helpless with the tropicals.