We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I'm not sure how to phrase this question. I kinda wanta ask how many of you that are making money at this are doing it by the book. But I don't want anyone to fess up to illeagel activity in an open form. I know a bowl sold here and there is just a hobby. My tax guy tells me that any net profit over $400 dollars a year is income from a business and should be reported as such. This also means collecting sales tax etc. because you get put on the governments radar. What are your thoughts about this?
>I don't recall any exact figure that defines a business rather than a hobby, but there are tax advantages for deducting expenses with a business classification. I have been using a good CPA to keep me out of tax trouble for many years, and I recommend consulting a qualified expert whenever you need answers you and I don't know.
Jamie's suggestion to consult a professional is a good one. But it is possible to deal with this yourself, I've been doing it for several years. So here's my $0.02, take it for what it's worth:
First of all, the tax law requires that you report income whether you earned it as a business or not. Income is income. The advantage (to you) of reporting as a business is that you can deduct tools, supplies, and a whole bunch of other stuff. Plus, depreciation. So to some extent, it depends on how much you've put into this hobby/business and how willing you are to wade through some tax law instructions. Prior to filing as a small business, I reported income from my turnings as "other" on my 1040A. Yeah, I know, everybody has some small amount of income that they don't report at all. But keep in mind - if you get audited, there is the CHANCE that the auditor will ask you directly if you had income from selling any woodturnings. You will then be in the postition of either (a)having to lie to a federal agent, or (b) admit that you falsified a tax return. If you do the latter, the penalty will most likely not be severe. Some extra tax, some penalty fees. All the same, it's an experience that most of us would not want to have and the way to avoid it is by reporting the income.
There is no threshold number for filing as a business, and the IRS instruction books for Schedule C make that pretty clear. By the way, all forms and books are easily (well, sort of easily) downloaded from the IRS website. There really isn't any hard and fast rule for determining whether you're legitimately a business or not, the IRS has deliberately left this issue in an ambiguous state. But one of their criteria, one that they're pretty firm about, is this - if you're claiming to be a business, have you shown a profit in three of the last five years? If not, they are very likely to say that what you're doing is a hobby and disallow any Schedule C deductions for that year (the year in which this comes up for discussion). So, you can deduct a whole bunch of stuff during the first two years and take losses, but the next year (and the following years) you should start showing a gain. In my third year, I deliberately did NOT claim a couple of legitimate deductions because I wanted to show a gain on Schedule C that year. It wasn't much, but it was a gain and it got me off the hook for the "three out of five" rule.
I don't think that filing a Schedule C is all that difficult. It's about as complicated as itemizing your deductions on your 1040A, except for depreciation of equipment. That takes a different form and a sligthly complicated formula. As with many things pertaining to the IRS, the secret to getting through filing the forms is to just fill it out. Don't try to make sense out of it, just fill the form out according to the instructions.
If you file as a business, you can legitimately deduct the cost of tools, supplies, mileage to attend meetings, seminar fees, AAW membership fees, books, and more. For me, it's worth it. I'm now to the point where my profits way exceed my deductions, but I'm still paying much less tax than if I reported the income under "other", the way I used to.
>I can only speak for myself, but the math and formulas are crazy here in Canada. - but the boss keeps the books... she stated that the hardess part was eventually finding a parking spot...to pay the tax collected.. People ( here in Canada) I found out if you have a name , other than your personal one on a sign, business cards etc... You can be charged and made to remove said items from a show, if it hasn't be registered. We in the north must collect one tax( provincal) until we hit the magic number of ( I believe) it is $30 000 then we charge both a goods and services tax and the provinal tax. Sorry for rambling. Kevin T
I'm relatively new to turning and never intended to make money. However, I found myself making a bunch from selling magic wands - Harry Potter fans are wild and crazy!
My accountant said that money needed to be reported as income, but he could take care of it as a small business, perhaps include it with existing business income. I leave all that up to him.
However, a discussion here some time back posed a bigger problem. It was suggested that if you sell one thing you made in your home shop, your homeowner's insurance may no longer cover the shop, i.e., if it burned down they may not pay. I believe it was necessary to buy business insurance which was quite expensive, or take advantage of a special insurance available to woodturners. Sadly I slipped up and didn't save the discussion. Can someone fill in the blanks?
If you are investigating turning your hobby into a business, not only do you need to learn about the tax issues, you need to learn about the insurance issues. If you start to report income and claim deductions as a business, you need to make sure that your homeowner's insurance carrier knows what you are doing. You may or may not be covered, and you may need to look into a business policy. Insurance companies will take any opportunity they can find to avoid paying on a claim, and if you are running a business where you are not allowed to under the terms of their policy, you will not be covered for the business, and you may not be covered for any domestic loss. Please note, I am not an insurance agent, I just pay lots of money to them. A friend of mine does this full time, and he is covered by his homeowner's policy with a little extra premium paid because his shop is in his basement (i.e. attached). I have the same company providing my homeowner's insurance, but they would not insure my business because my shop is detached.
Back to taxes. We do not use a professional accountant. We did that once and had things so messed up SWMBO had to do them all over again. I know that is probably the exception, but we excepted it even further, since she took a bunch of accounting classes at the college she used to work at, and now keeps the books for my business. Whether you want to be a business or not, some states will require that you collect sales tax if you are selling items, especially at craft shows. If you do a show in the People's Republic of New Jersey, they actually have people who come around to see if you have a tax license, and if you do not have the appropriate papers, they will confiscate your stuff on the spot!
So, there is lots to learn, and it all takes away from time in the shop. However, if it is the way you want to go, good luck with getting it all together.
>Don't know about other locations, but here, with any business you have to list all the "business" equipment (in other words, just about everything you use to produce anything you sell) which is then subject to a business property tax. Yes, you can just not tell them about it, but if you do that you better not claim that equipment as a deduction. They get you coming and going. Won't be long before they try to tax that part of your brain you use to produce goods or services you sell!
>Thanks for the info guys. I didn't think about insurance, I will check into that. I am not sure if I want this to be a business or not. I am sure that I don't want it to be work! I just don't want to be looking for the tax man to pop up telling me I am in volation of some strange rule. I have always heard that ignorance of the law is no excuse, but it sure seems like a lot of people are still trying to use that defense! I guess I just don't want to be one of them. If I do sell something, I want it to be legal and above board.
>Bill is definitely right about the tax man coming to visit at shows, especially those held on state property. Be prepared to act like a businessman, and knowing the right words will keep things smooth.
You might want to try this for a couple years without becoming a business identity. You will have a lot of company in doing it this way. Keep it small, attend a couple shows and art fairs, and sell a few things. Keep it legal and claim the income on your 1040 to satisfy the IRS; pay your State income tax, and send a check to the State for sales taxes for the amount claimed. Don't claim any expenses.
Don't forget the liability risk. Check with your insurance agent to determine the limits of your homeowners policy. You might need additional insurance coverage if you are going to be selling anything more than a couple bowls to friends or a few trinkets at your Church bazzar. The AAW has a policy available for artists that might suit your needs.
You will know when it is time to move this venture into becoming a business. When that time comes, if ever, seek assistance in getting through the maze of agencies and taxes.
Due diligence in the persuit of a profit is the most important aspect of the business. Set it up as a business with the proper licenses, tax identities, depreciation schedules, insurances, accounting and records system, checking account, a business and marketing plan, a marketing budget, and all of those other things that identify you as a business. Looking like and acting like a business is more important than the profit you might make.
>Russ just stated exactly what I do. That's the way I handle it. My insurance wasn't bad but I'm going to look into the AAW policy when this one runs out.
>When I started my part time business making various hand tools (marking knives, awls, plane adusting hammers, etc) I decided that right from the start I would go legit. I chose my name (Chester Toolworks) and registered it with the state of NH as an LLC. Even though I had no employees I got a federal employer ID number. I went out and purchased Quickbooks Pro for accouonting software and generally set up all of the systems as a business.
All of what I did was for a variety of reasons pertaining to the tax advantages of being a legally recognized business, there are some great deductions there folks. I also felt that being recognized by both the state and federal governments would make life easier since I export some of my tools to Germany and Canada. I also don't have to worry about looking over my shoulder to see if there's a chance that I might get caught as a tax cheat. I hate taxes about as much as everyone else, but if you're serious about being a business you do owe your share. One of the major advantages of living in NH is that I don't have to worry about collecting sales tax on what I sell anywhere. We have no sales tax, and that makes bookkeeping that much simpler.
>Hi Bruce, a couple of thoughts....if you sell your work through a gallery, you must report sales, as the gallery certainly will claim payments to you as an expense. Similarly, if you receive payment for teaching, you must claim that as income. In both cases, you should receive a statement from the schools or galleries.
>Thanks Keith, I believe I understand that part. Outside inities that use my services will either give me a w2 or 1099 form. I'm thinking more about having to collect sales tax and reporting income from personal sales or sales at a craft fair. Here in Indiana (the land of taxes) it appears that the only way to give the governor his sales tax is to be a registered merchant and of course pay a fee. It appears like you must then decide your business structure (sole prop, partnership, etc.) and also file paper work on that. Again another fee. For the guy doing the rare sale the whole thing appears rather messy.