Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Art, Design, and Craft

Posts

Art, Design, and Craft

#1

Art, Design, and Craft

David Propst

>The thread last week on "Are you an artist?" really frustrated me. I think many woodturners shortchange themselves by rejecting the artist label. I had crafted a reply for that thread and then finally deleted it because I could not put into words what I was feeling.

Yesterday, I followed the link on Sean Troy's website to John Williams website where John had posted the quote below. The statement reflects exactly what I was not able to voice and I thought it worth sharing. A Google search shoes the quote attributed to Hella Basu, a British calligraphy artist.

"In all object making, that aspect which relates to the conceptual interpretation is art,
that which relates the object to an intended purpose is design,
and the quality of its execution is craft." - Hella Basu

Re: Art, Design, and Craft

#2

I had to give in....

tdaniel

>Hi David

I finally had to give in to "the label". When making just bowls I could easily call myself a skilled craftsman and avoid the "artist" label, but when I started doing mostly hollow forms which have no utilitarian use I had to succomb to the dreaded title. My buyers are buying art; therefore as the maker of that art I become an artist, whether I like the title or not....but I am still not an "artiste":)

Re: Art, Design, and Craft

#3

Re: Art, Design, and Craft.....Thank You!

Ruth Niles

>David,

Like you, the art vs craft conversations left me totally frustrated. But unlike you, I have 9 grandkids so I should be used to hitting my head against a wall trying to understand people using words, NOT for their true meaning, rather what THEY want them to mean.

Thank you so much for that quote, it settles it for me!

Ruth

Re: Art, Design, and Craft

#4

9?

tdaniel

>Naw, it can't be; you are too young to have 9 grandkids! Adopted right?

TD

Re: Art, Design, and Craft

#5

Articulator? Artifactor? Artichoke?

Phil Joines Krum, Texas

>

Re: Art, Design, and Craft

#6

Coming out of the closet

Ron in Drums PA

>Yes, I'm an artist.

I always knew I was an artist, even as a small child as I first picked up my first crayon. I knew then I could never turn back.

I admit, I have visited other artists in dark smoky rooms and we stayed up all night talking about art. Yes, we even smiled and laughed.

Many times when I walk down the street I hear old ladies gasp and say "Look Margaret, there goes another one of those artists" and watch them quickly walk away as if I had a disease.

I'm not ashamed. I am proud of who I am, just don't tell anyone! Please!

Re: Art, Design, and Craft

#7

Ellis Walentine

I wasn't aware...

Ellis Walentine

>...of the quote you mentioned, David, but it mirrors my own feelings about the subject nicely. The realm of turning is a peculiar crossroads for these definitions that still leaves a lot open to interpretation, though.

For example, when we conceive shapes for our turnings, is it art when we are conceiving shapes for non-funtional objects like hollow forms and design when conceiving shapes for functional objects like salad bowls? Or is there design and art in the shape and functionality of a salad bowl? What about a winged bowl like Mike Hosaluk might make, with a decorated rim? It satisfies the bowl criterion by being able to hold something, but the decoration is distinctly art.

The line is blurry, but I think we're on the right track with this characterization.

Ellis

Re: Art, Design, and Craft

#8

Re: Art, Design, and Craft.....Thank You!

Russ Fairfield

>I have never had a conflict between the "art" and the "craft" because I have always believed that the "art" was in the mind, and the "craft" was in making it into a reality. My only problem is that my skills in the "craft" have always exceeded my lack of vision into the "art". I don't have any problems with that and it doesn't bother me to be called a "craftsman". Besides that, the pay is better.

Re: Art, Design, and Craft

#9

Re: Art, Design, and Craft

oldgriz

>I have always been fond of this quote

"A man who works with his hands is laborer

A man who works with his hands and mind is a craftsman

A man who works with his hands, mind and heart is an artist"

There are times that I am a laborer and times that I like to consider myself an artist... but at the very least I try to be at least a craftsman

Re: Art, Design, and Craft

#10

Too much time in Hazelton Ron!..LOL

Gerry in Maryland

>

Re: Art, Design, and Craft

#11

Re: Art, Design, and Craft

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

>Thanks, David. I like that very much.

I hope all is well,

Mike

So little time lately in Apex, NC

Re: Art, Design, and Craft

#12

Re: Out of the closet

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>You're still welcome to come spin something.

Just don't touch me. It's "catching," you know.

Re: Art, Design, and Craft

#13

Does "Standing" Make a Difference?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>As in viewpoint?

I don't think of myself as an artist (whatever that is) when I'm doing a piece. I always, however, try to be a craftsman when I'm doing a piece.

I don't put "messages" in my pieces (political or otherwise); I just try to bring out and convey a simple concept that has occurred to me. Yet others have "found" deep meaning in some of the things I've done.

Design is a means, a language if you will, to non-verbally express a visual idea. Anyone may express an opinion on how good my vocabulary is (clearly some people are more "literate" than others), but it is no less and no more a tool than my bowl gouge, my welder, or my proprioceptive sense.

"Artist" is a label that others may (or may not) place on me from some distance after looking at the results of what I do. I am not, however, obligated to claim it, nor am I obligated to "live up" to someone else's cockeyed notion of what it means.

It comes down, does it not, to where the person who uses the term is standing? If some "rube" looks at my piece and exclaims that "someone would have to be a complete idiot to pay money just for the ability to put that junk in their home," that's okay, we obviously have different tastes. But if a collector/dealer calls me an artist and pays me twice what I think that same piece is worth, I'm going to argue him, right? Now, if I climb up to the roof and put up my sign in flashing 4-color neon "I AM AN ARTIST", what am I trying to claim and why?

So. If it all depends on individual perspective, why is it so damn important for some people who are actually making the stuff to decide whether or not they are "artists" or "crafts[persons]" or "designers" or some other literary label when, in fact, they are, to some degree, all three? Aside, that is, from trying to sell stuff to some collector for twice what it's actually worth.

M

Re: Art, Design, and Craft

#14

Re: Does "Standing" Make a Difference?

Russ Fairfield

>"Standing" only applies to the difference between a "fiddle" and a "violin". Grandpa Jones said the difference was that you played a "fiddle" standing up.

Re: Art, Design, and Craft

#15

Re: 9?

Ruth Niles

>Nope, I got married when I was 7! : )

Re: Art, Design, and Craft

#16

Re: I had to give in....

Mac

>And just when did you start doing hollow forms? Seems to me I remember that you said they took too long and you would never be able sell them. Remember? How views do change.....

Re: Art, Design, and Craft

#17

Reckin

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>That about leaves the First Violin parked. 'Course fiddle players is known to be showoffs anyways.

Re: Art, Design, and Craft

#18

Re: 9

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>You from Georgia too, Ruth?

Re: Art, Design, and Craft

#19

Re: I saw Ron Hazelton on "Hands On History."

Al Crandall--NE of Indy--

>

Re: Art, Design, and Craft

#20

What can I say?

tdaniel

>You were right! I never imagined people would pay enough for a vessel for me to be able to make a profit....wrong again. That is the nice thing about this sport....if you live long enough you get to eat every word you previously said. :)

Re: Art, Design, and Craft

#21

Re: I had to give in....

Wes Jones

>Terry,

I can't believe you have taken up turning vessels. Thought you were a confirmed bowl guy. Guess you had to buy a whole bunch of new (hollowing) tools. I find it very stimulating to turn a mix of different stuff.

Good luck.

Wes Jones

Re: Art, Design, and Craft

#22

Re: Art, Design, and Craft

matt fallon, li ny

>i've always loved that one too, its by

saint francis of assisi