Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Mahogany Bowl

Posts

Mahogany Bowl

#1

Mahogany Bowl

Dick Parr

>Here is some mahogany that was given to me by a new neighbor that just retired from the navy and has been carrying it around since getting it from the Philippines where is was stationed.

It is 6" x 3" x 3/16" thick and is finished by using the beall buffing system. I have enough to make maybe 4 more this size.

Thanks for looking

Dick in Knoxville


img

Re: Mahogany Bowl

#2

Re: Mahogany Bowl, Bottom 

Dick Parr

>


img

Re: Mahogany Bowl

#3

JL

Re: Mahogany Bowl

JL

>Great grain, nice profile. Like the knot and the knot hole. Was it a pain to turn?

Re: Mahogany Bowl

#4

Re: Mahogany Bowl

John Lucas

>Dick, very nicely done. I like the shape and the finish. I want to ask a question of the group. This is not a critic or your piece which I think is quite nice just a question on design as it relates to grain and figure in wood.

On your first photo we see the heart is just barely out of the wood. This creats little curved grain lines that are interupted by the edge. I find that my eye goes straight to this as a visual point of reference. We all do this, myself included. I have made bowl where I purposely shortened the bowl to get rid of this. My question is how do you all feel. It is better to have a taller bowl (assuming the form is good) with this grain orientation or do you think it would look better shortened. It would obviously require a redesign of the shape to match the lower bowl.

On a green wood bowl you will get a raised warp in this area. Some like this and some don't. What do you think?

Re: Mahogany Bowl

#5

I try for 3/4" minimum from pith to rim.

Al Crandall--NE of Indy--

>

Re: Mahogany Bowl

#6

JL

Re: Mahogany Bowl

JL

>Wouldn't it depend on the relative fragility of the pith and the heartwood? I think that a design element, be it a knot (or knot hole) or the grain figure adds and gives definition to a piece.

I mean - you can go for pure form and a delicacy of shape as your design element - or you can utilize the design opportunities inherent in a piece of wood. Take some of the Norfolk Island Pine bowls as an example. Your eyes gravitate to the knots - all of them. I think that in Dick's piece the circular grain of the heartwood and the knots and grain swirl around the knots give several focal points for attention so that you end up really studying the piece.

(And we now all say auummmm and start to commune with the wood).

My $0.02.

Re: Mahogany Bowl

#7

Re: Mahogany Bowl

John Lucas

>Dick I just looked at your bowl again. I really like the beads on the bottom . They give it a base and I think they work with the grain to help give it some lift. Good detail.

Re: Mahogany Bowl

#8

Re: Mahogany Bowl

Kevin Turner

>I like the challenge of the knots. The finish really brings out the colours of the grain. To the questions floating around... Is it not what the turner sees (him or herself) creating out of the piece(s)..As some one mentioned, its' a matter of skill and their own taste of design. ( My cdn 2 cents).... Kevin T in T Bay

Re: Mahogany Bowl

#9

Re: Mahogany Bowl

Dick Parr

>Thank you everyone for the kind words.

Great question John and I surprise myself that I did look at what you were saying while I was turning this down. At first I was going to take it down some to remove a little more from the pith, but when looking at the opposite side of the bowl, it would mean removing the knot closest to the edge which I didn't want to do unless the knot came out during the turning. I don't think it would have looked as good with just two holes in it, the one hole was good as long as the knot stayed in.

Having been told that this wood was at least 10 years old and very dry, I didn't think it would have any problems with moving after it was done. I guess it would depend on what side of the bowl you looked at first. Attached is a picture showing the opposite side.

Having only turned bowls for about 10 months, I am surprised that I did actually see that and thought about it. In fact 4 months ago I would not have known what you were talking about.

Thanks again everyone.

Dick


img

Re: Mahogany Bowl

#10

Re: Mahogany Bowl

Dick Parr

>JL it was only because I wanted to keep the top knot in and not loose it. The wood is very dry and was nice to turn.

This is the piece of wood my neighbor gave me. It is one of 2 or 3 pieces he has been carrying around with him for years. I will make him a bowl from this and hope to maybe get another piece since he does not have a lathe. :-)


img

Re: Mahogany Bowl

#11

Re: Mahogany Bowl

Dick Parr

>JL, What I meant to say was, it was hard to turn only because I wanted to keep the top knot in and not loose it. So I was being very careful.

Re: Mahogany Bowl

#12

Re: Mahogany Bowl

John Lucas

>Dick I would have made the same decision. If you cut the rim down any it would either eat into the knot which wouldn't look good or you would have to shorten it beyond the knot which would really change the bowl. Interesting decision.

Re: Mahogany Bowl

#13

Re: Mahogany Bowl

Tom Sweeney - Coatesville, PA

>Hey Dick,

Glad to see you putting that new lathe to good use :-)

That is really an exquisite piece. This last pic really shows off the relationship of the knot & the knot hole - you're right it really is an important part of the design. Very nice job on the form & finish as well.

Re: Mahogany Bowl

#14

White banjo?

Carole in VA

>Dick, what's that white banjo on your Nova? Hoping not to hear that the original broke or was unsatisfactory! :)

Very nice piece, BTW. I have one bowl I have turned from Mahogany, but it would look much better if it had knots like yours! They give it so much character.