Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

My take on Tormek and other grinders...>>>

Posts

My take on Tormek and other grinders...>>>

#1

My take on Tormek and other grinders...>>>

RonZ

>...>>> I apologize for not posting for a while. I have been marrying off my daughter and nursing a thumb injury. I lopped off the top of my left thumb. No, not in the woodshop but in the garden pruning grape vines. You never realize how essential a finger tip is until you can't use it.

Anyways, I think I can give a well rounded opinion on Tormek vs. other grinders as I have all three; high speed, slow speed, and Tormek.

If you can only afford one grinder, it’s preferable to get a slow speed or variable speed. Of course I'm referring to the 8"x1" models. Variable and slow speed grinders are not readily available here in Israel so my first one was high speed. This would be your last choice for a grinder. I also recommend a grinding jig if you don't have one. One of the biggest setbacks for the beginner is unsharpened tools. Later, at your leisure, you can learn to sharpen by hand. I have been turning for a living for around two and a half years and I just started to sharpen by hand after I learned from Raffan first hand how to do it. I still prefer a jig unless it is a finger nail grind.

A fast grinder will burn the ends quicker and eat up your tools faster. If you do use one you should put no finer grit than 80 for your sharpening stone. Higher grits will heat up faster. Your other should be 40 for shaping.

A variable speed would be the next choice. I don't know what the other speeds would be used for perhaps an owner of one can enlighten us. The one I own is from Taiwan and is the same one sold at Garrot Wade on sale for $260. While this is not cheap, this monster weighs in at 62lbs and runs ultra slow. In short if you have this machine or similar with a good grinding jig, you really don't need another.

So now you're asking, 'where does Tormek fit in?' Well, if you did carving for a living or sharpened tools for a living and were sharpening regular steel then the Tormek would be your first choice.

For woodturning, the Tormek is an excellent HONING machine. It’s best to use a grinder to shape and sharpen you tool and then hone it on the Tormek. If not, you'll be replacing that $140 wheel often. There is no question in my mind that the Tormek gives the best and longest lasting edge of any machine sharpener, the question is at what price. For a full time woodturner, one must weigh the extra time needed to use the Tormek vs. using a tool just off the grinder and the time it will take to resharpen your tool again. If you use the Tormek set up and labeling system, the time on the Tormek is greatly reduced. If you’re turning for a hobby and are blessed with additional income then the Tormek is a nice thing to have.

In short, the Tormek is nice but not a necessity.

Re: My take on Tormek and other grinders...>>>

#2

Re: My take on Tormek and other grinders...>>>

John Lucas

>Ron I bought one of the dual speed grinders. I never use the high speed. I thought I would try both and depermine for myself if High speed was better than slow speed. I personally don't see any advantage. It takes longer for the grinder to build up to speed. It heats the tool up easier, which isn't a problem for HSS other than it's easy to burn your fingers if you touch it. I tried sharpening both ways on my bowl gouge to see if I could tell a difference in the cut and I couldn't. Maybe microscopically it's better or if your using it to grind HSS metal lathe tools and turning metal but I spent the whole day turning bowls and would sharpen every other time on High, the Low. I could not tell the difference. So if you have a high speed grinder keep it. I wouldn't go out and buy a slow speed grinder just for sharpening lathe tools. However if your buying a new grinder and the price is the same I would go for the slow speed.

Re: My take on Tormek and other grinders...>>>

#3

Re: My take on Tormek and other grinders...>>>

Peter Toch

>High or low speed grinder is not the major question. I can "burn" a piece of tool steel on a low speed grinder just a fast as I can on a high speed one. There are two things that are the important issues in sharpening; 1) the type of wheels you are using, and 2) the amount of pressure you are applying to the tool against the wheel.

1) The best type of wheel to be using is one that is friable (the grinding media fractures readily under use constantly exposing fresh sharp edges for grinding) and that the binder (the "glue" that holds the wheel together) be on the soft to medium side. A good choice would be an aluminum oxide wheel with an "F" to around a "J" binder hardness. The color of the wheel, white or pink is not important here.

DO NOT USE THE GRAY SILICONE CARBIDE GRINDING WHEELS THAT TYPICALLY COME WITH MOST NEW GRINDERS. THESE ARE DESIGNED TO REMOVE LOTS OF METAL QUICKLY AND DO NOT GIVE A GOOD CUTTING EDGE!!!! This is just the opposite to what you are trying to accomplish.

2) When sharpening, most people instictively apply much to much pressure of the tool against the grinding wheel which leads to overheating. The weight of the tool is all that is needed. Use your hands to gently guide the tool over the wheel's surface and not to force it against the wheel. You will find the results very gratifying.

There many who are strong advocates of a slow speed grinder for sharpening. Oneway, the manufacture of the widely used Wolverine sharpening jig recommends a HIGH SPEED grinder!!! The High or Low speed arguement is one of those questions that if you ask two turners which is better, you'll get at least three different answers.

Peter Toch

Re: My take on Tormek and other grinders...>>>

#4

Re: My take on Tormek and other grinders...>>>

RonZ

>You're correct in your stone statement and it was lax of me not to mention what I use which are the blue friable stones with frequent use of a diamond dresser.

Being in my location gives me a unique view of things in the woodturning world whereas the US sometimes only sees 'oneway' of doing things. I've seen the Oneway recommendtion but I have also seen the Oneway video where they dunk HSS in water to cool it between sharpening which the overwhelming majority say not to do as it weakens the HSS. Slow speed grinding is conducive to hand sharpening where high speed is not.

At the Utah Symposium the only grinder available was slow speed as that's what all the turners such as Richard Raffan, Mike Mahoney, Allan ans Stuart Batty and many others prefer. When I took my course in Calgary with Raffan, he also complained about the high speed grinders. I personally prefer to trust turners with 30+ years experience over manufacturers.

I should put a disclaimer which I usually post; I post what I've learned and what works for me. My method is not the only way, it is what works best for me. I'm posting to share my knowledge and not to convert people to my methods. When one thinks he knows it all, he's doomed.

Re: My take on Tormek and other grinders...>>>

#5

Re: My take on Tormek and other grinders...>>>

Peter Toch

>Note that in my post I did not advocate the use of either a high or low speed grinder for sharpening turning tools. My point simply is that proper wheel composition and a light touch sharpening technique will govern the success of the sharpening much more so than the rpm of the grinder. I have used both high and low speeds very successfully. If one has a preference for one over the other, so be it.

Thanks for mentioning a point that I forgot to. That is that one should always keep the wheels clean and well dressed. This also greatly helps in efficient grinding and keeping the tool cooler.

Peter Toch