Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Speaking of toolrest height...Cut two

Posts

Speaking of toolrest height...Cut two

#1

Speaking of toolrest height...Cut two

Jorge Castaneda

>These days I have little time to hang out here in the forum and I just read with great interest the posts about toolrest height, I think we all learn from posts such as this, big thanks to all the posters, but all the posts I read deal with exterior cuts, how about some discussion about the toolrest height in inside cuts on bowls and hollow forms?

TIA

Jorge

Re: Speaking of toolrest height...Cut two

#2

Re: Speaking of toolrest height...Cut two

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Hi Jorge. I too thought that toolrest discussion was really valuable!

No fair asking us what we do without telling us what you do as well, but here goes. First, I think that what we'll probably find is interior toolrest height, for bowl turning, depends a lot on the type of gouge/grind we're using and how we prefer to present the gouge to the work, as well as our other working conditions and preferences. I hope respondents list some of those things as well (please)

Me, I'm kind of an oddball as far as I can tell when it comes to hollowing a bowl. I'm short (5'5") and I use a big heavy gouge (5/8" Ellsworth in a stout Kelton handle), and my lathe spindle is high, relatively speaking, to most other turners. My lathe (PM3520A) also has a sliding headstock which I take full advantage of when hollowing, as I slide it all the way to the end so I can stand facing the interior of the bowl. I never, ever, work on a bowl interior from the side of the lathe bed.

I can't think of any other toolrest height I use on an interior bowl profile than that which allows all cutting action to take place directly at the centerline/lathe axis. I hold my gouge absolutely horizontal, tucked into my armpit tight against my body. My presentation keeps the gouge horizontal during all cuts on the inside from roughing to finishing, and the toolrest never changes from the height I start roughing with all the way to finishing. This armpit horizontal tuck, which physically just isn't possible for most folks who've been to my shop/basement, gives me phenomenal control of the cutting edge. But I'm a bit of a freak physically. Still, I think its important to know why a turner keeps his/her toolrest at a certain height and that is why I keep mine there, for bowl interiors only. BTW, this horizontal gouge approach is the way David Ellsworth proscribes in his signature gouge video, but he's way too tall to do the armpit tuck.

For hollow forms, things are a little different. To decrease/eliminate the possibilty of catastrophic catches, I set the toolrest so that the cutter height is just a bit above centerline. With the rest set thusly, should a catch occur, the cutter is thrown down into clear air as it rotates with the workpiece, clearing the catch. Tool cutter height changes pretty quickly as hollow forms get deeper, so frequent alterations of toolrest height are important.

Thats just what I do!

Re: Speaking of toolrest height...Cut two

#3

Re: Speaking of toolrest height...Cut two

John Lucas

>Mike I'm a hair taller than you but not much. I lowered my 2035 as far as it would go. I tend to hollow a bowl with the tool cutting at the center line or slightly above. I adjust the tool rest height so I can easily rub the bevel and have the tool just above my hip. This varies somewhat but usually the tool rest is below center. If you laid the tool on the tool rest so the tool is horizontal the tip will be on center. For thin tools the tool rest would be higher than thick tools but I don't jump up and down and move the tool rest all the time.

I usually just adust the tool somewhat depending on the the shape of the bowl and the way the grain runs. Mostly I cut using a push cut with the flute about 2 oclock or so but will rotate the flute up or down depending on the shape of the bowl.

Re: Speaking of toolrest height...Cut two

#4

type and brand of toolrest

John Lucas

>Let's incluce the style of tool rest that we all use in this. I think that would be very useful for me and others. I currently have 3 that I use most often. I have my Powermatic straight 12 inch that I use for shallow bowls. I have a Bestwoodtools 12" that I use when I need to get the tool rest lower or for steep sided bowls. I have an adjustable curve tool rest from Bestwoodtools that I use when I need to get the tool close the cut. I would not recommend this one as your only bowl rest. The adjustable part gets in the way for some cuts. I would, and probably will, buy their new fixed curved rests. They are much sturdier.

Re: Speaking of toolrest height...Cut two

#5

Re: type and brand of toolrest

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Just two at present. The OEM supplied Powermatic toolrest and a 1" round bar T'd at 4 and 7 inches. I have an idea for a curved rest that I want to talk to Randy (Monster Wood Tools) about before tossing it about here. I had the BestWoodTools curved rest but returned it as I found it to be pretty useless - not only did the clamp get in the way but the rest vibrated badly - but have loved every one of their other products.

I use the Powermatic rest for roughing work because I don't care if it gets dented and dinged, then I switch to the round rest for shaping and finishing work.

Re: Speaking of toolrest height...Cut two

#6

Brad Vietje

Re: Speaking of toolrest height...Cut two

Brad Vietje

>I'm with John. Usually a little below center so the gouge cuts at, ot just above center. In making a push cut in from rim to bottom of the bowl, though, I ususlly arc well up above center height, ending at center height and at the center of the bowl, slowly rotating the tool CW as I go. Not sure exactly why, but it seems to work best for me. When using the left side of a swept-back (Ellsworth) grind (flute up), I keep the tool level and at center ht.

I use 3 rests, 12", 6" and 4", all straight. I will be getting a curved set for inside and outside bowls to reduce the distance from rest to bowl when the new shop goes on line.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT

Re: Speaking of toolrest height...Cut two

#7

Re: Speaking of toolrest height...Cut two

John Lucas

>Brad I also rotate the gouge clockwise while going to the middle. The reason I do it is if the gouge tip is verticle as it gets to the very center it will simply stop cutting. This keeps you from getting that nasty catch when your tool goes beyond center and the wood lifts the tool and pinches your finger.

Re: Speaking of toolrest height...Cut two

#8

Re: Speaking of toolrest height...Cut two

Ed Karch

>Same as Brad. PB2035 pulled to the end of the bed. Also do a flute left pull cut from center for rapid stock removal.Elsworth 5/8, stock tool rest as can't afford anything else yet.

Ed Karch

Re: Speaking of toolrest height...Cut two

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: Speaking of toolrest height...Cut two

Keith Tompkins

>ON bowls, I cut right on the center line, same as the exterior. On hollowing end grain, I cut above center with a lowered handle, then swing the handle as I approach the rim so the cut is on center. I use the stock general rests and a homemade curved rest, also a new woodcraft curved bowl rest.

Re: Speaking of toolrest height...Cut two

#10

Re: Speaking of toolrest height...Cut two

Jorge Castaneda

>Hi Mike,

Thanks for your input, apologies for not mentioning what I do. in small bowls, I use a 3/8" P&N in a looong handle, (this is a new development), presenting the tool about 3 o'clock and making an arch, the tool rotating to the right until it reaches the center vertical. I have made a couple hundred small bowls, but I still consider myself a prentice.

Now that I have a better lathe and can swing bigger chunks of wood, I've made a couple dozen big bowls, 10" and beyond, using my Hamlet 5/8" Ellsworth gouge, with this I have a problem making one continuous cut so I go quick from the gunnel to the bilge, so to speak, and then from the keel to the bilge, it works but it leaves a thicker area near the bilge. In an inspired evening, I took the handle of the Kelton core saver and put the 5/8" P&N gouge on it, I had an epifany, this rig works very well but I have not yet learned its secrets.

In both inside and outside cuts, I set the rest below center so when the gouge is horizontal, the tip is on center, and work with the tail of the gouge lowered until I get to the center.

When working in boxes, I set the tool rest a little above center. Now that I am starting to make hollow forms, I have been trying to keep the tool horizontal, right on center, I am using the Scorpion, but I still get bad catches now and then, specially when using the tear drop scraper..

I have a number of tool rests, The 12" straight that came with the lathe, the 12" Nova bowl rest, it only works on exteriors, a box rest, a 6" Monster rest that I use a lot and a pair of interior bowl rest we made last may at the meeting of the Maine Turners Association, thanks to the generosity of Dave Lancaster, he freely gives of his knowledge, and let us use his equipment. They are made of 1'1/4" x 1/2" steel and we rolled them cold, Both were the same lenght, but at home I hacked away at them and made one a lot smaller and both got cut away a taper to be able to get closer.

This two became instant favorites, they are solid, the great mass and the flat top are both very helpful to me, look at the pics.

I was looking at what I have to do to be able to duplicate your armpit stance, I would need to raise the spindle a little more than 2", I am 5' 7", right now my spindle is at 46".

Thanks

Jorge


img

Re: Speaking of toolrest height...Cut two

#11

Tool rest in use

Jorge Castaneda

>Here is a picture of the small interior bowl tool rest, it is useful in other aplications as you can see, this too was made in the Maine turners Association meet last may. I love that flat top!

Thanks for looking.

Jorge


img

Re: Speaking of toolrest height...Cut two

#12

Brad Vietje

Nautical Terms and Bowls ...

Brad Vietje

>Hey Jorge,

I've done a fair bit of sailing (mostly Downeast Maine) so I'm pretty familiar with terms like gunnels, bilge, and keel... Now I'm trying to picture these used to describe a bowl...

OK, gunnels (gun-wales for the non-sailors) are the rim, and keel would be the foot, or base, but how are you distinguishing keel and bilge ? Do you mean keel for outside (foot, or tenon), and bilge for the bottom of the inside ? (There's no brine, granite blocks or lead sloshing around in most of my bowls, so I'm not entirely certain.)

I may just have to head for the Maine coast, and you can teach me all about the bilge-bowl connection ! We could can sail up to Joaz Hill's place in Stonington, eat a few lobsters and drink a few beers, and a good time would be had by all ! (...except the lobsters)

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT

Re: Speaking of toolrest height...Cut two

#13

Re: Nautical Terms and Bowls ...

Jorge Castaneda

>Brad,

Perhaps I should have said chine, that line where the free board changes into bottom in the outboard side, below that point would be the highest point of the water sloshing around if it is not a dry boat, something like that.

Abaout Joaz, that gent lives in the same town as I do, so maybe we just walk or drive over there and yes, we should party and have lobstah, and beah, ayuh!

Let us know when you are coming this way. I have a daughter at Dartmouth, next time over there I will ping you.

Jorge

Re: Speaking of toolrest height...Cut two

#14

Brad Vietje

Re: Nautical Terms and Bowls ...

Brad Vietje

>Jorge,

Would love to hear from you when you are over Dartmouth way. My wife works at the Hood Museum of Art at Dartmouth, and I live about 9 or 10 miles away. We're in the process of selling, and moving up the Connecticut River to Newbury, anout 25 miles to the north. I'll be able to set up a proper shop up there, instead of working in an unheated garage, but have a few months of work to do on the house first.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT