Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

Posts

Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

#1

Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

Mike Schwing from Md.

>I've been noticing something that I think might be important about my photography. In my small booth/cube, I have been using a different light source than in the larger cube. In the large cube I use 500 watt halogen work lamps. They do a fine job. BUT in the small cube I have been using GE "Reveal" floodlight bulbs in 100 watt size. I can't use them in the large cube because they're not strong enough to light the object in the 36" tent.

I really like those Reveal bulbs and use them throughout the house. Whenever one breaks and my bride replaces them with a standard bulb I am struck by the difference in color rendition, so I thought it would be a good experiment to try photography with them. I've been using them for a while but with each photo I think more and more of them. I simply unscrew them from the ceiling lights in the kitchen and use them in portable reflector units. With the last photo of bug 4 I'm totally convinced.

The photographs taken under those lighting conditions are in my estimation - my best by far. Photos taken in that small cube with the halogens are not nearly as pleasing. I've tried both!

It could be that I'm red/green colorblind, but the pics with those bulbs just look much nicer to me. No comparison really.

The photos below were all taken in a 12" cube with 2 GE Reveal 100 watt floods. The soft, pleasing color rendition just screams "nice" to me. Next time I use this booth I'll take identical pics with both light sources for comparison. Any similar experiences or experiments?












Re: Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

#2

Re: Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Mike I'm very interested in this....as lately I haven't been real pleased with my photos. I feel like the light is too harsh. I'm using a 16" soft box and two 500 watt hallogen work lights. Are these bulbs standard scew in bulbs? Do you use them in one of those bell type shop fixutres?

....and do you buy them at any big box store?

Thanks for the heads up!

Jen

Re: Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

#3

Re: Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

John Lucas

>Mike Most interesting. I haven't played with the Reveal bulbs but assumed that they were just tungsten bulbs that had a filter to make them look more daylight to your eyes but not necessarily to film. I will buy one today and check it with our color meter so I will know for sure.

Mike your pictures appear much sharper than most people. At what resolution are you saving them to put on WC? I've been using 180 DPI at around 400 pixels and then using SAve for WEb on my photo shop. Mine aren't nearly as crisp as yours and not even close to what they look like when I'm working on them in photo shop. Like I've said before, I'm a photographer not a computer person. I know lighting and cameras but my printer and graphic artist take care of all the computer stuff so I really struggle in that area.

Jennifer. If your light is too harsh meaning to much contrast then you need more fill light. If it's too harsh meaning the shadows are too well defined then you need to diffuse the light more so it appears bigger to the object. This might mean either using a bigger soft box or simply putting some more material near the middle so the light hits the softbox more evenly. Often on our homemade lights, even though the panel or softbox is large the light is really concentrated toward the middle. I solve this by putting a mini panel aabout 12" square between the light and panel. This diffuses the hotspot in the middle so your panel is more evenly lit. I hang the little mini panel about 8" in front of the light with a piece of copper wire.

Re: Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

#4

This is what I use. *LINK*

Gerald McGrantham

>It is called an EZCube. Your can purchase the daylight bulbs from them and set up your own cube. Or buy the lights. I use three lights. One on each side of the light tent and one just behind and to the left of the camera. You vary the amount of light on your object by moving the lights closer or further away from the light tent. You don't have to move them much.

Gerald


EZCube Light Tent

Re: Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

#5

Re: Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Jennifer, harsh lighting usually involves light that is too direct/not enough dispersion/filter. It might simply be terminology, but are you seeing shadows from your work? That is what is usually referred to as harsh lighting. Glare is a different issue and is usually solved directionally rather than intensity. (look at me I sound like I know what I'm talking about..how did that happen?)

These bulbs are normal screw in type bulbs and yes, I put them in the standard reflector type mount you described. I hang one above and one to the side. I don't think HD carries them but I do think Lowe's does. Target usually has the most reliable supply that I have found. They're not very bright, I usually have to open the lens up and slow the speed down, but on a tripod mounted camera it doesn't matter.

Even if you don't like them in the photo booth, I bet you'll like them in the house.

Re: Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

#6

sharp photos

Mike Schwing from Md.

>John, thanks for the compliment. My photos are proof that you don't need lots of megapixels. Every photo I take is on a 1.2 megapixel camera.

To describe how I get them to the finish stage its important to tell you what application I'm using as well - I use "The Gimp" - a open source photoshop clone. (free - www.gimp.org)

Rather than save them at a set pixel size, I use the "quality" slider on the Gimp "save as jpg" tab to set the quality to file size instead. Here on WC the size limit is 80Kb so I set the slider on my photos to save the pictures at just under 80Kb. If you click the "preview" checkbox before adjusting it will show you file size, too!

But thats not the whole story. I save them in SHQ mode, which puts a .jpg from the camera at about a meg each, in 1600xsomething resolution.

The steps I take in the Gimp are as follows (and done with specific intent in this order).

1. Open the file.

2. Crop to final appearance. Try to crop only once.

3. Rescale cropped image. On WC I usually choose 650 pix wide and let the height auto scale.

4. Alter the appearance as necessary.

a. Adjust white balance.

b. Adjust colors until background matches actual background.

c. Adjust contrast by using the "curves" controls.

d. Adjust sharpness till pleasing.

e. Save file so file size is just under 80Kb.

I only adjust scale and sharpness once. If I need to do that more than once I start over from the beginning because each time you perform either of those two operations you lose detail, lots of detail that add'l work will never restore.

Hope that helps. Thats all I do, really.

Re: Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

#7

tested those

John K Jordan

>A few years ago I considered those bulbs a few years ago as possible inexpensive supplements to the professional video and photo lights where I work. Our in-house video studio then ran some careful tests on the color temperature and spectum and found them unsuitable for general work.

These bulbs appear to use a colored frosted layer inside the glass to try to counteract the normal yellow of a low-power tungston filament. Unfortunately, the overall spectrum suffers. To my eye, they leave a pinkish cast on everything. This might make wood look warmer than tungston but looks bad on people and other things. (To compare, try shining two different types of bulbs on either side of a smooth sphere or cylinder painted flat white or grey.)

Note that the whole system must be considered and the CCDs in different digital cameras may respond differently - the filtered light might be just what your camera needs. Another variable is the the digital post processing. It might be "enlightening" to examine the histogram in the digital file with Photoshop.

BTW, if you want the most accurate color rendition, there is a correction technique for Photoshop that uses grey points and curves that does a very good job of correcting color. It requires while, grey, and black references in the photo - some people take two identical shots,with and without the references. (Remember the old photographer's grey card?)

JKJ in East TN

Re: Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

#8

Re: Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

Donna Banfield

>Mike, if I recall correctly, you work for the government - the State of Maryland? Well, your work gives new meaning to the definition of the tired old phrase..."good enough for government work." Absolutely outstanding!

Re: Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

#9

Even better - I work for the Feds!

Mike Schwing from Md.

>I love it when I deal with a state representative. They refer to me as "The Feds" always makes me chuckle.

Re: Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

#10

Re: Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

JamieDonaldson

>Mike- there is some variation in your color correction, but that's not unusual under any circumstance. If you are indeed R/G color "weak" you must have a real challenge doing CC- does Mrs. Swingding help edit- women often have better color vision than us guys. It might be more scientific to include a color test chart if you can find one- an old Kodak Color Dataguide has a good one inside, and you can find them cheap at old photographer yard sales!

Re: Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

#11

Re: Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

JamieDonaldson

>Ouch Mike- I messed up spelling your name- I'm sorry! I haven't tried these bulbs-too many new gadgets to play with them all!

Re: Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

#12

Re: sharp photos

John K Jordan

>>I only adjust scale and sharpness once. If I need to do that more

>than once I start over from the beginning because each time you

>perform either of those two operations you lose detail, lots of

>detail that add'l work will never restore.

Same thing with color adjustment - a look at the histogram after an operation will show you how the color is being degraded. Enough adjustments and gradients will be "banded" and shadows and highlights destroyed. I'm sure you know this but others may not.

If you do a lot of image work, you might want to look into Photoshop some day (if you haven't done so). You can do things like work on multiple layers so an adjustment to color or sharpness will not destroy the original, or use the History feature to back up many steps, or even selectively undo portions of the image but keep changes in other portions. It's kind of like saving multiple copies at different stages of work and being able to instantly switch them in and out for comparison. You can also use Adjustment Layers which provide a nondestructive way to make a variety of image adjustments. The masking features are also powerful - it's easy to "paint" sharpness (or any other function) only where needed.

Photoshop is expensive for a hobby, but it's so powerful it's easy to understand why it's the professional standard.

JKJ in East TN

Re: Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

#13

Re: This is what I use.

JamieDonaldson

>Don't bother with a small one unless you turn miniatures- for most average size turnings the 20" Cube is barely large enough, and their not cheap either!

Re: Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

#14

Re: Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics) *LINK*

Ned Bulken

>Mike,

first off your turning work is incredible, can't wait to get my own spinny thing to attempt to emulate your skill.

the trick with the reveal bulbs is that they're balanced or tuned color wise to mimic daylight, which your halogens are not. The halogens are very yellow. whereas the reveals are much more 'blue' or cooler in tone. You're getting even lighting with the reveal bulbs, which will help a lot as well.

I use my photographic floods from Paul C Buff, see link. mine are older units, but basically the same as the linked units. Overkill if you're just lighting for web photos. I have mine from a previous 'incarnation' as a pro photographer.


Paul C Buff photo floods

Re: Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

#15

Re: sharp photos

John Lucas

>They tell me at work to save the image as a TiFF and then do all your adjustments. In JPG it compresses the file everytime you do something and after a bunch of playing the image looks terrible and the file size is a lot smaller.

Re: Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

#16

Re: Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

John Lucas

>Ned I tested the first White Lightenings when they came out. Paul used to buy photo gear at our store and brought some of the old Milk Bucket style lights by for us to use and give our opinion. I'm still using the 3200's for location work. They don't draw as much power as other lights so you can use them in people's homes without blowing circuits. They aren't as good as my Speedotron Black line units but they are still a good buy.

Re: Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

#17

Re: sharp photos

Mike Schwing from Md.

>John, thats partially good information. The best save is in your editor's native format, whatever that might be. Any conversion from the native format, which is what the photo is in while it is being edited, back to any different photo format will result in distortion/loss. For example - Gimp's native format is .xcf , I believe Photoshop's is .psd (not sure though).

TIFF conversion retains more data than JPG but its not as good as native.

Re: Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

#18

one more thing

Mike Schwing from Md.

>I always save my work in the native format every few minutes just in case I mistakenly close the app, power failure, crash, etc.. Just a quick "CTRL-S" does it after it is initally saved in your preferred format. A good habit to adopt, I don't care who you are.

Re: Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

#19

native format - not correct

John K Jordan

>>The best save is in your editor's native format, whatever

>that might be. Any conversion from the native format,

>which is what the photo is in while it is being edited,

>back to any different photo format will result in distortion/loss...

>

>TIFF conversion retains more data than JPG but its not

>as good as native.

Mike, this is not correct. I'll provide some detail when I get time.

JKJ in East TN

Re: Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

#20

Re: native format - not correct

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Will be very interested in seeing that. I recently read an article in a PC photography mag that says the opposite.

Re: Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

#21

JPEGs, PSDs, TIFFs

Ron in Drums PA

>In Photoshop when you save to PSD (Photoshop's native file) what you are doing is saving all the changes along with a tiff file. So saving as PSD is good only if you want to backstep your changes at a latter date. The price you will pay is a bloated file.

I always save my original image and only make changes to a duplicate. Since my old digital camera can take images in TIFF format that is what I use.

Everything you wanted to know about JPEGs but where afraid to ask.

ttp://www.faqs.org/faqs/jpeg-faq/part1/

Re: Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

#22

Re: native format - not correct

John K Jordan

>>Will be very interested in seeing that. I recently

>read an article in a PC photography mag that says

>the opposite.

Based on some articles I've seen, I'm not entirely surprised! But I'd like to read that article. Is it on line? Do you remember the magazine and issue? Is it a new magazine likely to still be on the shelves?

JKJ in East TN

Re: Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

#23

Re: native format - not correct

Mike Schwing from Md.

>I've been looking for it this morning, but I believe I left the mag on the airplane. Will keep searching. Figures! I think it was "PC Photography"

Re: Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

#24

Re: JPEGs, PSDs, TIFFs - say what?

John K Jordan

>>In Photoshop when you save to PSD (Photoshop's native file)

>what you are doing is saving all the changes along with a tiff file.

>So saving as PSD is good only if you want to backstep your changes

>at a latter date. The price you will pay is a bloated file.

This is entirely untrue. Where do these ideas come from, from experience or hearsay or another magazine article?? (Yikes, I'll be banned for being too confrontational!)

What IS saved in a Photoshop file is all the layers, paths, and channels, including masks and alpha channels. The changes (i.e., the history) are not saved. You cannot open a PSD file and undo or revert back to a previous step or backstep to any previous date using the history list or any other method. (Unless you are using some version of Photoshop that we don't know about!) I just tested this in Photoshop 7.01 and CS (8.0).

What you CAN do is freely copy layers and make changes to layers, add adjustment layers, effect layers, make layer masks, save selections as channels, and many more things. All layers and effects can be freely turned on and off to use or disable them. All of these things are saved unless you delete them or merge or flatten the image before saving. When the file is reloaded, you can use or not use the saved layers, so if you saved a layer with the original unaltered image, you can still work from that if desired. The power and flexibilty is simply amazing and I'm hard to amaze.

I have detected no file bloat. Files do get larger as you add more layers, but if you add up the pixels in each layer and include other data and overhead, there is no bloat. (Unlike MS Word and Excel files) But large files are possible and common. One large construction site panoramic photo that I update periodically creates a 300+ meg file with all layers and masks. I have other files with at least 50 layers and they too are huge. Fortunately, today's machines with fast dual processors, big cache, fast memory, fast disks, and huge amounts of cheap storage space make such files easy to work with.

Also, a PSD is not a TIFF file, although it does share some features with TIFF. Some "flavors" of TIFF file do save layers but not some of the other data.

If you have some specifics which contradict this, I'll be glad to investigate. (This topic is direcly related to my field of work.)

JKJ in East TN

Re: Photography tip? GE "Reveal" bulbs (pics)

#25

Re: JPEGs, PSDs, TIFFs - say what?

Mike Schwing from Md.

>" (This topic is direcly related to my field of work.) "

No kidding. Hahahaa!