Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Lathe Advice Needed

Posts

Lathe Advice Needed

#1

Lathe Advice Needed

Michael Wangler in Rochester, NY

>Turners,

I am from the land of flat stock. I have a spot in the shop which I have allocated for the lathe I will buy someday...

I received a call from a friend's wife. This friend is also from the land of flat stock. She wants to buy him a lathe for his upcoming 40th birthday. She is asking for my advice. I am not sure I can give her proper advice without input.

The needs are probably pretty basic. I suspect something like the Jet 1236 or Grizzly 14 x 40 lathe would fit his initial needs. However I don't want to under equip him. His flat stock equipment is currently considered 'upgradeable' (6" jointer, contractor table saw, shop vac...) He would like to upgrade all of these tools some day. I would not want his initial turning tool to fall into this catagory after a year.

I understand that the lathe tools and accessories really make the lathe package complete. Would it be better to buy some really good turning tools and purchase a 'cheaper' lathe or buy a good lathe and a few tools?

The other limitation is the money. I suspect $500 may be the limit.

Any suggestion you could provide would be most appreciated.

Thanks much,

Michael

Re: Lathe Advice Needed

#2

Re: Lathe Advice Needed

georgetroy

>You almost need deep pockets for this hobby or profession> I would start him on the Nova DVR and be done with it. 16" swing, variable speed, 115 volts, 1 1/4 x 8 thread, Swivel head, can add on bed sections, fits in small space. Can set on top of bench, or make one for it. Outboard turning capacity. 5 year warranty. Spend about $2000.00 for one. Don't forget all the tools. As an occasional instructor and mentor, it's hard enough to teach someone, but when you have to fight a starter lathe, it makes the job so much tougher. Don't forget the cost of tools and supplies, etc. I know this is not what you wanted to here. Several sources for the DVR, a close one back east is Packard Woodworks. GT

Re: Lathe Advice Needed

#3

JL

Re: Lathe Advice Needed

JL

>What does he want to turn? For $500, it's difficult to get a quality large lathe (check the used market though). Many people have been happy with the small Jet Mini with variable speed and a bed extension. You figure about $360 for the lathe and $60 for the bed extension. That takes you to $420. With the extension, you can do up to 30-35" between centers and probably up to 10" in diameter for bowls and such. My $0.02

Re: Lathe Advice Needed

#4

Re: Lathe Advice Needed

John Lucas

>I'll agree with JL. I owned the old Delta 46-700 and have turned on the Jet 12". I don't think either one is that much better than the Jet mini with extension. They are a little heavier and have 3/4 horse motors, vs the jet's 1/2 horse but the Jet mini is a lot less expensive and let's you buy more tools and grinder, etc. You will probably upgrade in the future but this let's you find out if you really like turning.

Other than the Jet Mini I would step up to the next category above the Jet and Grizzly you are looking for and go with the Jet 14" or all the way to the Jet 16 or Nova DVR.

Re: Lathe Advice Needed

#5

Re: Lathe Advice Needed

John K Jordan

>I'd buy a better lathe and just a very few tools. He can add tools later if and when he is "hooked". Also, most experts recommend starting out with just a few basic tools (depending on the types of turning) and learn those very well before adding more tools.

Something everyone needs to get started in addition to the lathe is a good sharpening system. It can be a simple bench grinder with a good wheel but since sharpening the compound curves on a gouge by hand can be very difficult, it's best to get a jig for a gouge. A four-jaw chuck is extremely useful and makes lathe work far more enjoyable and efficient, but that's a significant additional expense. ($200+)

I understand almost everyone gets a small/cheap lathe to start out then upgrades when they outgrow it. (I certainly did) Unless you buy used, a budget of $500 will not get you much beyond that initial low-end lathe so future upgrading might by necessity be part of the plan.

The problem that I see besides the budget is if you buy an expensive lathe to start with you've wasted a lot of money if it you find out turning is not for you. In that respect, it might be better to start out with a gift certificate for some beginning woodturning courses at the local Woodcraft or one of those coveted multi-day courses with a pro in a resort setting in the mountains! I took a bowl-turning course once and one guy was there had never turned and was about to buy a lathe and the works. After the class he changed his mind!

Another thing is what kind of things will the prospective turner make? I'm not so sure anyone could make a wise decision without input from the guy himself! Is he interested in short things like bowls, pens and such, or will he make long things like table legs? A basic Jet mini with the stand is good for most everything but the table legs and would fit in the budget. The Jet 1236 would allow turning longer spindles but would probably break the budget when you add a few tools.

My experience: I didn't know any better so bought a very cheap tube lathe (from Home Depot) just to do some long spindles, got interested in turning, then bought a Jet 1642. The 1642 is likely all the lathe I'll ever need (although I'd like a second one some day!) If had been able to see the future I would have budgeted about $3000-$4000 at the start.

I gave the first lathe away but it was so cheap the learning experience was not too painful. I later bought a Jet mini as a second lathe for small work - it is far, far better than the tube lathe in power, features, precision, etc.

JKJ in East TN

Re: Lathe Advice Needed

#6

Lathe is only half the cost

Dave MacLuskie in VA

>Don't blow the whole budget on the lathe. Remember that there are tools, grinders/buffers, sand paper, chucks, lights, finishes... those all add up amazingly fast.

I have a Jet 1236 for what its worth. I want something bigger. I still think I did the right thing though. I'd hate to be sitting on a $3000 and decide I didn't like the hobby! I have just as many crazy impluses that result in dead ends.

Re: Lathe Advice Needed

#7

Re: Lathe is only half the cost

ChetB

>I had my Craftsman tube lathe for 25 years - but used if only infrequently when I needed a "round." Then tried the newer Craftsman variable speed 12". That was a bust with too much play in the planetary gears. So I went to the Jet 1236. It was an okay lathe, but too intermediate. Then I added the Jet Midi.

After all of the above, I believe the Jet Midi is the best bet for someone is learning and isn't yet committed to turning. All the <$500 lathes have the same problems with min speeds too high, non-reversing and insufficient mass for large work.

After four years of learning about serious turnig, I purchased a Powermatic 20" lathe. What a dream for a reasonable price. I would like a Oneway, but it's not within my budget. The Powermatic, in combination with the Jet Midi, work for me.

Anyway you look at it. The accessories remain a bottomless pit for $$$ after the lathe is purchased.

Re: Lathe Advice Needed

#8

Re: Lathe Advice Needed

David Propst

>If your friend is interested in bowls I would recommend the Jet Mini variable speed lathe for all the reasons folks have already listed here. If he wants to move up later, chances are he will also keep the mini.

If his interest is in spindles, the 1236 would be an OK choice given the budget.

Tools also depend on what he wants to do.

Before buying anything, the BEST present in my opinion would be to get him hooked up with a local turner for a few hours. Maybe she could find someone willing to give him a few lessons. My club has a mentor list and I bet if there is a club near you they do as well. The advice I got (and still get) on the Badger Pond forum and now here was and incredibly helpful as a new turner.

Best Regards,

David