We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I've been working on my lacquer finish technique with pretty good results. Pretty good, not great.
My question for the experts; How does one remove the very fine swirl? After wet sanding thru all MM grits and polishing with white diamond wheel, I can still see the faintest scratch marks. I have to look for them, but they're there. Other than that, I'm pleased with the glass-like finish.
>I think you are learning why I always caution that a lacquer finish is the easiest to do, but the hardest to do well. There are several possible causes for the appearance of scratches in a buffed lacquer finish. Without looking at the piece and being able to ask questions, I can only offter the following ---------
I suspect that there are scratches on the surface of the wood under the film of lacquer. Your mention of "swirls" would indicate they might be left from power sanding. A buffing wheel would leave short "linear" scratches.
"No finish can be any better than the surface of the wood under it. "Nowhere is this more true than for a high gloss lacquer finish. The surface acts like a magnifying lens that magnifies every surface flaw in the wood, and the thicker the film, the higher the magnification.
Sanding scratches are a common problem for folks who are using fluorescent lighting. There are no shadows and the scratches are invisible until after the piece is finished and it is taken out of the shop. The harsher light from an incandescent bulb will make shadows and the scratches more visible so they can be removed.
If they are turly in the surface of the finish, they would be from the buffing process itself. The most likely suspect would be a contaminated buffing wheel. It could be airborne dust or residual from the tripoli or other coarse abrasive. Just as in sanding, always remove all of the residual from the coarser abrasive before going to the finer grit. The tripoli uses tallow (animal fat) as a carrier that sticks to the wood and it is a dust magnet, and it can contaminate the White Diamond wheel with gunk. Wipe the wood clean before using the White Diamond.
Clean out the wheel by holding the edge of a piece of hard wood against the spinning surface. If it is really dirty use the edge of an old handsaw blade.
Make sure that the lacquer is dry before buffing. It takes up to 6 for lacquer to develop its full hardness, and the thicker the film, the longer it will take. Wait 2-weeks, and a month is better, before buffing the lacquer film.
Or, you could be running the buffer too fast. An 1800 RPM wheel can be too stiff for lacquer. Even the ends of the unloaded fabric can scratch the surface at 1800 RPM, especially if it hasn't had that 2-weeks to dry. Slowing down to 900 RPM presents a softer wheel surface to the lacquer, and less likely to cause any damage.
Then there is the possibility that you have a sufficiently high gloss and smoothness on the lacquer finish that the White Diamond is not a fine enough abrasive. You could use some of finer 3-M abrasives that are available from the auto paint stores. I have always had good results from using 4X Pumice powder lubricated with water, followed by Rottenstone lubricated with water, followed by a final polish with Rottenstone lubricated with Mineral Oil. Both the Pumice and Rotenstone are a finer and less aggressive abbrasive than the White Diamond.
I sand all my wood finishes to at least 600 grit. I then apply the initial grain filling coats. I sand these while the bowl is still on the lathe with 320-400 grit (not sanding through to the wood). Once the grain is leveled, the bowl is parted off, the bottom finished and then I begin applying addition coast, and all sanding is done by hand. The hand sanding is wet sanding lubricated with water.
I sand up through at least the equivolent of 2000 grit (400, 600, 800, 1000, 1500, 2000). After this point, I either continue to go up thought Micromesh 12,000 or I hand buff with 3M Finess-It.
I avoid machine buffing. Even a large bowl does not take 10-20 minutes to hand buff. Machine buffing is (IMHO) more trouble than it is worth, and neith saves no time nor produced a better finish. The fabric of the buffing wheel is more abrasive - especially at high speed, than the 2000 grit sandpaper.
>Most scratches are the remnants of the coarser grits that we didn't remove. Remember that it's not how fine a grit we use, but that all of the scratches are removed from the previous grit before going on to the next. This is especially important with the coarser grits.
>You could be right, Russ, I've often puzzled over how to tell when the scratch marks I see are from the current or previous grit. But this time, I really don't think that is the issue. I knew I was going to lacquer these pieces and paid particular attention to the thoroughness of my sanding.
By the way, you mentioned pumice powder and rottenstone, but the guys at the auto paint store had no idea what they were. Where does one find these items?
>scratch marks I see are from the current or previous grit.
Try sanding across the previous marks.
Long ago I ran a small metallography lab, grinding and polishing tiny sandwiches of aluminum and uranium alloys for chemical etching and microscopic analysis. Scratches from previous grits was the worst problem. ONE particle of grit from a previous step could ruin the process. I had to clean ultrasonically to be sure to remove grit stuck in tiny pores and cavities.
Wood seems a worse material than the metals, since there are many pores in the grain to trap abrasive particles. Although not nearly as demanding as for photomicrography, I think the same principles apply.
- Clean the surface as well as possible before beginning a new grit. For wood, wiping with a cloth and perhaps a blast of compressed air should do.
- Sand until all previous scratches are removed. How to tell: I test by sanding across the direction of the previous sand marks. For spindle turning, I turn off the lathe and sand by hand with the grain to reveal and remove scratches from previous sanding with the lathe running. For face work I do the same thing - after using a power sander on the inside of the bowl, for example, I'll sand by hand and look for remaining scratches.
- Be sure polishing materials are not contaminated with even one particle of sanding grit.
I use a strong light to carefully examine the surface at each stage. A trick I learned - use a flashlight or swing-arm light to light the surface from different angles.
One thing that is a serious hidden issue with metals and may also apply to some extent to wood is subsurface deformation (according to one reference book - Darlow's Fundamentals of Woodturning, page 38). When a particle of grit gouges through the metal, it not only removes some material but presses and deforms material below the surface. Just removing the visible scratches is not enough - you have to remove the subsurface deformation as well or later processing will reveal the damage. If you are carefully sanding wood until all the visible scratches are gone and STILL see later problems, it might be necessary to sand a bit more at each step. Places where fibers are torn from then endgrain are another example of (severe) subsurface damage but that's another issue - that usually needs to be cut away before sanding.
A couple of local turners told me how much they hate sanding (and unfortunately you can tell from their work), but I kind of enjoy it. It's a zen thing.
whew, that was in-depth. Thanks for the info, I'll pay close attention and sand cross-grain as you advise.
In this case, I brought the bowl to work and looked at it under a high power microscope (which was very cool, by the way).
The close up look revealed that the fine swirl I see is definitely in the lacquer coat. Under the microscope, the scratch marks appeared to hover over the wood. Again, it was very cool to see and definitively answered my question.