Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Tear Out - Soften or Harden +/-

Posts

Tear Out - Soften or Harden +/-

#1

Tear Out - Soften or Harden +/-

Craig Daymon

>I have a couple of nice looking curly/lightly spalted maple blocks that I hope to turn into bowls with minimal tear out. To minimize tear out I am considering either hardening with wood hardener or softening with mineral oil. What are the pluses and minuses of each?

The spalting appears to be rather light and very dry at the moment, but has presented some nice mottled figure/coloration. The wood is supposed to be curly, big leaf maple, but the smell is "molasses/sweet" making me think it is sugar maple (any difference?).

I'm curious how each will effect finishing/color and which one will present the best work-a-bility.

Thanks,

Craig

Re: Tear Out - Soften or Harden +/-

#2

Depends

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Sometimes hardening works, sometimes lubricating works. I always go with hardening it first, because I'm not left over with any oil residue to deal with. Some of my finishes don't mix well with oil/wax/lubricants. I have a better chance of removing whatever I use if it is a hardening agent, like shellac or glue. I shy away from thin CA because it penetrates so readily and deeply. If you are using an "in the wood finish" like Watco, sometimes the CA'd areas will show when finished thusly. Yellow glue doesn't soak so far in, nor does a shellac. Shellac has the benefit of drying very quickly.

Rarely do I need to lubricate/oil as hardening usually works, but when necessary I'll use a bees or butcher's wax before moving to a more viscous solution.

Others have totally different experiences.

Re: Tear Out - Soften or Harden +/-

#3

Re: Tear Out - Soften or Harden +/-

Ed Karch in No.VA

>Molasses/sweet is probably from spalting/fermentation of sugars found in all woods. I usually go for hardening on maple.and other fine grain wood, but might go for softening on ring pourous if the wood is dry.

Ed

Re: Tear Out - Soften or Harden +/-

#4

Re: Depends

John Lucas

>I aqree with Mike and for the same reason. I do use thin CA glue on small areas but only if I'm going to turn most of it away because it will stain the wood. I use lacquer for a finish on my non functional bowls so I use thinned lacquer to stiffent the wood.

Re: Tear Out - Soften or Harden +/-

#5

Re: Depends

Craig Daymon

>I hadn't really considered shellac. I have plenty of that and I know it is safe under any finish, although it will prevent an oil from penetrating deeply. Then again, that might be a good thing since an oil finish might soak in too deep causing it to puddle out while drying. I guess shellac would be a lot friendlier to work with than Minwax Wood Hardener. (A friend thinks Minwax WH might be a thinned CA. (?))

Are there other downsides to shellac for this purpose aside from stopping penetration of a final oil-based finish? I know it's food safe, just not alcohol. (So much for a grog bowl.)

-Craig