Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

RE-mounting of pieces

Posts

RE-mounting of pieces

#1

RE-mounting of pieces

DD

>I continuously have a problem when I try to remount a piece in my talon chuck. Whenever I re-mount it I can never get the piece (it doesn't matter what I am turning)to run true. I was watching a Raffan video the other day. He simply taps the piece, and presto! it's running true on the lathe. No amount of tapping gets my pieces to run true. Is there some sort of trick to this that I am missing? I try to get it as true as I can, but it never seems to get there, which can create more problems downstream (depending on the piece). I also always ensure my tenon doesn't bottom out in the chuck. Any help appreciated.

DGD

Re: RE-mounting of pieces

#2

Re: RE-mounting of pieces

John Lucas

>DD 2 things come to mind. Do you turn a shoulder on the tenon to sit on top of the jaws? This helps the bowl re-align. The other thing is are you removing the bowl to let it set and then putting it back in. If you are it is probably warping. Sometimes tapping one side will align it but usually it will not align perfectly.

Re: RE-mounting of pieces

#3

Re: RE-mounting of pieces

Dick Parr

>DD, I put the number of the jaw that corresponds to the place on the tenon of the bowl so when I remount if (if I haven't trued the tenon up) I can just match the number and the jaw and it is back in place.

It helps me.

Re: RE-mounting of pieces

#4

I second this method....

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>

Re: RE-mounting of pieces

#5

Re: RE-mounting of pieces

DD

>I don't think warping is the issue here. In my last "episode" I was trying to turn a pepper mill. I turned a cylinder between centers from a dry piece of butternut, made a tenon at each end, an one part way down for the top of the mill. I parted off the top, again leaving a tenon so I could mount either end of the top and base of the mill in my chuck. When I remounted the base on the talon chuck, it doesn't run true. I try to do some minor adjustments to get it true. The real problem arises when I try to bore out the center of the pepper mill base. Because it isn't running true, the bored hole is slightly off-center. When the top is finished and sized to fit the bored hole, everything is fine and dandy until one rotates the top. Rotating it 180 degrees on the base identifys the degree of the "run-out". I in essence picked the wrong method to turn the pepper mill. I wanted the top and base to flow with a concave curve that started on the top and finished on the base, with only a fine line showing between the two pieces. It seemed to work until I rotated the top and highlighted my run out. It was all for naught (apart from lessoned learned) because the whole thing split in half longitudinally when I was trying to clean up the bottom of the base.

I will try to remove the chuck's spindle adapter and re-mount it. The tailstock and spindle are aligned and I have always assumed my chuck runs true. Maybe it doesn't.

Doug

Re: RE-mounting of pieces

#6

Ditto

Carole in VA

>

Re: RE-mounting of pieces

#7

Re: RE-mounting of pieces

John Lucas

>DD Did you drill out the hole in the pepper mill. If so that may be the problem. Drill,even big ones often wander at the start of the cut. This throws things off center. The only way I've found do drill a hole on center is to bore it using turning tools so you only cut from one side such as hollowing a box.

The other way is to drill the hole first and then use a wooden mandrel that fits in the hole to drive the body while you turn it. This is the method I use for pepper mills and salt shakers.

When you mount the mill in the chuck before you drill it, is it running true. If not find the high point and tap in gently with a deadblow hammer. It may take a time or two to get it running true. Then tighten the jaws and see if it stays on. If not tap another time or two. You can usually get it trued back up.

Re: RE-mounting of pieces

#8

Re: RE-mounting of pieces

Ron In Drums PA

>Almost the same

I place a mark on the tenon and always algin the mark to the #1 jaws

Re: RE-mounting of pieces

#9

Re: RE-mounting of pieces

DD

>I drilled the hole (first a 1 3/4" hole 1/2 deep in base, and then a 1 1/16" hole for the remainder of the base, both with saw tooth drill bits. I had to turn the base end for end to drill from the other end because the 1 1/16" bit wasn't long enough to go all of hte way through. Trying to get the cylinder true in the first place is the problem, and drilling only amplifys it, I guess. I will try the dead blow hammer trick. I did remove the spindle adapter from the chuck, cleaned it up and re-installed. When removing the the apapter bolts, I did notice one was very easy to loosen compared to the others, but I doubt that would have been the cause. Just have to do a better job of installing the piece in the chuck.

I am using some sawtooth drill bits that have a center point on them. I wonder if drilling a small hole in the base would prevent the drill bit from wandering at the point the bit is inserted in the wood. If the piece is not running true, the point of the drill bit, upon insertion into the wood, will cause the bit to run untrue initially as well. Will have to try. Thanks for the responses.

Doug D

Re: RE-mounting of pieces

#10

Re: RE-mounting of pieces

Ed Karch

>I seldom get a true going from centers to chuck. I always have to re-turn after chucking.

Ed

Re: RE-mounting of pieces

#11

Re: RE-mounting of pieces

DD

>Will try this as well. Thanks for the help and advice. Appreciated.

Doug D

Re: RE-mounting of pieces

#12

Re: RE-mounting of pieces (ditto)

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Exactly what I do, a pen mark on each side of the #1 jaws.

Re: RE-mounting of pieces

#13

Brad Vietje

Couple of thoughts

Brad Vietje

>DD,

First -- a common problem with chuck jaws that have aggressive teeth -- this is one aspect of turning for which a properly sized and shaped tenon and dovetail (smooth) jaws are far, far superior (and almost the only case, too). I noticed this many times when comparing my ability to re-chuck work on my Stronghold (w/profile jaws) and a Supernova with dovetail jaws. Has nothing to do with the chuck manufacturer, but the aggressiveness of the "teeth" on the jaws. If you turn a hard shoulder, and mark the jaw numbers, as john suggested, and jiggle the piece just exactly right, you can sometines get it to line up perfectly, but don't hold your breath.

Second, Butternut is a soft wood, and the softer, the worse for re-chucking, as there can be significant, and non-symetrical crushing of fibers in the tenon ==> wobble when re-chucked (with any jaws, I'm afraid). Harder woods are less of a problem. Another approach is a lighter hold with the jaws, and a steady rest to keep the wood centered.

Third, as Ed (?) suggested, you might have better results leaving some extra mass when rough turning, then true up the piece for drilling, then do the finish turning between turned wooden cones to get the outside and the cylindrical hole concentric.

Lastly, whenever possible, leave a mark from the tail center for re-centering when re-chucking later. This applies to bowls and other types of twice turned items as well.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT

Re: RE-mounting of pieces

#14

Brad Vietje

One More Thought

Brad Vietje

>Forgot to mention... The peppermills I have made called for a long bore of something like 1-1/16", and a shorter recess of 1-5/8". Turns out I have a pretty cheap-o revoloving center (might be an artifact from my ShopSmith days) that is just 1-5/8" outside diameter. Made re-mounting the drilled mills a breeze. A Oneway center with the cone attached ought to work well, too.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT

Re: RE-mounting of pieces

#15

Re: Couple of thoughts

DD

>Thanks for the additional info. Don't quite understand what you mean by leaving a mark for the tail center.

Am new to pepper mill turning and tried something different. After boring the base to 1 1/16", I turned a spigot on the top to fit into the bored hole. I then turned the top and base together, the base held by the talon chuck and the top held onto the base by the tail center. I tried it this way to make the grain run from the base to the top without interruption. It looked quite nice. I had to occasionally apply a little more tail center pressure while turned to prevent the top rotating relative to the base. The spigot had no visible play in the bored hole.

I take your point about the softness of butternut. I may have induced some run out by applying too much pressure on the chuck jaws.

Thanks again for the advice.

Doug D

Re: RE-mounting of pieces

#16

Re: RE-mounting of pieces

Russ Fairfield

>Chucking problems are usually more a problem with poor work habits than anything wrong with the chuck or the wood. Some of these habits include....

The ideal situation is when the diameter of the spigot or recess is the same as the "true circle" diameter of a set of dovetail jaws. This way the jaws will grip around the entire surface of the spigot. You will have maximum gripping with the least distortion of the wood.

When using a spigot that is not the "true diameter" or when using the profile jaws such as the Oneway chucks, it helps to line up the grain direction with a line that splits the chuck diameter in half. This gives you a better chance of having the same grain orientation to all 4 of the chuck jaws. This insures equal compression of the wood on all 4 jaws.

Always mark that line on the wood and always come back to it between the same chuck jaws. This compensates for any run-out in the chuck.

The worst condition is to run the grain through the gripping area so that one pair of jaws is squeezing on end-grain and the other on side-grain. This could lead to the condition of having a 2-jaws chuck with all of the gripping being done by the one pair of the jaws across the end-grain.

Use only enough pressure to hold the wood. It isn't necessary to crush the wood or use a cheater bar to crank down on the chuck. You have reached the maximum grip of the chuck when the wood starts to crush, and no amount of pressure is going to give you any more grip on the wood.

In really soft wood, tighten the jaws to where they will just hold the wood. Use the tail center as a precaution. Squirt some thin CA glue under the chuck jaws. Then give the jaws one last tightening. Then squirt some accelerator to cure the glue. The glue hardens the wood for a better grip. The CA won't stick to the jaws, but if this is a concern give them a light rub with a stick of parrafin wax.

Lastly, always jab the point of the tail center into the wood. No need to crank it into the wood. Use just enough to leave a mark if you need it. A pencil will do the same thing, but always leave a center mark.

I apologize if I am repeating what others have said.

Re: RE-mounting of pieces

#17

Re: And.......

Russ Fairfield

>I forgot one important thing.

Always tighten the chuck to an equal torque on both sides. Tightening from only one side location pulls all of the clearance to that side. Going to the other side pulls it back towards the center again. Go around the chuck 2 or 3 times for best centering.

Re: RE-mounting of pieces

#18

Brad Vietje

Re: Couple of thoughts

Brad Vietje

>DD,

If you start a piece between centers, the tailstock will leave a small mark -- how small and what shape depends on the shape of the tail center and how hard you tighten it. Later, when re-mounting the work, this little mark is very helpful in getting the piece to run true, or as close to true as you can get it. Even if the work is now held in a chuck, hold it very lightly, bring up the tailstock for centering, then tighten the chuck, before withdrawing the tailstock. This is even useful with twice-turned bowls that have warped -- I usually leave a little center indentation in the center of the tenon, which will now be oval. I re-mount the bowl 3 times to finish it: 1) between centers with the foot at the tailstock end to true the tenon for re-mounting (you can drive the opening with a wooden disk or cone held by a faceplate or a chuck) I usually true the outside here, too. 2) Held by the tenon to true up and finish the inside, then 3) reversed and held between centers again to sand/finish the outside, and remove any evidence of the chuck jaws, re-shaping and hollowing the foot.

I start every bowl between centers whenever possible, usually for the flexibility of tipping the bowl this way and that for the best use of the figure and overall balance, and I retain the center mark from the tailstock for re-mounting later. You may not prefer to do it that way, but works for me.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT

Re: RE-mounting of pieces

#19

Re: And.......

woodspinner/ Bill Hale

>Another one that helps in soft wood is when you cut the tennon to run thin CA on it prior to removal for reversing.

Run tha CA on the tennon, let it cure for a moment and re clean the tennon. This hardens the tennon and it will align better.

Also be sure not to cut the tennon so deep that it bottoms inside the jaws. It should rest on the outside of the jaws.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in Dolores Colorado