Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

GE reveal bulbs

Posts

GE reveal bulbs

#1

GE reveal bulbs

John Lucas

>After Mike's adventures with the GE Reveal light bulbs I went to the store and bought some along with the Sylvania Daylight bulbs. They look blueish so I thought they might be slightly cooler than the standard bulb. To my surprise they were not. I compared them to a 3200K #1 photo flood. Then shot photos of a Kodak test card on the Tungsten setting of my Nikon D1.

The Reveal bulb measured 2530K. The sylvania 2720K. A standard household bulb measured 2660K and of course the photoflod measured 3200. What this means is according to the meter the Reveal should be warmer or redder than a regular light bulb. The sylvania should be a little bluer but both should be orange on tungsten film.

I guess it's because of the blue filter but neither one of them photographed all that far off. The Photoflood was pretty much on the money but maybe a hair green. Of course I was using the screen on the back of the camera which is close but not dead on. The reveal was a hair red. The sylvania actually gave the best color and the regular bulb was red. Based on my experience with standard quartz worklights whick read 2700K they should all shoot very much the same with slight color differences the same as using 2 different brands of film or 2 different digital cameras.

I have one guess why Mikes photos came out different other than the slight color shift from the lamp. The Reveal bulbs are many times less bright than the quartz lights. This means that ambient light around the room could have more influence on the color. Another possibility is the room color. If the Reveal bulbs weren't in a reflector they would bounce light all over the room, thus changing the color. Anyway, all that doesn't really matter. What matters is getting a good photo and whatever it takes to do it is OK. I don't think the REveal bulb is going to give you any better results, only different results.

Re: GE reveal bulbs

#2

Re: GE reveal bulbs are tungsten

John Lucas

>I forgot to mention that Daylight film is balanced for 5000K so even though the Reveal bulbs say daylight they need to be shot on the tungsten setting. You can buy Flourescent bulbs that are balanced to 5000k and will work with Daylight film. I use those in my light table so the slides I view are the correct color.

Re: GE reveal bulbs

#3

Waht ???

Frank G ( Ingleside Texas )

>I have no idea what you said and have no doubt I'm the only one that doesn't understand what you said. Where's my Brownie ?.

Re: GE reveal bulbs

#4

I also can't spell.

Frank G ( Ingleside Texas )

>

Re: GE reveal bulbs

#5

Re: GE reveal bulbs

John Trant (Baltimore/DC area)

>As you said in your post, a proper photoflood light gave a green cast. This leads me to presume the camera (software) makers assume "tungsten" means household light (2700K) to most amateur photographers therefor the filters are not balanced for 3200K. If this is true, then a photo of a piece of wood with a green cast (as per your photofloods and camera combination) is going to be less appealing than the photo taken with the warmer (2700K) light source. I make the same choice when selecting a nice oil finish with its warm tones verses a bluish, water-born finish.

John

Re: GE reveal bulbs

#6

I love this kind of stuff

Mike Schwing from Md.

>This is great. I love forums like this one. I post a possible photo tip, with nothing other than my own results to postulate on, and within 24 hours we have hard data on the lamps, and have probably all learned more about JPG and lossy/lossless compression than we'd ever have thought existed.

Your possible reasons why my photos look so much better with those lights might be right on. The following facts exist, at least - I can only use those lights with my small cube, they're not bright enough in the 30" cube. I do use them enclosed in a reflector, and I do always turn all other lights in the room off, and it is in a room with no windows usually. (basement)

I don't use the preset camera light settings, but instead choose the one touch white balance.

As I said, next time I'll use both types of lights on the same subject.

I also wonder if my red/green colorblind has anything to do with my editing preference. I seem to love those Reveal bulbs much more than my wife (Mrs. Schwingding) does in the house. To me, they are unbelievably and dramatically different than a standard tungsten bulb, but to her they make everything look pink.

Great stuff everybody!

Re: GE reveal bulbs

#7

Ott Lights

Stuart Johnson

>Have you every taken a reading from an Ott light? My wife swears they give the truest color to her needlepoint work. She has finally given up on asking my opinon on the thread she is using.

Wife: do you like this color?

me: Yes

Wife: what about this one?

me: Yes

Wife: which do you like best?

me: Huh, they're both blue.

Wife: No they aren't. One is "x" and the other is "y".

( x and y are both blue and to me there is no difference)

me: Okay, the one on the right.

Wife: You do? I like the other one.

me: I'm going out to the shop.

Re: GE reveal bulbs

#8

Re: GE reveal bulbs

John K Jordan

>John,

Your test confirms our experience when we tested a few years ago although I could not find the email with the data so I don't have the numbers. As I mentioned earlier, subjectively the lights also look warmer to me, towards the red side, which is perhaps not a bad thing for wood photos. I first noticed this with two different bulbs side by side in track lighting. (The human eye is incredibly adaptable making it difficult to make objective evaluations without a side-by-side comparison.)

Although warmer and perhaps more pleasant than bluer or green, for turning photography an uncorrected pink cast might show up most on white or neutral backgrounds.

JKJ in East TN

Re: GE reveal bulbs

#9

Re: GE reveal bulbs

John Lucas

>John The green cast was only on the Camera monitor. These are always inacurate. On the computer the photoflood light looked normal with good colors and neutral grays.

Re: GE reveal bulbs

#10

Re: I love this kind of stuff

John Lucas

>Mike The low power bulbs should work just as well in the big booth(unless they are physically just too small). You would simply have to use a much longer exsposure, on the tripod of course. The only problem with long exposures is some digital cameras pick up a lot of "noise" and look like high grain photos.

Re: GE reveal bulbs

#11

Re: Waht ???

John Lucas

>Frank the color of light is measured in degrees Kelvin. If you heat a carbon rod it will gradually change temperature. When it gets red it is around 3200 degrees and blue is around 5000 white hot is of course much higher on the scale. Tungsten Film is balanced for Tunsten light and Kodak or whoever decided on 3200 degrees. Daylight film is balanced for 5000 degrees kelvin. What this means is if I shoot daylight film with standard light bulbs (or the GE Reveal bulbs) it will look orange. With Digital cameras you can simply change the White Balance.

Re: GE reveal bulbs

#12

Re: I love this kind of stuff

John Lucas

>Mike It is also possible that the CCD in your camera simply likes the color of Reveal bulbs better. All CCD's reproduce colors differently. Like changing brands of film. I get to shoot with Nikon D2, Nikon D1, D100 and D70. All 4 reproduce colors differently. Drives us crazy when we shoot graduation with all 4 cameras. EVeryones black robe and skin tones are very slightly different.

Re: GE reveal bulbs

#13

I went shopping too John....

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Thanks so much for the report. I think I'll give them a try, since I've got them in hand. Now I'm wondering if the room I shoot my pics in might have something to do with my results. It's a very deep burgundy on the walls? Hmmm....

Again thanks for all the help from you and everyone else.

Jennifer

Re: GE reveal bulbs

#14

Re: GE reveal bulbs

Rick in Colgate, Wi

>I'm going to guess that the bluish tint to the GE Reveal bulbs is actually a "didymium" tint that is commonly used in glasses worn by glassblowers to reduce yellow light from sodium as it burns off of molten glass. I was a glassblower for 10 years and I do have GE Reveal bulbs for our lighting. The following is from a web site:

Didymium is a mixture of the elements praseodymium and neodymium. It is used in safety glasses for glass blowing, where it provides a narrow filter which blocks mainly the light emitted by the hot sodium in the glass, without having much effect on general vision, unlike dark welder's glasses. When used as a photographic filter it tends to strengthen red tones. It is also used in calibration materials.

Re: GE reveal bulbs

#15

Re: GE reveal bulbs

John Lucas

>Rick I believe it did say that on one brand of bulbs I looked at. There was a large difference in prices. I can't believe I didn't know that about glass blowing. I shoot a lot of photos of glass blowing as well as their artwork and no one mentioned that. I'm always impressed by how they can see temperature changes that I can't.

Re: GE reveal bulbs

#16

Re: GE reveal bulbs *LINK*

John K Jordan

>>John The green cast was only on the Camera monitor.

John,

Yes, I saw that. I simply meant that a light towards the red in general might be more pleasant for a photograph of wood than the alternative from any source, a bluish tint (cold and harsh) or a greenish tint such as from fluorescents (sickly). But although the light did look pinkish to my eyes, as you mentioned elsewhere it's not the eyese but the CCD sensitivity that counts (as well as the monitor or printer!).

If you researched these bulbs on the web, you probably noticed that that there has been much discussion of these bulbs relative to photography. One person on photo.net tested the color temperature with his meter and got 3400K. Another wrote to GE who claimed they bulbs "burned" at 2850, however there was some question whether this was before or after the filtering.

I found the interactive comparison on this page was interesting (also linked below):

http://web.mit.edu/cjoye/www/photo/tests.html

And this table lists color temperatures and data for a variety of bulbs:

http://www.tabletopstudio.com/documents/TTS_LIGHT_MYTHS.htm

One thing I've never researched is the color temperature differences in the same type of bulb at different wattages. For example, it's possible that a 40 watt bulb might have a different temperature than a 300 watt bulb. I didn't see where you mentioned the bulb wattage. Did you test different Reveal wattages?

JKJ in East TN


Interactive comparison

Re: GE reveal bulbs

#17

Re: GE reveal bulbs

Ron in Drums PA

>Thanks For the info John

There is another topic I'd like to throw into the pot.

White Balance

Without getting to technical:

On my old 1 meg digital camera, I can set the white balance simply by placing a white card on the table, go though the menu and find "White Balance", zoom in on the card an press the shutter. The colors are always spot on.

On my daughter's brand spanking new, 5 meg camera, there are 7 presets for white balance to choose from, and too bad if they are off by a little.

Re: GE reveal bulbs

#18

Re: GE reveal bulbs

JamieDonaldson

>Ron- just another example of progress giving us too much information, which we probably didn't need!

Re: GE reveal bulbs

#19

Re: GE reveal bulbs

John K Jordan

>>just another example of progress giving us too

>much information, which we probably didn't need!

In this case I think it is a case of progress in some marketer's idea of simplification, or perhaps progress in corporate profit or progress in the dumbing down of the masses. I think a good camera needs a good white balance control, not a set of presets. For this simplification they save a dollar.

I believe these are still called "PHD" cameras. (Push Here, Dummy!)

JKJ in East TN

Re: GE reveal bulbs

#20

Re: GE reveal bulbs

JamieDonaldson

>Watch out John, I represent that remark!! I have both Olympus and Nikon dcams, and don't think multiple white balance custom settings make anything simpler. I still have to carry the instruction books in the bag!

Re: GE reveal bulbs

#21

Re: GE reveal bulbs

John K Jordan

>>and don't think multiple white balance custom

>settings make anything simpler.

Just to be clear, the simplification remark was satire, somebody's IDEA of simplier - I think we agree there is no replacing setting the white balance by metering.

I bought an Olympus SLR digital mostly for the manual focus and TTL viewfinder, but the other manual controls are also good. But I also "resemble" the remark - there are at least five PHD cameras around here! My pet peeve is when the designers put common functions under menus just to save a button or control, although I understand why it's done.

JKJ in East TN