Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Stopper tops won't come off the mandrel

Posts

Stopper tops won't come off the mandrel

#1

Stopper tops won't come off the mandrel

Joe Pack

>I am turning a bunch (100+) of bottle stoppers for some upcoming shows. The style I am now using has a 3/8" thread that screws into the top. The instructions tell me to drill a 5/16 hole in the blank, then thread the blank onto a 3/8" threaded mandrel, which, theoretically, cuts the requisite threads into the blank. The blank goes on quite tight, but then, during turning and finishing on the lathe, tightens up so much more that it is all but impossible to unscrew it without messing up the finish. Some have been so tight that I have had to use channel locks around a pad to remove the blank.

I see on one web page that some folks use a 3/8" tap to manually thread the blank before mounting the blank on the 3/8" mandrel. This might make the threading on easier, but will it eliminate the overtightening while being turned and finished?

Any ideas on how to eliminate this problem of overtightening?

Re: Stopper tops won't come off the mandrel

#2

Re: Stopper tops won't come off the mandrel

Al Crandall--NE of Indy--

>First thing I'd try is one of those flat pieces of rubber which your wife has in a kitchen drawer. She puts it over the pickle or mayonaise jar lid to give a better grip on it before twisting it off. The next thing I'd try is one of those cheap strap wrenches from harbor freight. I use them to loosen some of my shop made vacuum chucks when they won't let go. I doubt if you need a third option.

Re: Stopper tops won't come off the mandrel

#3

Re: Stopper tops won't come off the mandrel *LINK*

John K Jordan

>Would a little wax on the threads help?

I like the idea of cutting the threads first. Note that if you don't have a tap the right size you can make a simple one very quickly with a small triangular file by filing a few groves across the threads at the end of a bolt. I file at an angle rather than straight down the shaft, but it probably doesn't matter much.

Another thing - is it possible to deviate from the instructions and turn the wood on a pin chuck in a smooth hole, then thread it on the hardware later? A pin chuck is very easy to make - it's just a short rod with a flat and a small pin. The pin rolls on the flat and tightens in the hole. The rod can be held in a Jacob's chuck.

JKJ in East TN


example pin chuck

Re: Stopper tops won't come off the mandrel

#4

Wax the threads

John Lucas

>I think the wax will work. I have used a candle to wax my screw center when feeding it in really hard wood.

I use a homemade pin chuck for my wine stoppers but then I use dowels and corks. I am planning on using Ruth's new stoppers if I ever get around to ordering them. Maybe this will remind me to send her a check today. If I'm not a master at procrastinating I must have at least a Brown belt in the art.

Re: Stopper tops won't come off the mandrel

#5

Re: Stopper tops won't come off the mandrel

CapeMayMike

>Hi Joe,

I assume you're using the BS-1 style stopper and matching chuck. I drill my blanks with a 21/64" bit and occasionally have one that doesn't want to budge. You say 3/8" so perhaps you're using something different. As John mentioned I use rubber, though it's the rubber from a strap wrench. I then apply, as gently as possible, pliers around this and also a wrench on the chuck, operating in opposite directions this will remove the stopper. Two things, if you've turned coves and have sharp edges, be careful, they will cut your hand when trying to remove one that is stuck. Also, if you've turned a narrow neck or cove, try not to apply force above this, you may twist off that portion.

Re: Stopper tops won't come off the mandrel

#6

Re: Stopper tops won't come off the mandrel

Peter Toch

>Hi Joe:

I ran into the same problem that you are having. The solution I came up with is as follows:

1) Get a 3/8" dia. hex head bolt which has approx. 1" of threads on the end and about a 2-3" unthreaded portion towards the head. Cut off the bolt head leaving about 1-1/2" of the untreaded bolt. This now is your mandrel.

2) Use a drill chuck in your lathe's headstock to mount the unthreaded portion of your mandrel.

3) Thread TWO 3/8" nuts onto the mandrel such that you leave a couple of bare threads on the mandrel between nuts and the headstock. With a couple of small wrenches lock the two nuts against each other (turn one clockwise and the other counter-clockwise).

4) Pre-drill the blank with a 5/16" hole and then tap it with a 3/8" tap as you have been.

5) Thread the blank onto the mandrel until it snugs up against the two nuts which are locked together.

6) Turn your stopper to the desired shape, sand and finish as usual. The stopper will have tightened itself onto the mandrel during the turning and finishing process as you have experienced in the past.

7) To easily remove the finished stopper, using a small wrench, thread the nut closest to the headstock towards the headstock a couple of turns, next thread the nut against the stopper a couple of turns towards the headstock also. This will release the pressure on the stopper's threads, making the stopper easy to remove.

Have fun, Peter Toch

Re: Stopper tops won't come off the mandrel

#7

wax works good

jared

>remove 1 for email

I had similar problems. Drill the hole too large and it strips out, drill it too small and it is too tight. I rub a little candle wax on the threads of the mandrel before the blank is screwed on. I drill the hole the size that is recommended, mine is from Berea Hardwoods, I do not prethread the blank. I use one of those rubber jar lid looseners and have had no problems since. Jared

Re: Stopper tops won't come off the mandrel

#8

Re: Stopper tops won't come off the mandrel

Ron in Drums PA

>I tap the blanks.

I turn off the lathe then insert the tap while the lathe is slowing down.

Never had one stick... yet

Re: Stopper tops won't come off the mandrel

#9

Re: Stopper tops won't come off the mandrel

Rick Allen

>I have used two methods.

1. apply a finishing wax to the threads before mounting.

2. Thread the square stock on the mandril, dismount part way till is unscreews easly and then mount back on. Simular to the taping idea but a bit faster to acomplish.

Re: Stopper tops won't come off the mandrel

#10

Great ideas.

Joe Pack

>Thanks, folks. Some great ideas here. I will play with them this week to find the one that works best for me, then, hopefully, crank up production this weekend. I just ordered another 100, so (1) I hope things go smoothly, and (2) I hope I sell them! :-)

Re: Stopper tops won't come off the mandrel

#11

Re: Stopper tops won't come off the mandrel

Barry Irby

>I would try chucking a tap, screwing a nut that fits the tap on, drill the correct size hole in the blank, screw it on against the nut, turn it, back the nut off a half turn and unscrew the finished piece. Same Idea as the guy earlier who used two nuts locked against each other, but why not just lock one up against the blank. Might work better if you screw the blank on and then tighten the nut a tenth of a turn.

Let us know what works. I'm getting ready to try a few myself.

Re: Stopper tops won't come off the mandrel

#12

Not a Good Idea ;-)

Ed Thomas, Leaside (Toronto) Ontario

>Using a tap as a mandrel would fall in the realm of using a skew or scraper ground from a file. Both the tap and file are very brittle due to their hardness. One good catch, or maybe even a little one, and ...

Better to tap it off lathe with the tap in a reversible drill and the block in a vise. It would only take a moment.