Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

help! rough turned boxes splitting!

Posts

help! rough turned boxes splitting!

#1

help! rough turned boxes splitting!

Phil in NJ

>Hi,

I've turned a few rough boxes (as in the Raffan videos) from a wet oak log. I bandsaw'd the log into 3x3x6" blanks, then rough turned and hollowed them. I avoided the pith entirely in the blanks, and the grain is straight.

The walls are approx 1/2" thick, and the bottoms are perhaps 3/4" or 1" thick.

Within a few days either the top or the bottom or both are splitting across the bottom.

I'm keeping the rough turned blanks in open air in my basement, which is dehumidified (to about 50% RH at about 68 degrees or so).

Any suggestions? If I slow the drying by sticking them in a paper bag, will they still split but more slowly? Again, I say, Raffan makes this look easy. :)

Thanks!

-Phil

Re: help! rough turned boxes splitting!

#2

Re: help! rough turned boxes splitting!

Barry Irby

>I turn them as you have suggested and tape the top and bottom together, bottom to top, so that the hollowed ends are "out". Just a strip or two of cheap masking tape around the joint. Then I drop them in a paper bag until I remember them. Some of them are several years old now and I don't think I have lost any, but If I have it was very few. This also keeps the matching parts together so the grain will match up later. I write the date on the tape if I'm organized enough to do it. I have only done about thirty or forty, but once in a while I get the urge to turn colorful scraps into box blanks.

Re: help! rough turned boxes splitting!

#3

Re: help! rough turned boxes splitting!

Ed Davidson (Colorado Springs)

>Phil,

Try putting your blanks in a sealed paper bag, filled with sawdust and shavings from your turnings, for one to six months. This will slow down the drying process and help avoid cracks and splits.

best regards,

Ed D.

Re: help! rough turned boxes splitting!

#4

Re: help! rough turned boxes splitting!

John Lucas

>I put them in a box. Might be my location but putting shavings in with them just caused mold. I also seal the end grain but I'm not sure it's needed I just have a habit of doing it. I think restricting the air movement is the most important.

Re: help! rough turned boxes splitting!

#5

I sound like a broken record.

Dave Smith, Longview, WA

>Soak the roughed out pieces in alcohol and wrap the pieces just like a roughed out bowl. Read the article in the Article Section if you are not familiar with the process. The roughed out boxes will be dry in less than a week with few failures. I tried the other methods and got tired of waiting. It works with or without pith. Half inch is probably thicker than is needed for that size box. I go 1/4" to 5/16" thick.

Email me if you need more help.

Dave Smith

I feel like the Ancient Mariner in Longview, WA.

Re: help! rough turned boxes splitting!

#6

Re: help! rough turned boxes splitting!

Jim Pugh, Ohio

>You will have more success if you put the rough outs into a brown paper grocery bag, fold the top over and put a clothspin on it. You can put several rough outs in one bag. Also, you have picked a wood that just loves to crack to it might improve your average if you could get your hands on some other hardwoods like ash, maple, cherry, elm....

As Dave Smith suggested, drying in the bag will take at least 3 months and longer is better. I have been using the philosophy that when the piece(s) have warped to their extreme, they are probably dry enough to finish turn. At my house that usually takes several months.

Oh yes, you will also help yourself if you put the bagged rough outs in the garage rather in the lower humidity house. Nature does things slowly and so must you.

Re: help! rough turned boxes splitting!

#7

Re: help! rough turned boxes splitting!

Jim King

>I know it will take your breath away the first time you do it but just boil one for a couple of hours and let it cool in the water before you take it out. It will be bone dry in a couple of weeks and ready to finish and will not crack.