Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Better explanation for other newbies

Posts

Better explanation for other newbies

#1

Better explanation for other newbies

Carole in VA

>You veterans already know this, apparently, but I didn't do a very good job of explaining in words the cut that has banished tearout for me, so I tried to take a pic. This is a particularly nasty, punky piece of Box Elder that literally looked like corn stubble after initial shaping with the gouge. (wish I had taken a "before" pic.) On the shear cut, the gouge is beng drawn left to right, nose at about 10 o'clock, right flute just off the wood and handle almost to my knee. As you can see on the second pic, I have maybe one more pass to clear up the tiny remaining specks of tearout. Right now I can't for the life of me remember what video I think I saw this on, but I will bet on Bill Grumbine. Now, if someone would only help me get the stuff that smooth on the INSIDE!


img

Re: Better explanation for other newbies

#2

Brad Vietje

Re: Better explanation for other newbies

Brad Vietje

>Carole,

To me this looks just like the shear scraping I do with a swept back gouge, with one side of the tool engeged, and the other no more than 1/8" from the wood.

I may be incorrect about this, but the cut that I described earlier as a shear cut looks very similar to this, with the handle down very low, and leading slightly, but it is started with the flute facing to the right, and just the bevel rubbing. Then the tool is rotated CW just enough to engage the cutting edge in a very delicate, fine ribbon of a shaving, and the tool is advanced from left to right (in this view). The flute in the cut I'm trying to describe would still be facing to the right, but much more open than the tool in your photo.

Semantics aside, whether its a shear scrape or shear cut, if its working well, and producing smooth, tear-free results, that's all that really matters.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT

Re: Better explanation for other newbies

#3

Re: Better explanation for other newbies

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Carole, the cut you're using is called shear scraping. A very useful cut to have to clear up a poor surface. I works even better if you apply oil or wax. You can use the same cut on the inside of a bowl. With the flute facing the wood and cutting with the lower cutting edge, draw the tool toward the rim using a light touch. Don't drop the handle as much as on the outside, and cut on, or a little above center.

Wally

Re: Better explanation for other newbies

#4

Re: Better explanation for other newbies

Carole in VA

>So is what I am doing a shear "scrape"? Is it a matter of semantics? Turning terminology is confusing to me! LOL I am getting ribbons like sewing thread if that helps any. The gouge does have very swept back wings but it doesn't look like it in the photo due to the angle.

Re: Better explanation for other newbies

#5

Corn Stubble.....ha!

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Carole,

I love your description...corn stubble! That is so perfect for those nastly pieces that just won't cooperate.

Jen

Re: Better explanation for other newbies

#6

Re: Better explanation for other newbies

Carole in VA

>Thank you Wally! As I just said in my post below the terminology confuses me. I think of scraping as producing more dust and a cut as producing threads or ribbons. With this cut I get what looks like sewing thread. One of these days I will get the terminology right! LOL I am going out to the shop to try your suggested cut on the inside of that piece of Box Elder. :)

Re: Better explanation for other newbies

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: Better explanation for other newbies

Keith Tompkins

>Carole, as Wally cautioned, a light touch! LOL. thanks for the photos.

Re: Better explanation for other newbies

#8

Danger...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Carole, you should be aware that there is a possible danger in using this cut. If you get careless and allow the top cutting edge to get too far from the wood. flute facing up instead of toward the wood, the unsupported lower cutting edge will dig in. Sometimes that's how unintended thin walls are created.

Wally

Re: Better explanation for other newbies

#9

Re: Danger...

Carole in VA

>Wally, I figured that might be the case. Usually when I am going to try an unfamiliar cut, I will put the tool up to the wood with the lathe off, rotate the piece by hand and move the tool around to try and figure out which edge attitudes are likely to cause problems. Fortunately, that was one I picked up on, so I have managed to avoid it so far. As you say though, all it takes is a little lapse in concentration. I tried the method on the inside last night with some degree of success, but it was a lot more difficult than working the outside. Practice, practice! With the help of my WC friends like you, I am learning stuff now that I never would have dreamed of doing back in March when I tried to turn my first little bowl! Many, many thanks!