Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Vote - platter - Circles vs Flowers

Posts

Vote - platter - Circles vs Flowers

#1

Vote - platter - Circles vs Flowers

Rick Allen

>Hi

These are a result of a recent collaboration I have had with Audra. I made the platters and she did the rim decoration (woodburning). The deal I have with her is that in this first collaboration with her I get to select the platter I keep and she gets the other platter.

I am having a difficult time selecting one over the other. If we call the platter on the left circles and the one on the right flowers which would select?

Thanks

Richard


img

Re: Vote - platter - Circles vs Flowers

#2

Re: Vote - platter - Circles vs Flowers

Les Robison

>I vote for "Circles" as I feel the design fits the look and feel of the plate (circular).

Les

Re: Vote - platter - Circles vs Flowers

#3

Re: Vote - platter - Circles vs Flowers

Randy G

>I agree... I like the circles better

Re: Vote - platter - Circles vs Flowers

#4

Flowers for me. Where do I send my platters.

Dave Smith, Longview, WA

>

Re: Vote - platter - Circles vs Flowers

#5

Flowers

Mike Schwing from Md.

>

Re: Vote - platter - Circles vs Flowers

#6

Circles

David Propst

>

Re: Vote - platter - Circles vs Flowers

#7

Flowers

Ed Karch in No.VA

>

Re: Vote - platter - Circles vs Flowers

#8

Brian McKearney

Re: Vote - platter - Circles vs Flowers

Brian McKearney

>Circles for me - flowers for my wife!

Brian

Re: Vote - platter - Circles vs Flowers

#9

Circles.....

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>I like them both.....but I think my favorite is the circles. Very nice!

Re: Vote - platter - Circles vs Flowers

#10

Circles

Chris Andrew

>I like the circles.

Nice work!

Re: Vote - platter - Circles vs Flowers

#11

Circles

Terry Quiram, Roanoke Illinois

>Circles has a more interesting grain pattern in the center. That the one I vote for.

Terry

Re: Vote - platter - Circles vs Flowers

#12

Re: Vote - platter - Circles vs Flowers

John K Jordan

>I like the flowers better. The circles are broken at the outer rim leading my eye right off the piece. This creates tension. They are bounded comfortably towards the inside by the bead. I think the circles would work better if they fit on a flat band bounded by a bead or raised rim also at the very outer edge.

The flowers guide my eye around and inwards (for the most part). The flower pattern also has more open space which I find pleasing while the circles look like they are trying to push and crowd each other out, creating more tension. Just MHO.

Looks like a beautiful soft satin finish. Makes me want to touch it.

JKJ in East TN

Re: Vote - platter - Circles vs Flowers

#13

Re: Vote - platter - Circles vs Flowers

Tom Mullane

>Flowers for me... just seems to feel right...

Re: Vote - platter - Circles vs Flowers

#14

Tension

Chris Andrew

>John hit on why I like the circles better -- there is a tension in the piece that is attractive. Thanks, John for putting words to what I was feeling.

Re: Vote - platter - Circles vs Flowers

#15

Re: Tension

John K Jordan

>>John hit on why I like the circles better --

>there is a tension in the piece that is attractive.

Isn't it wonderful that we all don't like the same things! Life would be so boring otherwise.

JKJ in East TN

Re: Vote - platter - Circles vs Flowers

#16

Re: Vote - platter - Circles vs Flowers

Rick Allen

>Thanks everyone.

It is nice to see that there isn't a clear winner.

I find myself looking at the circles platter more. It is hard for me to walk past that platter without looking back at it.

The flowers pattern is what drew me to collaborate with Audra in the first place.

I was attending a class in section 508 for the web and Audra was sitting next to me. I noticed at one point that she was doodling a wonderful swirl pattern on her paper. I instantly imagined what those swirls would look like on the rim of a platter.

Over the week it took me to sand and finish her work on that platter, the design really grew on me. Usualy my work holds less and less interest for me over time.

I am still not sure which platter I will keep. I don't think I can make a bad choice. I will have a platter that is a bit of me and a bit of Audra. I am going to keep the platter and I will smile each time I see it.

BTW I hope to do a second collaboration with Audra. She gets to select the "keeper" on the second collaboration.

Thanks

Richard

Re: Vote - platter - Circles vs Flowers

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: Vote - platter - Circles vs Flowers

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Rick...I like the circles, reminds me of end-grain logs. they are both nice!

Re: Vote - platter - Circles vs Flowers

#18

A true win-win situation.

Jack Savona

>

Re: Vote - platter - Circles vs Flowers

#19

Re: Vote - platter - Circles vs Flowers

GeeSeaWhy

>If you can't decide, why not let Audra pick? If it was me, I'd keep Circles. The tension John pointed out needs to be resolved in a follow-up piece. I'd want the original sitting there to push me into finishing the idea.

Graeme

Re: Vote - platter - Circles vs Flowers

#20

Flowers

Jay in TX

>Call me a sensitive kind of guy... Circles looks a little busy for my tastes, but well done none the less.