Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Taking pictures

Posts

Taking pictures

#1

Taking pictures

Russ Fairfield

>Sorry folks, but I look at the quality of the photo in the same light as finishing the bottom of a piece of wood, or putting your signature on it. If you don't think enough of it to finish it, claim it, or take a good picture of it; then, why should I look at it.

I give the beginners some slack on the pictures, but there is a limit to how much. There is no excuse for not taking and posting better pictures. There are several folks on these forums who are professional photographers and they are always offering their advice. If they aren't to be believed, there is an abundance of Internet sites devoted to taking better pictures of small objects like dolls, model cars, and jewelry. All of that can be applied to our turned wood. There is no lack of knowledge available.

Many use the inadequate pixel excuse, but that won't work for pictures posted on the Internet. High pixel numbers are required for making large prints of the photo. Internet pictures don't need a lot of pixels.

Neither is the editing software an excuse. There are some very good editors available free for the downloading from the Internet.

Am I missing something here??

Or, am I just being the "Olde Curmudgeon"?

Re: Taking pictures

#2

Re: Taking pictures

Stuart Johnson

>Russ, Look, don't look or just hit delet. It's your computer so do what you want. What I don't understand is why it seems to be perfectly acceptable to give negative critiques regarding how an item is photographed when help isn't requested. Why not grade spelling, punctuation and proper grammer as well? If this was a photography group I would expect to see comments about not using blue background when photographing a Maple vase but not comments that only talk about how shear cutting would give a better finish.

As a slight side note W.C. doesn't seem as narrow minded in this regard as WOW.

Re: Taking pictures

#3

Re: Taking pictures

Sean Troy

>I agree with Russ. If your not going to do the best you can, why do it at all. This site (forum) is for help(learning) in all aspects of turning. Photographing your work is part of that if your at all serious about your turning. If your not serious about it, put a photo album up on the internet for your family and friends to see. You can do that for free. Most people on this forum are serious about learning all they can about turning so they can see improvment and develope skills and the thought process.

Re: Taking pictures

#4

Re: Taking pictures

Gary Ljostad

>While this is a turning site, and yes turning should be the main topic of discusion, often times we post pictures of our work, for critique or to show and discuss verious aspects of the art. It is in all our interests to present the best possible photos in order to clearly show the beauty of our turnings. A good photo shows so much more detail and accurate color, and lets us all see the true quality of workmanship. It also helps others spot and offer solutions for problems when asked. Not being able to see all this work in person,a good photo is the next best thing to being there. We don't need to spend a fortune on equipment and training, remembering a few simple rules and a little thought and common sense goes a long way. As for spelling and grammer, well this would be a very lonely site. ;-)

Re: Taking pictures

#5

Re: Taking pictures

georgetroy

>Ok, no lectures please. We have both been in this game a long time. Somtimes I even do so called artistic work and get a lot of enjoyment during it. In the old days I had to send out good photos and slides. Now I just do the best I can and take it to galleries. Call me lazy I guess, I do not have a photo booth, if needed I can use the photo gray paper, a light booth and so on. Then you can call me a Photographer, otherwise I'm just a nasty old woodturner. Showing a real life photo here of work in progress. Is it a good photo, who knows? GT


img

Re: Taking pictures

#6

Re: Taking pictures

georgetroy

>Showing another bad photo of the real world. Maybe this is not what Russ is referring to and Russ brings out a lot of good points. But I can't help but think you will learn more from this photo instead of just another pretty thing. You can see tools in use, an air line, calipers, tools with outriggers, outboard turning stand, and 16" tool rest holder. Now all I have to do is take a pretty picture of the finished project on photo matte paper or in the light box I don't have GT


img

Re: Taking pictures

#7

hornet's nest

John K Jordan

>With all due respect, I disagree.

Unless I post a photo in a thread discussing photography or ask for photo advice, I would more appreciate comments on the turnings rather than the photo process.

I personally enjoy seeing both excellent and poor photographs. I'm in awe of some photos I see here even though I've been a "photographer" for almost 35 years. But I don't think a professional quality photo matters much when trying to show the form of a turning. Not everyone is capable of taking professional photos, some are unable to even see the difference, and some work for a living and simply may not have the time.

But this is not a photography or even an art forum. Should a turner (or carver or furniture maker) be judged by his photo skills and snubbed or ridiculed if he doesn't measure up to some standard? And where does it stop? Even the BEST of photos posted here might be critiqued to death by those "far more professional" than the entire team of Woodcentral photo judges.

Consider also that quality photography can be an entire hobby in itself that not everyone has the interest, resources, space, or time to persue.

A great photo is helpful when trying to sell something or when trying to impress your peers or trying to get accepted into some event. But I happen to appreciate and get good ideas from even bad photos. (I've also seen some astoundingly good photos of what I considered very poor turnings, so it works both ways.) I far prefer to see a lot of average photos rather than just a few exceptional photos. It would be sad if the standards were set so high by a few that many were intimidated into posting no photos.

Just my humble opinion.

JKJ in East TN

Re: Taking pictures

#8

Re: Taking pictures

Sean Troy

>George, What kind of (brand) lathe is that in your picture?

Re: Taking pictures

#9

Re: Grammer?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>wussat?

[Oops, that am dicshun]

Re: Taking pictures

#10

Re: Taking pictures

Ron in Drums PA

>I don't think a turner should not be judged by his photography skills.

But it takes as much effort to take a bad photo as it does a good photo.

My equipment:

6 year old, 1 mega pixel digital camera.

Tripod

Table

Backdrops:

White Paper

Black Paper

Black Felt

Cardboard as a support for the backdrops.

I don't use artificial lighting, I take pictures on a cloudy day. Sometimes outside, other times inside in front of a big bay window.

I use two white cardboard reflectors taped together and placed on a table to form a V, There is a hole in which I can place my camera lens into. I hold a sheet of tracing paper above to help knock out the glare if needed. Sometimes I need to reflect more light so I use another piece of white cardboard.

Setup time: 5 minutes

Knock down time: 2 minutes

I take a couple of pictures, then download them to my computer to see if I want to make any changes. (i.e. turn the bowl to a better side)

Tips:

It takes as much effort to take a picture in focus as it does out of focus.

Watch your backgrounds.

Pay attention to the highlights.

Pay attention to the shadows.

When I need three hands, I use the timer on my camera.

Re: Taking pictures

#11

Re: Taking pictures

Ken DeMarco

>Wow Russ,

Where did that come from, I've been mostly offline for the past two months due to a move but looking through the past several weeks I see lots of good, great, and excellent photos, and very few crappy ones. I know that the first few photos I posted were terrible, but really I was just excited to show my work. I think if I had read all this "stuff" about photos i would not have posted at all. I take time now taking pictures, but the quality is still not near the great and excellent photos I see here. I will continue to post photos anyway (after I get my shop set back up) even if they are not up to quality standards, and I sincerely hope others will not feel bullied into not posting great work because they think there photos are not up to snuff.

"Am I missing something here??

Or, am I just being the "Olde Curmudgeon"? "

Sorry Russ, but I vote for "Olde Curmedgeon on this one!!

Re: Taking pictures

#12

Re: Taking pictures-Sean Troy

georgetroy

>Hello Sean,

That lathe is a Vicmarc 175 Longbed, swivel head, Vicmarc outboard stand,which is rock solid. Without covering all the features and it has a lot you can go to the Vicmarc Owners site and look at them and other Vicmarcs. GT

http://groups.msn.com/VicmarcOwnersGroup

Re: Taking pictures

#13

Re: Taking pictures

David Campbell Upland CA

>I have not posted a picture to WC because I am not satisfied with the images I tried to grab in a bit of a hurry. I did get dinged a long while back on WOW for using a blue back ground (which was recommended on a photo how-too site). The better the picture the more information and pleasure, but doe that mean that we should not post an image with glare from the flash or some other distraction? As usual there are two sides to the issue and it will be interesting to see what the group consensus is.

Re: Taking pictures

#14

Re: Taking pictures

gary clarke

>Russ, sorry about the bad pic I posted and the horrible blue background. Maybe I should have spent some of that money that I spent on your classes on photography :) see enclosed photo of my class instructor without glasses( good subject bad pic) Please do not get your knickers in a not. Life is to short, have fun, make chips, not pictures. All in good fun, eh ;)


img

Re: Taking pictures

#15

Re: Taking pictures

gary clarke

>PS: my wife informs me that not is spelled Knot. Good thing we have no grammer police.

Re: Taking pictures

#16

Re: Taking pictures

georgetroy

>Now this is the Russ that I know, hard at work here. Deep in thought. Looks like the stack of segmented rings just came off the press. I notice he is using formica covered discs to help keep it all flat as possible. Thanks for showing. GT

Re: Taking pictures

#17

Re: Taking pictures

JamieDonaldson

>I don't know who rattled Russ's chain with their photos, but he is making good sense as usual, even if he is a curmudgeon! Photos are the visual language by which we communicate, and learning to improve your photos is not rocket science. We spend many hours trying to improve our turning skills, so why not show that effort to your fellow turners in the best possible/practical images?

Re: Taking pictures

#18

Re: Taking pictures-Sean Troy

Sean Troy

>I thought that looked like a Vic but had no idea they had a swivel head model. You have the 300 also don't you? thanks for the info, Sean

Re: Taking pictures

#19

Very well put

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I totally agree with John's comments.

I'm here for woodturning. I'll admit that good pictures are nice. But a technically imperfect picture of an excellent turning is much better than no picture at all!!

Re: Taking pictures

#20

I Agree...

David Propst

>I have to agree with John. I am very interested in improving photos of my work and thus I greatly appreciate the advice of Russ or anyone else on that topic. I followed Dom's post about backgrounds closely and may go ahead and order a graduated background.

However this is a turning forum and as such it should be a place where turning is discussed, critiqued, celebrated, etc. It takes some nerve to post a photo of your work, especially the first time, and I would never want someone posting here to feel that the quality of their photo was not good enough to post.

David

This is the pic of my first bowl which was proudly posted on Badger Pond in 1999.


img

Re: Taking pictures

#21

Re: Taking pictures

John Lucas

>Gosh this is one time I have to dissagree with Russ. Although I think photography is important and I will do all I can to help people with their photography. this is a turning forum and some people simply don't want to spend the time taking a top quality photo. That's fine. I think we all agree that some people simply want to turn simple things and don't care about art pieces. That's fine also. This is after all just a hobby to most people and we should be having fun. We should all feel comfortable about sharing photos of our work. I would of course like to help you take better photos so that we can see your work in a better light but that's purely up to the individual.

The same is true with beginner's work. I love to see all work. It's fun to watch people grow in the quality of their work. This means that we will see less than expert work and less than expert photography. That's OK.

I have seen the quality of photos improve a lot in the last few years. That doesn't mean that their won't be bad or mediocre photos.

My photo of the Banksia Pod bowl was a good example. I didn't have time to set up a photo booth. I placed it on yellow construction paper and shot it on the kitchen floor. I just wanted to share it with everyone before it was gone. I think that is what everyone else is thinking when they shoot a piece.

Now if we are talking about using these photos for juried shows I have very strong opinions here and I will be glad to help with this because this is what I do for a living.

Re: Taking pictures

#22

Keith Tompkins

Re: Taking pictures

Keith Tompkins

>I am as guilty of posting bad photos as anybody....(just ask Jamie, who has let me know my photos were not up to par)Usually, I am excited about taking a shot to post online and don't think about taking a really good photo. In that regard Russ is correct, I think my photos are a reflection on my work. Personally I have been trying to take better shots, and learn from my mistakes.

Part of the reason I didn't bother to take really good photos is I take all my pieces to a professional photographer, who does all my slides and cd's. so, I take a quick shot for on-line, then the piece is off to the photo studio. If I intend to enter a juried show or exhibit, I will only submit the very best slides.

When I begin to add up my photography expenses, I can see the need to improve my photo technique; I have spent thousands (literally) on slides and digital images. I just dropped off a roll of film to be developed, which I attempted to take myself. They are not good enough....they are for a major event. I now have to take the pieces for the pro to reshoot. I now have wasted several days. Grrrr

Re: Taking pictures

#23

Mission success

Russ Fairfield

>A bold statement is sometimes the best way to get a conversation going that is a true expression of peoples feelings. To that end I was successful.

I had always wondered if the critiques of the pictures themselves were appreciated. I had asked the question a couple times before, back when I was attempting to moderate this forum, and I got the usual politicaly correct offensive-to-nobody answers. This time it worked, and now we know. Some do, some don't, and some feel very strongly about their view of this topic. I will let anyone who comments on the quality of a photo be their own judge. I will never comment on the photo quality because I am not qualified to do that.

There are two types of photos, those that are of a turned object that is posed in a studio type setting, and those that show a technique or whatever in a snapshot style photo. I always expect more from the posed studio type photo of our work, and my comments were about those photos.

There is NO WAY that I was trying to discourage anyone from posting their photos, regardless of their quality. But, I will still encourage folks to improve their pictures if they are going to post them on the Internet.

And, I hope that I will be forgiven if I post a picture that is of less than sterling quality. Like everyone else, some of mine aren't very good either.

Tomorow will be a better day.

Re: Taking pictures

#24

Re: Taking pictures

Steve Mushinski

>I do believe we all come to learn. I for one try to take the best picture I can to show how proud I am of the work I have done. The gentleman here and on the other forums take the time to explain how to due just that - take a good picture. It is easy to take a good picture once you know how. I thank all that have help us get better. I feel that if you never want some elses opinion then you might best not visit public forums. If someone says the picture could be better if you tried something for heaven sake "Give it a try and don't belly ache". If you are happy with your photo then just ignore the comments about the poor photo. Jamie's set up cost me about $15. I then spent about an hour learning how to use my camera (reading instruction manual helps) and taking test shots. You know what, I really like my pictures now more then ever. Now if turning was as easy as taking a good picture!! Here is a old sample and it could be better as it is a little soft around the edges. I could make it better now thanks to Jamie's help.


img

Re: Taking pictures

#25

Re: Mission success

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Russ, you described what I believe is a common thread in many/most humans - we spend time doing that which is important to us. People that strive for true excellence will seek that excellence in everything they do, and will not accept less than the best of their capabilities.

An Indy car, for example, cannot win a race by having the best engine alone. All of the other car's aspects, including the driver, must be the best they can be. Accepting less in any one area will result in less than a first place finish. A woodturning competition is much the same, and if judged on photo submissions, that photo becomes part of the race car.

Here in the online world photos serve as a surrogate to holding the work in our hands and seeing it with our own eyes. A turner who is proud and confident of his work will learn to crank out photos that show it in the sharpest detail and best light possible because he knows it adds to the overall package of excellence. A lousy photo is a good way to hide less than wonderful woodturning. Turn that sharpness down to hide sanding scratches. Darken the photo a bit to hide a flaw in the profile. I know very experienced turners who are great photo takers/processers as well as wonderful turners who are not. Same goes for beginners, there is no hard rule I guess.

Some guys just want to turn. They don't care about the details that other turners do. Some even resent that they need to learn other things to make their work stand out, including photography. Nothing wrong with that. I find it sort of enviable. I fuss over so many things! Would be nice to be happy with just turning something round. But that is just not me.

I never comment negatively on a photo unless asked for comments in the description. Same for turnings.

Just to keep Jamie off of my back I learned to take better photos, and while I resented it at first, I really appreciate it now. And as a turner who has submitted photos of my work for juried shows, I should thank him firsthand. Thanks Jamie. I also know that without a doubt my photos help me sell work from my website rather than hinder them.