Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Long shot, but

Posts

Long shot, but

#1

Long shot, but

Carole in VA

>I thought I'd ask anyway. I have searched around trying to identify this small log, but I don't have much to work with. When cut green it is a very bright orangy-yellow, quickly mellowing to pinkish brown. The bark is smooth and I can only describe the limb as "muscular" in appearance. It turns easily and has open grain much like mahogany. Location is in eastern VA if that's any help. I suspect it is more of a shrub-like tree. Any ideas?


img

Re: Long shot, but

#2

2nd pic

Carole in VA

>I grabbed that little log as a practice piece but it turned into a keeper. This after oiling. DOn't know it you will be able to see the grain or not.


img

Re: Long shot, but

#3

Re: Long shot, but

W.C. Turner

>Looks like Bradford Pear

Re: Long shot, but

#4

Re: Long shot, but

Rick Allen

>My vote is cherry.

Re: Long shot, but

#5

Re: Long shot, but

Ed Karch in No.VA

>Muscle wood? (hop hornbeam). How hard is it?

Ed

Re: Long shot, but

#6

Re: Long shot, but

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Looks like a fruitwood but the bark does not resemble bradford pear.

Re: Long shot, but

#7

Re: Long shot, but

Carole in VA

>It's pretty hard. I know it is not cherry or pear.

Re: Long shot, but

#8

Bradford Pear?

David Propst

>Looks like the Bradford pear I have turned and have growing in my yard. It is a hard, very easy turning wood.

David

Re: Long shot, but

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: Long shot, but

Keith Tompkins

>Beech? Does it have rays similar to oak?

Re: Long shot, but

#10

George Balock

Osage Orange or Mullberry?

George Balock

>

Re: Long shot, but

#11

Re: Long shot, but

Carole in VA

>Not really. I think the key is the very bright orange/yellow when cut green. It is more orange than mulberry or osage (I have had both of those) and does not have the bark of either. From the bark and characteristics, I am guessing hophornbeam or hornbeam, but I can find nothing about those having the color. I will probably label the goblet Hornbeam anyway! LOL

Re: Long shot, but

#12

Re: Osage Orange or Mullberry?

John Lucas

>Definitely not Osage or Mulberry. The bark isn't even close.

Re: Long shot, but

#13

Re: Long shot, but

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>If it's open grained, like mahogany, that inequivocally rules out beech, all fruitwoods including cherry and pear, hornbeam and hophornbeam.

The problem with identifying it from a photo is that a picture of the whole log doesn't give much information. It's the details that are important. Instead, you should try to get closeup photos of the bark and the leaves, and especially important, an extreme closeup of the endgrain, after you have planed it smooth with a very sharp plane.

I agree with John that it is not mulberry or hedge. Even at the resolution of your photos, the strongly ring porous character of these should be obvious.

It might be Chinese elm, but I can't tell for sure from the resolution of the bark photo. Chinese elm would have reddish, horizontal rows of warty ridges on the bark.

Re: Long shot, but

#14

Looks like persimmon to me.

Dave Smith, Longview, WA

>

Re: Long shot, but

#15

Re: Long shot

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Think you're going to find that it gets about hard a concrete when dry because I think you've got a piece of eastern dogwood or related species. A beautiful turning wood when wet (comes off in streamers), that just chips when dry. Bark looks right, and the pink color change would also be correct. Dogwood is usually a very fine grained wood, so your description of open-grain mahogony doesn't fit.

Re: Long shot, but

#16

Re: Nope

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Just re-checked the bark on dogwood. That ain't it.

Nev-ver mind.

Re: Long shot, but

#17

Re: Nope

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>Persimmon bark in the photo doesn't match the description and drawing in my book: "…almost black, broken into small, rectangular blocks."

Re: Long shot, but

#18

Definitely not Dogwood.

Carole in VA

>My property is littered with that! What other woods are brilliant orangy/yellow when fresh cut and quickly turn very light cocoa brown? Pretty sure this is not a fruitwood...it is far too stable. Does not crack or warp at all. It is not Osage or Mulberry...I know both of those woods.

Re: Long shot, but

#19

Re: 2nd pic

Dale Stansbery

>It looks a lot like a Hawthorne that I cut a couple years back, especially the turned piece. It wasn't orange so much though as it was a pinkish tan as I recall.