Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Alcohol drying of turning squares

Posts

Alcohol drying of turning squares

#1

Alcohol drying of turning squares

Royce Meritt

>I've read Dave Smith excellent article on alcohol drying. I'm ready to give it a try. I think I understand the procedure. However, Dave's article dealt specifically with drying rough turned bowls. I would like to try it with some small turning squares. Specifically, I will be making some duck calls. For those of you not familiar with the process, calls are turned in two pieces. Hole bored down throught the blank, mounted on a mandrel and turned, much like turning a pen.

My question...since Dave, in his article, recommends rough turning to shape, soaking in alcohol and wrapping the outside of the bowl in heavy paper, should I bore an undersized hole in my blank, wrap the outside and allow to dry that way. Or should I just soak the 2" X 2" X 6" blank and allow it to dry? Thanks.

Re: Alcohol drying of turning squares

#2

Don't have a lot of data but it works

Dave Smith, Longview, WA

>Hi Royce,

I have dried a large number of pen blanks and larger blanks by soaking in alcohol then sealing the ends with anchor seal or similar end grain sealer. Lay them on a rack or stand them on end with enough room for air circulation. Pen blanks, 3/4" to 1" square will usually be dry in 2 weeks. Drilling an undersized hole before soaking will help speed the drying. I would turn the outsides round after boring the hole to make the wall thickness uniform. I would expect that would make the drying stresses more uniform. Highly figured wood will distort but probably not enough to cause you a problem.

If you try drying 2" squares please share your results with us.

I have a lot of dry pieces of fruit woods that are about 2" square if you run into problems. Actually I have a variety of woods that would work for duck calls.

Dave Smith

Wondering if there is life after alcohol in Longview, WA.

Re: Alcohol drying of turning squares

#3

Re: Alcohol drying of turning squares

Carole in VA

>I think maybe if your bore an undersized hole before the drying process, you "may" have problem when you go to bore the full sized hole. It's hard to center a bit in a previously bored hole and even if it is centered, if the wood has warped at all, it may force the bit off center as you start to drill. Just a thought. A duck call blank should absorb the alcohol fine without the hole, just leave it in there for a day or so. Just my thoughts.

Re: Alcohol drying of turning squares

#4

Re: This works in steel, so I bet in wood also.

Al Crandall--NE of Indy--

>Drilling a hole in steel where there is already a hole which is off center is usually best accomplished by using a flat bottom drill or an end mill on a long shank. If you are trying to drill wood with an out-of-round hole already there, I'd give the flat bottom twist drill a chance to shine. Worth a shot, imho.

Re: Alcohol drying of turning squares

#5

Re: Don't have a lot of data but it works

Dave Anderson Chester,NH

>I posted a few weeks back about the problems I was having with Snakewood cracking on completed awls even after the finish was on them. About a week and a half ago I cut up a 1.5" x 1.5" square about 15" long into 3" lengths. I scraped off the parafin covering and they are currently submerged in alcohol. I figure because of their density I'll give them a total of 3 weeks soaking before beginning to dry them slowly wrapped in newspaper and a paper bag. I'll report on my results. While Snakewood is really beautiful, it is exceptionally unstable in larger sizes and frankly I'm not too hopeful that the alcohol technique will work.

Re: Alcohol drying of turning squares

#6

Do A Search...

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I made a post last spring about the results I had with drying some 3" diameter x 28" (more or less) pieces of walnut for rolling pins. It worked great. I have turned the pins and they are ready for the customer.

Re: Alcohol drying of turning squares

#7

Mills work real well

Fred in NC

>Milling bits work real well for truing out holes. The thing is that they are usually too short, especially the double ended ones. Longer mill bits can be bought from most machine shop suppliers, like Enco, McMaster, etc.

Re: Alcohol drying of turning squares

#8

Hmmmm

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I did a search on my posts and I do not find the one about the walnut. Dave, did I send you the information?

I do have it charted and saved if anyone is interested.

Re: Alcohol drying of turning squares

#9

Ahhhh...It is in the Turning Archives

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: Alcohol drying of turning squares

#10

I'm still a skeptic *LINK*

John K Jordan

>But an open-minded skeptic.

My experience with small turning blanks: I tried alcohol drying on a number of 3/4" to 1" spindle blanks of red oak, some if it burl. Red oak has large unblocked pores (almost like soda straws) so it seems ideal for alcohol penetration. I soaked for a week with periodic agitation then air dried for months. I saw no difference between those alcohol-soaked and those in the control group that had no alcohol. Most warped badly and none cracked or checked. All (both alcohol and non-alcohol) had similar moisture content afterward as measured by a pinless meter.

I wonder if reported successes with alcohol drying depend on both the geometry and the type of wood. Perhaps there is room for more testing.

I see many people claim alcohol works well for them, i.e, their roughed bowls did not crack and warp badly. But are they testing with proper controls to prove that the benefit is from the alcohol and not just the procedure, i.e., wrapping the outside with paper? Would some other procedure, such as simply anchor-sealing the outside, have worked just as well on THOSE pieces?

It proves nothing to have success with a bowl or even a series or batch unless a similar parallel batch without alcohol fails under the same conditions and treatment. And due to the nature of wood, having wide variations within even the same blank, a large sample size also seems important.

Due to the structure of the wood cells, I am also convinced alcohol cannot penetrate very deeply into the wood and even if it did, that deep in the pores of the wood would be quickly saturated with water. However, even with agitation there is no transfer mechanism to get the water-saturated alcohol quickly out to the surface and replace it with fresh alcohol. It seems to me then, that any benefit is bound to be from very shallow surface effects, perhaps tensioning of the inside vs. the outside. I hope someday do careful tests with similar control pieces cut from adjacent wood with a variety of geometries - alcohol vs. anchor seal vs. boiling vs. microwave, etc.

BTW, I received this from someone who has done some tests: "Having done the sg and penetration tests, I can tell you that soaks of 24 hour duration will take a long time to dilute, because the unbound water mixes extremely slowly, and the bound water, that which makes a difference - never." The writer recommends the link below for a description of how alcohols are, in his words, "actually used to remove or remove/replace unbound and free water. Note, the material must still be dried after the soak is complete." The link concerns preserving waterlogged wood, but the information may still be useful. The issue of bound vs. unbound water within wood cells can be examined in Bruce Hoadley's books.

-----------------

If you do use alcohol drying, please try similar pieces with and without alcohol at the same time and let us know the final results.

One thing I did recently that dried small turning squares quickly and successfully - microwave drying. Heat the wood just long enough to get it uncomfortably warm (not steaming hot), then let it cool completely (about an hour), weigh, then repeat. This took a couple of days.

JKJ in East TN


wood conservation

Re: Alcohol drying of turning squares

#11

Re: I'm still a skeptic

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>I don't know about the drying effects, but I do know that the alcohol penetrates rather deeply and fairly quickly. I did a few experiments on letting aniline dyes in alcohol penetrate wood blanks and then later tuning them. I also think that another flaw in your test was that you waited too long to test the moisture content. Eventually pieces dried in either matter would have the same moisture content. One of the purposes of using alcohol is to hurry up the process. The difference in moister content would be greatest right after the soaking. The warping and splitting results are valid. Here is a picture of one box I made. The box is about 3" high. I dyed the blank (a rectangular piece of wood) by immersing the lower end in Alcohol and dye solution. The dye penetrated this far in the matter of a few ours not days. The wood however was already dry maybe wet wood would not absorb the alcohol as fast. It's something to ponder.

Tom


img

Re: Alcohol drying of turning squares

#12

Re: I'm still a skeptic

John K Jordan

>>I also think that another flaw in your test was

>that you waited too long to test the moisture content.

>Eventually pieces dried in either matter would have

>the same moisture content.

Tom,

I agree with the latter statement. I didn't include every detail but I did measure the moisture content just before, immediately after, and at various times over the next weeks. I did not record the numbers, but I don't remember significant differences between the two batches. I will be sure to document carefully the next time.

That's a clever use of dye! I would expect dry wood with open pores to pull liquid a significant distance. Consider chromatography, usually done with (dry) paper fibers. (Just now thinking about it, separation of dye components by chromatography methods in dry wood might make for some very interesting multi-colored turnings. We may be seeing just a bit of that effect on the left side of your photo.)

This does suggest another variable, the amount of drainage, pre-drying and perhaps even the season the tree is cut. Try repeating the dye experiement with wet wood (green dripping right off the tree, green a few days old, etc.) and let us know. All knowledge gained (about this) is good.

JKJ in East TN

Re: Alcohol drying of turning squares

#13

Re: I'm still a skeptic

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>I'll try that after We get back from vacation. My wife and I are going on a road trip for a week. We will be visiting Shenendoah National Park and going down Skyline Drive and the Blue Ridge Parkway!

Re: Alcohol drying of turning squares

#14

Re: I'm still a skeptic

John K Jordan

>That's a beautiful drive. I take it instead of the interstate sometimes coming back from Washington. We've stayed in a ski resort during the off season. You'll be fairly close to our area at the end. We're just on the other side of Knoxville.

If you make it to the Smokeys go around the Cades Cove loop and get out and walk the woods. I've seen and videoed many bear and cubs and even saw a red wolf once. Deer are abundent and almost tame enough to touch. Don't try this with a bear. My favorite place is the side road to the Primitive Baptist Church, park at the 90-deg curve in the road and walk down hill on the old road to a little hidden cove, and from there around and over the ridge to the left.

JKJ in East TN

Re: Alcohol drying of turning squares

#15

Re: I'm still a skeptic

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>We might just make it tht far! We are leaving tomorrow morning early. (Before 7:00 A.M.) I can get up at 5:00 A.M. with no problem, but don't ask me to stay up past 11:00 P.M.