We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>Just how smooth should one be able to get end grain? I have tried every cut I can think of...scrape with a scraper, shear cut and vertical shear cut with a gouge, etc. Only thing I haven't hit it with yet is an 80 grit gouge, which I am trying to avoid because I want to learn to do it with tools. I even though about trying a skew, but my toolrest won't go high enough. Should I be able to get this stuff as glassy as I can end grain in flat work with a sharp plane or is that pie in the sky? I am getting frustrated when I run into this. On other pieces, I have tried oil, wood hardener, etc and didn't like the result from any of those methods.
>Carole, you have a nasty piece of wood here. First, make sure that you're cutting WITH the grain, not against it. A good final cut with the gouge is, with the flute facing up and rubbing the bevel near the nose, make a very fine cut, going with the grain. When shear scraping with the gouge, apply finishing oil first, then with the handle well down, and with a light touch, shear scrape with the grain. If this doesn't do the job, 80 grit and oil will. Reverse your lathe if you can.
Try everything. Use different tools and different angles of attack. This is a terrific learning oportunity where you should be able to get that glass smooth surface off the tool. But doing so is going to be a combination of tool control and a bit of experimentation.
I can't tell from looking at the picture what will make it work for you. I might need to remove 1/4" in 10 passes before I could find the tool, speed and angle of attack which would work for this piece of wood.
The good news is, that by working with pieces like this from time to time you will learn a BUNCH of good stuff that will help you in other turnings.
Recap:
try different speeds of the wood and of advancing the tool through the cut.
Try different angles of the tool to the spinning wood and try different directions for the cut (uphill and down hill)
Try different tools. Working the outside of a bowl lets you experiment with tools other than bowl gouges (rub the bevel and and cut with the edge of the tool supported by the toolrest)
>Hi Carole, This is actually a good learning experience....a couple of things to try. Don't attempt the skew, as this appears to be bowl orientation. However, a sharp, well-honed spindle gouge, especially an old fashioned type (not made from round stock) will usually work for me in difficult situations. I make a slicing cut with the tool on its side, the effect is similar to a skew cut.
Imagine using a dull plane on flat work....lots of tearout. A well honed plane will make a clean cut.
A bowl gouge can also be honed, and used in a similar way, although I rarely do it. I roll my bowl gouge so it cuts near the "catch area" which causes the tool to contact the wood at a 45 degree angle. It cut cleaner, but is a bit riskier.
I also worked in the opposite direction, from large diameter to small...sometimes it works.
>Carole All good responses. Can't add anything on cutting technique without standing over you. However some woods just have a curly grain area that doesn't want to turn. I either put CA glue or Thinned lacquer on the area to stiffen the fibers. This helps make them cut better.
>I usually soak difficult grain/figure with sanding sealer or CA glue if it's really nasty. Either will harden up and help hold the wood together while cutting or scraping. For real soft woods (cedar, buckeye) a little liquid of some sort often helps - water, wax, oil. I also use cabinet scrapers (hand held, no tool rest, slow speed) to remove extremely fine shaving to combat uncooperative grain.
As for the skew, it could be a disaster to use it to cut on a large diameter, but you can often use it as a fine scraper - best held flat against the tool rest with a very light touch. This can take off very fine shavings but will dull it very quickly.
>I will try all the suggestions (except tossing it...I think maybe it can be saved)
Wally, I had wondered if this might be one of those times when a reverse would come in handy. Unfortunately, my Jet doesn't do that, but when I flip the bowl and put it in the chuck it will be effectively "reversed" so I will see what happens. Of course then I will probably have the same problem with the grain on the opposite side of the bowl! LOL When you wet sand with 80 grit, what kind of sandpaper do you use? The only wet/dry paper I have found around here is the black stuff which leaves black on the wood. Is there any reason not to wet sand with my regular wave discs?
>Carole, don't think of oil sanding with wet/dry sandpaper, except in fine grits. Just use a good grade of sandpaper preferably aluminum oxide. The sandpaper will clog very rapidly so I wouldn't use discs. I cut sheets of sandpaper into 6 pieces and use them double folded. Keep moving the SP and to fresh areas that aren't clogged. You'll be surprised at how fast using oil will clean up the areas of damaged wood. I only use oil with the heavy grits.
>I can't remember the name of it now but when I was at Black Forrest in Calgary, They had regular grit sandpaper but with a sponge backing. This was ideal to soak up the oiland use it as a lubricant while sanding.
I don't know if this was mentioned but another thing I learned from raffan was to lay a skew on its side and very gently go over the area.
>Of course you can use the scotch-brite pads. They hold oil quite nicely. Just go ahead and snip a piece off and put a little oil on it. I'd use through the coarse and the medium with oil and then switch to the wave system. Be careful with the fingers and wear a nitrile glove (the latex ones melt). My $0.02.
>Carole, it looks like black walnut and what you have there is very characteristic of that wood. I've done a lot of black walnut, it's a "junk wood" in my area and just about every piece I've turned I ran into this exact problem. Russ gave me the advice to rub it really good with Johnson paste wax then do the shear cut with the gouge. It worked for me.
Also Keith's advice to try cutting up the bowl instead of down just might do the trick. I could never be sure which way the grain was running before I shaped the bowl and often I'd have to cut uphill instead of down because I had the bowl upside down.
Good luck and with all the suggestions, SOMETHING has got to work.
>End grain on maple can be a real b....bear to cleanly cut, but I use a coat of thinned sanding sealer and a freshly sharpened gouge to lightly shear/ scrape a fresh surface. It case hardens if you keep pushing a cut with a less than really sharp tool.
>I had the same problem with red oak. I used my angle grinder with 60 or 80 grit & presto no mre rough end grain. I had worked for about an hour trying everything. Power sanding using a light touch knocked it down in less than a minute.
This is a real common problem that we all face, so we all have something to say ! It ought to go w/out saying that the first step is to sharpen and/or hone the cutting edges to get the smoothest cut.
I want to make sure I understand what I'm looking at here -- it looks to me like you're roughing the outside of a walnut bowl, held between centers on the lathe in bowl (side-grain) orientation, and the smaller diameter is to the left (as pictured). If this is not true, you can disregard my response, below:
If the above is true, you'd usually get the best quality cut going from left to right in the supplied photo -- from smaller diameter to larger diameter. Only problem is, there isn't such great tool access the way this blank is mounted, due to the mass of the headstock, so I would turn a tenon (for chuck) or flat circular area (for faceplate and/or glueblock) on what will be the opening of the bowl, and re-mount it from the top.
Mounted from the top of the bowl (widest dimension), the outside profile would be cut, again, from smaller diameter to larger diameter, or in this case (after bowl is reversed), from tailstock toward headstock, or right to left, as seen in a view like the photo. This orientation will give you a lot more room to maneuver the bowl gouge to get a delicate, shearing cut. If your mounting is secure enough, you can remove the tailstock to get even better access to the bottom of the bowl.
Like Keith, I often use a shallow but stiff spindle gouge to get the cleanest cut on the outside of a bowl, aiming for a very high, shearing angle cut. Unlike Keith, I usually use a 3/8" detail gouge with a swept-back grind, as this tool has a very small nose radius, so there is very low resistance as the wood is cut. I also use a 1/4" bowl gouge with a straight-across "English" or cinical grind and about 45-degree bevel, which sometimes cuts better than any other tool I try. I have had good results cutting across the tight-radius tip (flute to side), as well as cutting with the flute up, cutting on the far side of the bevel. On the outside of the bowl, I sometimes cut with the flute facing down, resulting in a very fine shear cut.
Another method a lot of turners employ is a shear scrape with an Ellsworth or Irish grind on a bowl gouge. To do this, I lower the rest well below center, hold the handle as far down toward the floor as I can, with the flute facing the bowl, contacting at or just above center. With the bowl held by the top, I do this with the handle leading -- that is downward, but angled toward the headstock end, while the cutting end is angled to the upper right, or toward the tailstock end. I then rotate the tool to open up the flute just enough that one edge very lightly scrapes the wood at a pretty high shear angle, while the other edge is just off the wood -- no more than 1/8" This scrape needs to be done very lightly, and with practice, will remove delicate and translucent tiny ribbons of wood. The only reason I lower the rest is to allow a steep angle to the floor and still be relatively close to the wood.
Like John Lucas wrote, without being there with you in the shop, that's about the best I can offer.
>Hey Brad! We think alike....I use the same bowl grind as you, I bet identical to the David Chapman grind. (?) Yes, it works well upside down as well. When I first saw his book, the similarities in my turning style and grinding technique were many.
The detail gouge is my secret weapon :with a long grind, it's amazing how well it works on turning a consistant line on forms...I should have mentioned that tool as well.
>I make a little scraper for this using the disposable blades from my thickness planer after they are dull. I cut them in half and round off the edge even more. I sharpen the ends with a thumb-nail shape and sharpen like a normal wood-chisel to about 25*, When sharpening this steel, you need to get it hot enough to turn it red while sharpening, because it is too brittle to roll the bur without fracturing the edge. Sharpen it razor sharp, then with a burnisher roll a bur to about 90* to the face. I like to use a burnisher without a handle which lays on the bench. I start out holding the tool in my fist with the side of my palm just touching the bench-top and the tool at about 45* to the burnisher. I start gently rolling the burnisher back and forth while bringing the blade up a little with each stroke. When I am through, I can still shave with the little hook edge.
When using this tool, I move the tool-rest out of the way, and am holding it freehand just below the centerline , and only enough of the tool sticking over the second bone of my index finger to allow me to gauge my cut by dragging my knuckle with my gloved hand of course.
I usually tilt the tool a little to get a shearing cut, and traverse pretty fast from small diameter out to the big diameter, unless I have a ridge to remove, which I may pass over several times before going back over the whole outside with several light passes. You need to keep the axis of the blade almost perpendicular to the surface, so that the cutting edge is cutting aggressively, Most turners that I have shown this to want to bring the butt end up too high, which turns the little bur back into a normal scraper which just makes the wood cells to crush rather than cut.
I usually mist the surface with water before going over to sharpen the tool which makes the cutting a little easier and cooler. The little shavings are about as fine as they get.
Did you ever tell what wood that is? I thought it looked like soft maple to me.
The opening for the bowl (maple) is too the left and the base (tenon) is to the right. Largest diameter is in the middle. As for the cut you describe, it sounds sort of like the vertical shear cut that I use. Once I flipped the piece and chucked the base, I had better luck with the shear cut. In fact I did not have to resort to the "80 grit gouge" route...at least not on the outside. The inside was another matter! LOL