Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

I'm curious. I've bathed...

Posts

I'm curious. I've bathed...

#1

I'm curious. I've bathed...

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>This is an uncomfortable post for me to write as it almost sounds as if I'm fishing for compliments, and I'm not. The following experience is atypical for me so I'm trying to find out if I missed something.

Last Thursday I posted a report on my lathe stand modifications I had made in converting from my old Craftsman tube lathe to my Delta 46-700. I even had visual aids (pictures). I also asked for opinions on the height as I'm unsure where I should be with it. So what's the problem? The post has had nearly 300 reads (as of the time of this post). There have been zero—zilch, nada, bupkus replies.

I know there had been some in-progress discussion in a post the week earlier, but I didn't think all the issues had been resolved, and I still was interested in thoughts on the height question. Was it something I said? Did everyone think I was just posting a completed project for all to view?

Anyway, I'll go shower again, if it'll help (I know I need a haircut, and I was at the dentist today, so I brushed for that). Please don't post a *NM* we're here for you—my ego isn't that hungry for massaging. But if there is something to add on the height issue, I'd really appreciate some input—especially from the more experienced, really savvy turners.

Rod

Re: I'm curious. I've bathed...

#2

Re: I'm curious. I've bathed...

Carole in VA

>Rod, it wasn't clear to me that you were asking any specific questions in that post. As for height of the stand, I am wrestling with the same thing since I need to build a stand for my Nova which will be here next month. I am used to my Jet Min, which is about 43". That is slightly below the 90 deg elbow thing. Would I be more comfortable with it a little higher? I have no clue! I have seen pics of great turners turning on lathes with a spindle height almost mid chest! I gues it's all up to the individual and personal preference. Yeah I know, that's not an answer, but "I'm here for you" ;)

Oh and BTW, yes you probably WILL eventually mount up something big enough and out of balance enough to send the lathe on a stroll! LOL I know I probably will.

Re: I'm curious. I've bathed...

#3

Re: I'm curious. I've bathed...

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Rod,

Sorry, been busy and just glancing and most posts for the last couple of posts.

Traditional advice is for lathe spindle height to be at elbow height, but this is for the traditional spindle turner. It is a bit low for a bowl turner, and really low if you do hollow forms. Since I do mostly bowls, and most of those are hollow forms, I have my lathe spindle height up at 48". Since you do mostly furniture, I would recomment the traditional elbow height. Also, if you do mostly spindles, there is not much need to heavily weighting the base.

Mark

Re: I'm curious. I've bathed...

#4

JL

Re: I'm curious. I've bathed...

JL

>Comments (he wants comments). OK. Comments.

1) Square leg stance - basically rectangular frame.

My concern is vibration. A rectangular frame like this might give rise to wracking vibrations with a rough bowl blank or severely out of balance piece.

2) Legs

How about levelers (which you could also use to raise/lower the height)? Maybe trestle style feet with levelers? This would give a wider stance and more stability.

3) Options for adding weight. How about another rail across the front of the legs. Then you can pile on sandbags or whatever.

4) Storage - maybe a cabinet/drawer unit to store tools, chucks, etc? When I got my 1642 EVS, I took Dominic's plans for a ballast box and set it down a bit lower. I then built a drawer unit to mount on top of the ballast box. Now I have storage for a lot (not all) of my stuff.

There - comments.

Re: I'm curious. I've bathed...

#5

you do bring up another curious point

Mike Schwing from Md.

>First - let me say that I didn't even see your post. Sorry.

Next, you brought up a point that you probably didn't even consider - what is an acceptable view/response ratio? Most threads don't get 5 replies, no matter how many views. Rarely does one get more than a dozen, but those that do seem to get DOZENS of responses - like the toolrest height threads a few weeks ago.

I've discovered that the best way to get responses is to ask specific questions. For example - do you think my new stand needs ballast? Do you think it needs crossbraces? Questions like "what do you think about my new stand" - folks don't so much respond to.

Now about your stand - it needs ballast! Several hundred pounds of steel, lead, sand, gravel, etc.. in a well constructed container below will help immensely. I haven't seen anyone try the above the lathe on the post ballast method other than the time it was described, but thats a consideration, too.

In my experience, the mobile bases detract immensely from stability. I would consider modifying the base to that you have the ability to anchor the lathe to the floor using feet that lie outside the perimeter of the mobile base.

Occasionally, I drop an important piece of something in between the rails of my lathe bed. It always falls into a pile of shavings and I have to chase it down in a time consuming and frustrating fashion. More than once I've wished I had a containment shelf underneath the bed for that reason. It would also get filled with shavings but doesn't everything?

Re: I'm curious. I've bathed...

#6

Thanks, Carole.

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>> …yes you probably WILL eventually mount up something big enough and out of balance enough to send the lathe on a stroll!

I hope not. Mainly because if I do, it'll be a sign I've gone over the edge, and I'd prefer not to do that. Well, we all have dreams…

Thanks.

Rod

Re: I'm curious. I've bathed...

#7

Now see, there's something I didn't know...

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>…spindle vs bowl. I never gave a thought to there being a desirable difference in tool rest height between the two main types of turning. I can certainly see that now that you mention it. In my case, it'll have to be a compromise. When I can no longer live with the compromise I'll buy a Vega!

Thanks, Mark.

Rod

Re: I'm curious. I've bathed...

#8

Thanks for the comments.

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>Thanks J, or should I call you Mr. L?

  1. There's a fair amount of stiffness due to the joinery of the cross memebers. As I use the lathe more, I'll have a better idea of whether it's sufficient or whether I'll need to add more structure. It'll certainly be easy enough to do. Rebuilding the entire stand isn't out of the question, if necessary.

  2. Levelers aren't an option, since the mobile base is a necessity. Also, the stand sits level in the mobile base, so further adjustment is unnecessary.

  3. Another rail is certainly a possibility. Especially since I found that the front rail of the mobile base wasn't in a bad position. A front rail, at just the right height for comfortable foot resting, and mounted on the back of the front legs would be do-able.

  4. I saw Dom's article. It's a consideration. I was hoping to keep things as free as possible underneath for chip control. But I haven't completely ruled it out.

There—thanks.

Rod

Re: I'm curious. I've bathed...

#9

That's me--curious.

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>Oh, I've been around here long enough to understand the nature of replies. That's why I started this thread—300:0 seemed out of the ordinary, and I didn't know if it was how I wrote the other one or something else. It seems from the responses to this one that it was a combination of both.

As far as ballast goes, I won't be reinventing any wheel there—when I add it it'll be conventionally within the framework (ha, ha) of the existing structure. I missed both the tool-rest-height and the above-the-lathe-on-the-post-ballast-method threads but I shudder at the thought of too high a center of gravity.

The mobile base is a necessity. I have ≈ 500 ft2 of shop space with Delta's full catalog of stationary tools (albeit also on mobile bases), so mobility is what I have to live with. The Delta style mobile base is very stable, and, with the 1¼" aluminum tubing, very stiff and strong. The support points all lie outside the footprint of the stand, and when the wheel is up (base down), there are four points of support. That's unlike my HTC base on my bandsaw (and on my old DJ15, now gone), which only has three.

Yeah, chips are chips, no matter where they are. I've found from past experience that I'd prefer them on the floor rather than intermediate surfaces. I also have this general problem with flat surfaces—they become temporary storage areas. No flat surface is safe from me.

Thanks for the thoughts, Mike.

Rod

Re: I'm curious. I've bathed...

#10

Re: That's me--curious.

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>A couple of suggestions:

First, put a significant slope on the top of the ballast box. That way, shavings will slide off, and you won't be tempted to set tools or abrasives down there where they will get buried.

Second, if you do decide to raise the lathe to make it more convenient for bowl and HF turning, just build a sturdy, short stool to stand on when you are spindle turning. You might be able to pick it up, toss it on top of the ballast box to get it out of the way and to use it for extra ballast when you are turning bowls.

Re: I'm curious. I've bathed...

#11

Re: That's me--curious.

Dave Anderson Chester, NH

>I understand your desire to use mobile bases Rod, but I strongly suggest that you make an exception for the lathe. The machine room in my shop is considerably smaller than 300 sqft, but of all my stationary power tools, the lathe and drill press are the only ones not mobile. I'm sure if you plan carefully you can find a good layout which will allow you to take advantage of the extra stability a lathe can have by not being on a mobile base. Knowing your planning abilities I'm sure you can work out something satisfactory. Good luck no matter what you decide.

Re: I'm curious. I've bathed...

#12

Re: I'm curious. I've bathed...

Geoff G

>how do you know how many reads a post has had?

Re: I'm curious. I've bathed...

#13

Re: I'm curious. I've bathed...

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>Look to the right of the subject line of every post. It says "Views xxx" where "xxx" is a number.

Rod

Re: I'm curious. I've bathed...

#14

Re: I'm curious. I've bathed...

Don Henthorn

>The little number to the right of the header.

Re: I'm curious. I've bathed...

#15

Mine is...

Jim Reed @ Tallahassee

>a Jet mini bolted to a 1/2" 2x4 sheet of mdf. It sits on top of my Ulmia workbench and is just perfect for pens.

Re: I'm curious. I've bathed...

#16

PS

Jim Reed @ Tallahassee

>glad you bathed.