We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>For those of you that sell on consignment through shops and galleries. If you receive a referral from that shop or gallery and have no agreement as to referrals do you give a percentage to that shop? If so, is it the same or less than the percentage that the shop takes when selling your item inhouse. I believe that the referring shop is entitled to some amount of commisiion but not quite sure how much. Perhaps half of what they receive when selling in-house items?? Your thoughts please.
Thanks,
Mike in humid rain-starved (but not for long)Cape May
>First - you of course know that you should have negotiated that with the store owner beforehand. However, you're not alone.
I just finished negotiating this very thing with a shop owner for a gallery. I suggested to him that if he referred me to a customer I would protect his prices by charging the gallery price, but that I would not offer a percentage. I also said that if the owner placed the order on behalf of the customer, I would give the gallery owner 50% - his typical markup.
I did that as an incentive to have all orders come through the store owner, as I'd rather deal with him and only get half the fee than deal with customers who are not used to dealing with me. (I can be crabby) That way the gallery gets to keep his customers under his control AND get his cut of the sale. I even suggested that the owner simply funnel all orders through him directly. He liked it.
But for your situation, you have to keep your gallery owner happy, so cough up the normal fee and give it to him/her. But definitely establish clear guidelines for future business of this type.
You have to protect your gallery owner's markups by charging the client the same price he'd fetch in the gallery. That gallery price must be your retail price.
Well it's still beforehand and I should have worded my question differently. In addition to the shows that I do and a winery shop and gallery that I have items in, I now have placed items in two more shops. The gallery and winery shop I have unique agreements with and referral fees don't come in to play. In the new venues we've agreed on pricing and percentage split but no dialog regarding referrals. I thought about it at the time but wanted to wait, get input from others and consider before broaching the subject. I agree that I need to negotiate this and was wondering what others do. I also agree that the shop's pricing needs to be protected and would obviously charge the client the same pricing as the shops charge. I'm going back to them later this week and will discuss referrals at that time. I like the idea of having them do the ordering rather than referring the client and will seek to do that. However if they do refer then it's your opinion that they receive the usual cut and that's what I'm mulling over before discussing it with them.
I wonder too about someone that buys my item through the shop and then orders something directly from me. Is this a referral of sorts. What about a referral that then becomes a repeat customer, does that client business continue to be treated as referral or is he/she now my customer with no referral fees. These are the types of scenarios that I'm pondering because I want to treat the shops fairly and keep them happy but also wanted to maximize my take.
>All of the good consignment contracts I've seen have a referral commission provision. Customarily, it's half of the in-shop sales commission. So, a 40% in-shop commission should yield a 20% referral fee.
BTW, there is a model consignment contract in the files area of another turning related message board. Send me an email if you'd like the address.
>Excellent question. Asking and addressing it now will help keep you and your sales agents (galleries and/or gift shops) on good terms. Mike's point about keeping the pricing consistent is especially good -- you can't be competing with, and undermining your gallery representation. They are paying the rent/heat/lights/ etc..., and putting potential buyers in front of your work. On-site discounts, where deemed necessary, or for volume purchases, should not exceed 10% off the gallery price. If I owned a gallery and found someone selling their work at wholesale prices (undercutting me by 40%), I might give that person one warning, but then the boot.
Most of the galleries around here charge a 40% commission. The contract I remember signing a few years ago is that if a customer hears about my work from a gallery, and then sees me privately to buy a piece (that was never displayed in the gallery), I should send the gallery 10% for the referred business. If they come to me to buy a piece that they first saw on display at a gallery, but is now in my hands, I should send the gallery 40% if the sale is within 30 days of the show, and 20% thereafter. This can arise from a limited-time gallery show, or seasonal display.
I may have the exact details wrong, but this is what I remember. Right now I'm too busy packing, renovating and moving to sell anything privately, but I will remember to look this up before I do ! Food for thoughtful discussion.
>There are 2 kinds of galleries, those where you sign a consignment contract, and those where you don't. My experience with those that don't has been that they are just as casual about sending a check for things that are sold. They also have a habit of going out of business and taking all of our stuff with them.
The consignment contract must include several things. Failure to have these spelled out is always a cause for argument later. The following are several of the things that I think are most important. A lot of this will depend on the selling price of the item. I might ignore a contract on things that sell for less than $100, but never on those selling for more.
A separate line item with a description and entry date for each piece. High priced or special items might also include a photo.
The gallery selling price for the item.
Protection of the gallery price. This will determine how much you can charge for your own sales of similar items within the galleries marketing area. This area can be defined as within a city limits, a 50 mile radius is common, and there are some that want a larger area and I have seen those that want up to a 150 mile radius. This restriction can be a good reason for never putting anything in a gallery that is close to home.
The commission rate, usually 50% for a first time association, but some are willing to accept 40%. Over time, development of a relationship with the gallery, and a good sales history, they should be willing to negotiate for a lower rate.
The gallery commission for referrals. This can be almost any number but never more than 1/2 their normal commission.
How long the piece will be on display. There comes a time when either you or the gallery will want something taken home.
Responsibility for loss, damage, and theft while in the gallery.
Your guarantee for damage or loss after the sale. What will you do, and for how long after the sale, to fix or replace the piece that has cracked while sitting on the mantel. Many galleries have had bad experiences with woodturners on this one because most folks don't understand that seasonal wood movement can damage the wood or the finish and most woodturners don't tell them about it. A well defined warantee can save a lot of arguments later.
Some of get lucky, and the gallery is willing to purchase our work. The terms of such a sale are always the same except those related to the commission and duration of the display.
>Also - I'm new at this but I've been diligent about it.
* Who pays for shipping under what conditions. For example - suppose the piece breaks while on display and it needs to be returned to you. Who pays that freight?
* How long a piece will stay on display before its price is lowered or it is returned to you. If the latter - who pays?
* Under what conditions can each party terminate the contract? Mine are at will of either party with return of merchandise in 30 days and shipping paid by the terminating party.
* Can you have work back temporarily for a show?
* Will the owner promote you/your website/provide contact info?
* How soon is payment rendered after a sale?
I'm working with a gallery who has wonderful work, I've seen it over the course of several years, and the owner told me I'm the only person who has ever required a contract to be signed. He agreed though, that it was a good idea. It took us about 2 weeks' worth of emails to come to final terms.
I find the fact that I'm the only one nearly impossible to believe, but also a good testament to that owner's reputation as there are some big names there and a lot of volume, too.
Either way, we both know exactly what to expect for every condition I could conjure.
>Always remember that the days of gentlemen's agreements and a handshake are gone- if it isn't committed to paper like other contracts, then it doesn't exist from a legal standpoint.