Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

A general comment based on photography thread...

Posts

A general comment based on photography thread...

#1

Steven Antonucci

A general comment based on photography thread...

steve antonucci

>I think that my coffee must be working this morning because I had an epiphany.

It seems that people are on both sides of the issue of unsolicited critiques, whether it is form or photography. The main issue is that some people feel that since the poster did not ask for it, other shouldn't offer their opinions.

Unfortunately, this creates tension, and inhibits people who do want to learn from the group. We can see that there are people learning from other people's posts as well as their own. Anyone posting any item, whether it is an object for critique or the picture itself should be willing to listen to the exchange of experiences and ideas and OPINIONS, and do what they want with that information.

So I offer the following compromise-

Since the true benefit of a critique is to have the group learn from it, do not offer a critique without a clear explanation of how you think things may be improved. Some folks around here have taken the time to "edit" images of forms that they have critiqued, so why not all of us put the same effort into our judgements.

As my own worst critic, there is nothing that anyone here would say to me that I haven't already said outloud...

Steve

p.s. to those people that do not wish to be critiqued but post work, pictures, whatever, - assume that 1/2 of the group wants to learn from your posts

Re: A general comment based on photography thread...

#2

Re: A general comment based on photography thread.

Mike Schwing from Md.

>A good idea and a good start Steve. May I add an idea? I have a suspicion that most of us know what we like and dislike about a work when we post it. That might include form or finish, decoration, whatever..

I believe it kind of "greases the wheels" when we offer up our own critique of our work when we initially post the picture. I have noticed that if I first say something like "I'm pretty pleased with the form, but believe I might have left the foot a little too tall" that others will seem more at ease with offering their thoughts on same.

So my suggestion is that if you are going to ask for comments, critique, opinions, that you first give the same of your own work. Besides making it easier for others to respond, critical analysis of our own work really makes us quite a bit better in the long run, too.

But I'm still not going to offer comments other than "nice job" or nothing at all unless the poster asks for them. Some folks just want to show their most recent work. Thats fine with me.

Re: A general comment based on photography thread...

#3

Re: A general comment based on photography thread.

Rick Allen

>Wel said Mike (or should I write "nice job"(;~>)

Re: A general comment based on photography thread...

#4

Re: A general comment based on photography thread.

JamieDonaldson

>I suggest that any poster who is attempting to benefit from this exposure should ask for comments- this policy works well (most of the time!) on the WOW site. This invitation should be clear enough for others to add their own responses, and the poster can then determine what other opinions are worth. And of course a good photo really conveys the message better than a thousand words!

Re: A general comment based on photography thread...

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: A general comment based on photography thread.

Keith Tompkins

>I think you are right here, Jamie.....on WOW, if you ask for a critique, you will get one. I think the critique is one of the best learning tools here at Wood Central also.

I think a good rule of thumb would be....only critique a piece if specifically asked for, or: ask permission to critique a piece before you do.

The critique should be honest and fair, always with the benefit of the person whose piece is being critiqued in mind. Keep in mind: if you ask for a critique, you may not always like what you hear....