Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Just picked up some lathe chisels

Posts

Just picked up some lathe chisels

#1

Just picked up some lathe chisels

Ned Bulken

>Since I'm joining the world of round work, I knew I was going to need a set of chisels. This evening I picked up a vintage set of Disston-Porter lathe chisels, included are a 1" Skew, 1/2" skew, 1/2" parting tool, 1/2" spear point, 1/4" gouge 1/2" gouge, 1/2" Round Nose and a 3/4" Gouge. Met up with a fellow from over on Woodworking.org, who let me have these for $80, and he freshly sharpened them on his Tormek while we traded wood stories. Oh, and I also got a Stanley #7 which he tuned up. The handles were a little rough, so he threw in a replacement handles kit. He also let me take home a #4 (unknown manufacturer, but brand new and nicely tuned also). I also brought along my little block plane, which he tuned up for me as well. Total for the evening was $150. As an added bonus, he threw in a couple of pieces of 1/2" thick brazilian Cherry (jatoba?) and a couple of salvaged but nice maple cabinet doors with euro hinges.

So how did I do? I have no idea on the chisels, feel comfortable with the whole purchase, and considering that he sharpened them all up tonight on his tormek, I couldn't be happpier. One 'small' problem, now I want a tormek... and he has more planes he's putting up on Ebay...

Re: Just picked up some lathe chisels

#2

Re: Just picked up some lathe chisels

John K Jordan

>>vintage set of Disston-Porter lathe chisels

>So how did I do?

I'm not personally familiar with Disston-Porter tools, but are they carbon steel or high-speed steel? Most tools today are HSS since those made from carbon steel don't hold up nearly as well for turning. In addition, HSS tools can be sharpened on a normal grinder without the constant danger of blueing the edge and ruining the temper of the steel. (Much care or something like the Tormak would be helpful)

BTW, I use the Tormak and love it. Some have other opinions. It is slower but it provides a wonderful edge.

If the tools are HSS, I think you got a great deal. (It is sometimes marked on the steel or handle) Some of the better tools are $80 each, new. If they are not HSS, you might need that Tormak very soon. :)

JKJ in East TN

Re: Just picked up some lathe chisels

#3

Re: Just picked up some lathe chisels

Don Henthorn

>You are the one who counts, If you think it was a good deal, then it was. I got along for forty years with carbon steel Buck Bros. chisels and never felt like I had poor tools. Sharpen often and they will serve you well.

Re: Just picked up some lathe chisels

#4

Re: Just picked up some lathe chisels

JamieDonaldson

>I would advise buying HSS bowl gouges when you really start turning in quantity, and the other tools you mentioned will be serviceable in carbon steel. The biggest problem with the Tormek is the cost of all the special jigs, and it's not the best for quickly sharpening HSS.

Re: Just picked up some lathe chisels

#5

Re: Just picked up some lathe chisels

Ned Bulken

>I believe they are not HSS, but I'll use them to learn on and when I Outgrow them I'll replace individually with HSS. Just part of the learning curve. I'm reading up on sharpening and so forth, and I'll just have to learn how to do it the right way won't I? In the meantime, I'm happy with the purchase, and my friend will resharpen on his tormek as needed. Albeit not 'immediately' but he can rescue me if I change the angles too much.

Re: Just picked up some lathe chisels

#6

Re: Just picked up some lathe chisels

John Lucas

>Ned I would be happy with the purchase and your idea of using them up and then buying Hss is good. I think buying old tools is one of the best ways to learn to sharpen. You don't have to worry about ruining a good tool so you sharpen often. Learn to use a light touch on the grinder and you won't overheat the tools and will learn a lot.

My best friend has turned thousands of pieces and he still uses Buck Brothers carbon steel tools. You do have to sharpen more often but then this improves your sharpening technique.

Re: Just picked up some lathe chisels

#7

Re: Just picked up some lathe chisels

Ned Bulken

>John,

My point exactly, we haven't always had HSS tools, and look at how much great work was done. I really won't mind sharpening more often, technique is built with practice.

Re: Just picked up some lathe chisels

#8

Re: Just picked up some lathe chisels

John K Jordan

>>I really won't mind sharpening more often...

Note that since the bevels are ground concave you can hone many times between sharpenings to maintain a very sharp edge. Some people use the credit-card sized diamond hones. I tried that but find I get more control with the smaller "paddle" type - a small diamond hone mounted on a flat plastic paddle handle. Hold the handle with the forefinger backing up the honing surface for control and hone with both the tip and heel of the bevel in contact with the diamond surface. You can feel when it is placed correctly. One book suggests you can hone three times between sharpenings but I do it far more than that.

As for the Tormak, it is expensive but I think it is well worth the money. I bit the bullet and bought the option with the entire set of jigs. Besides lathe tools, I've sharpened knives, sissors, chisels, plane irons, a pen mill, etc. I found it more efficient to get a second support bar so I didn't have to move it from front to back. I'd like to get a second jig for the skew chisel to keep one set exactly for my favorite 1/2" skew. A nice thing about using the Tormak is even a rank beginner can restore a perfect grind the first time. The bad thing about using the Tormak is it takes FOREVER to reshape a thick tool, especially HSS. I spent hours trying to reshape one large skew chisel. For that, I now go first to a conventional slow-speed bench grinder then finish on the Tormak.

Remember that scrapers are different. The edge should be rolled with a hardened tool much like a cabinet scraper. I do this several times between sharpenings as well.

Another thing about sharpening - if you need to sharpen but don't want to bug your friend, you might get it done elsewhere. For example, our local Woodcraft store will sharpen on their Tormak for a small fee.

BTW, the first lathe tools I had was a cheap set from Sears. I got a lot of mileage from them and still use some. Often old tools, especially scrapers, can be reground for special applications, for example to make a captive ring tool.

JKJ in East TN