Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Watco Finish question.

Posts

Watco Finish question.

#1

Watco Finish question.

Barry Irby

>I have asked this before, but let me try again. I turned some walnut stools and sanded them to 400. Client wanted Watco. I use Natural and applied a number of coats. They have reached the point they take days to dry, but I still have spots that are dull and some that are somewhat glossy. The glossy parts are beautiful. Great depth. I am tired of Watco and would like to put something else over it that will complete the gloss and dry more quickly. Any suggestions? What is compatible? Also, Is the Watco durable and tough after it dries?

I don't think you should start building a Watco finish after you

reach 55.

As an alternative, should I strip them back down and start over? With what?

Re: Watco Finish question.

#2

Suggestion...

Peter Teubel

>I use Woodcraft Urethane Oil. Its a mixture of BLO and poly. Great depth, fast build to a glossy shine, and fast drying.

Re: Watco Finish question.

#3

Re: Watco Finish question.

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Barry, at this point you may want to use a thinned coat of shellac over top of the watco - as long as it isn't sticky. Afterwards, knock it back some with 320 grit. The watco will take more evenly, and your coats will build much more quickly.

I used to, on flat stuff, use oil first to highlight the grain, then a coat of shellac, then use watco again. Saves about 3 years' worth of applying coats, old man.

Watco is extremely durable and easy to repair when needed.

You may want to switch to Waterlox. It builds much more quickly.

Re: Watco Finish question.

#4

Re: Watco Finish question.

Jack Savona

>I have come to really like Bush Oil. I think it's BLO with a varnish (???). Apply liberally, wait 30 min, not much more. Wipe off. Wipe off AGAIN! Recoats in 24 hrs. I Beall after a week or two.

Jack

Re: Watco Finish question.

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: Watco Finish question.

Keith Tompkins

>Bush Oil? Bill Bush is from my neck of the woods!...He's is an excellent craftsman.

Re: Watco Finish question.

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: Watco Finish question.

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Barry, one thing you may consider is mixing up a small batch of Watco mixed with polyurethane. I have done that in the past, also pure tung oil mixed with poly works well.

Re: Watco Finish question.

#7

Re: Bush Oil.

Jack Savona

>I picked up the Bush kit at a special price at the Totally Turning Symposium last October.

Re: Watco Finish question.

#8

Re: Watco Finish question.

Richmondwoodturner

>Barry,

My son has finished several pieces successfully with Watco. The trick, although time consuming, was to sand the oil with 600 wet or dry paper every 20 minutes until dry. He, unlike me, was religious about it. He has no shiny spots. I do.

Mike Lane

Re: Watco Finish question.

#9

Re: Watco Finish question.

Don Henthorn

>Sorry, Russ, but Watco does contain resin. If you put on enough coats you can build up a finish as full as if you had used regular varnish. I have seen turned pieces with as many as sixteen coats of Watco and they were as shiny and nice as one could hope for. I could never understand why anyone would take the time to put on that many coats to get the solids build up they wanted when regular varnish would have done it in two or three caots.

Re: Watco Finish question.

#10

Re: Watco Finish question.

Russ Fairfield

>I just removed my previous message because there could be some wrong and confusing information in there. I will defer to Dresdner because he has been a consultant to one or more of the makers of Watco Oil finishes for several years.

One of the problems with any discussion is the definition of the term "resins", a word that means different things to different people. Each manufacturer has their own definition of a "resin". Some of them define the solids in the drying oil as a resin. Others will define resins as those of the hard phenolics and polyurethanes. Others just lie about their being there. All of them, except those at the high-end of the price range, keep their contents a secret.

A problem specific to the Watco products has to do with them being made by several different manufacturers in the last few years, and every one of them changed the ingredients for their own reasons.

In the end we use what we use, and for our own reasons. I don't plan on a Watco Oil for a gloss finish. That is best done with the surface build from a finish whose contents are known to contain real varnish resins, either phenolic or polyurethane. This can be either a commercial product or one that I make myself.

Re: Watco Finish question.

#11

my reply got deleted as well *LINK*

John K Jordan

>Russ,

Somehow, my reply to your message was also deleted, perhaps accidentally. I've restored it below for completeness.

I recently was reminded that a material safety data sheet (MSDS) is required by law to be available to anyone who purchases a product. I looked up the MSDS for Watco oil and it listed "resin" as one of the non-hazerdous components. ( http://www.woodnshop.com/MSDS_SHEETS/WATCONATGAL.htm ) The MSDS did not specify the type of resin. Could this be because none of the different types of resin you mention are classified as "non-hazerdous" so they can be lumped together under one term?

I have a lot to learn. I'm trying to compile information on various finishes for my own use and to help all of us. How can I find out about the different types of things called "resin"? I thought resin was resin. (This is a confusing hobby!)

JKJ in East TN

Previous message:

--------------------------------------------------------------

>Watco is an oil finish that has no varnish resins...

I'm still trying to understand all this. Where does this information come from? The message in the link (from the flat side) indicates the opposite:

"Watco is an oil based finish that contains a substantial amount of resin. That makes it a varnish of sorts, though a fairly thin one."

I looked up the MSDS which indicates Natural Watco Danish Oil contains at least:

- Raw Linseed Oil

- Resin

- Zirconium Drier

- Mineral Spirits

The message referenced in the link below indicates the Watco oil formulation has changed at some point. Perhaps an earlier version had no resin?

JKJ in East TN

--------------------------------------------------------------


Message: Unconfusing Watco

Re: Watco Finish question.

#12

Re: my reply got deleted as well

John K Jordan

>Oh, I see what happened to my reply. When Russ's removed his message it apparently "orphaned" my reply to that message and made it a thread by itself. I found it further down. That's a bit confusing! I've seen other orphaned messages here and wondered how that happened.

JKJ in East TN