Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

When is a blank unfit for a salad bowl?

Posts

When is a blank unfit for a salad bowl?

#1

When is a blank unfit for a salad bowl?

George Van in WI

>Terry Daniel’s post “insect spray and salad bowls” created a question for me that I could not answer. At what point is a bowl blank unfit for a salad bowl?

If the blank has insects in it must have holes and if it has holes is it safe for salad and food? Wont food particles hide in these holes and rot?

What about spalting (rot-fungus), at what degree of rot do you say it is not acceptable for food? When the bowl-dish is washed wont the fungus be activated by the water? If I use a surface finish, it will wear with use and eventually trap the moisture underneath it.

I have many roughed bowls in various stages of spalt, some small wormholes and would appreciate feedback.

All views are welcomed.

Re: When is a blank unfit for a salad bowl?

#2

Re: When is a blank unfit for a salad bowl?

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>George,

I would think that if you sand in your oil finish, you would fill most any of the tiny beetle holes.

As far as spalt is concerned, when you get your roughed blank dried out, the fungal action will stop. A good oil finish should keep the wood from being re-wetted. I would probably not use a spalted piece that had really soft spots for a salad bowl, though, unless I was keeping it for my own use. Wouldn't want your customer to have a chunk fall out if they got too aggresive with the tossing.

Gary

Re: When is a blank unfit for a salad bowl?

#3

Re: When is a blank unfit for a salad bowl?

George Van in WI

>Gary, had to chuckle with my image of the chunk popping out during the toss! :-)

I was concerned that a walnut/mineral oil finish would not be permanent and inpenetrable enough to keep the moisture from activating the fungus.

Re: When is a blank unfit for a salad bowl?

#4

Re: When is a blank unfit for a salad bowl?

Ruth Niles

>George,

I would think a blank is unfit for a salad bowl if you look at it and have to ask that question. People want their food vessels clean and no amount of explanation is going to make a person comfortable with putting their food in a fungus rot bowl.

That, of course, is one woman's opinion. : )

Ruth

Re: When is a blank unfit for a salad bowl?

#5

Re: When is a blank unfit for a salad bowl?

adrien

>Unless the user of the bowl keeps it full of water, it will be dried out between uses (is that grmmatical?). So the amount of fungal growth that could take place in the couple of hours that the bowl is moist is infinitesimal, especially if there's a coat of oil between the wood and the bowl.

Re: When is a blank unfit for a salad bowl?

#6

Re: When is a blank unfit for a salad bowl?

George Van in WI

>Hi Ruth, in this house “One woman’s opinion weighs pretty heavy”, if I know what’s good for me and my workshop acquisitions! All kidding aside you bring up a good point; I guess those in question would be better finished as non-salad bowls. Russ leaned that way in his Salad bowl article also.

Re: When is a blank unfit for a salad bowl?

#7

Re: When is a blank unfit for a salad bowl?

George Van in WI

>Adrian, I understand your point, and I think that head of lettuce may have been in worse places that a spalted salad bowl before it got to me but the bowls I’m thinking of may pose questions that are not necessary if I finish them for non salad use.

Re: When is a blank unfit for a salad bowl?

#8

Re: When is a blank unfit for a salad bowl?

Barry Turner

>This response comes from some 30+ years of experience with a health department in Kentucky. Our food code in Kentucky allows only hard maple to be used as a food-contact surface in restaurants. In the everday world, I would venture to say that any similar close-grained wood (like Black Cherry) could be used successfully and with little concern for safety. For use as a salad bowl, the wood should be sound, free of beetle or worm holes and reasonably free of spalting. The terminology that health inspectors use is "Smooth and easily cleanable". If a bowl is fraught with beetle or worm holes, or soft and pitted by spalt, then it is not. Such bowls are better relegated to the display shelf instead of the kitchen.

Re: When is a blank unfit for a salad bowl?

#9

Re: When is a blank unfit for a salad bowl?

Rick in Colgate, Wi

>But, aren't mushrooms, commonly used in salads, a fungus?

Reminds of the joke about the mushroom that walked into a bar and asked for a drink, the bartender said, "we dont serve mushrooms here", the mushrooms said "why not, I'm a fun-gi"!

Re: When is a blank unfit for a salad bowl?

#10

Good one, Rick! LOL!!

Ruth Niles

>

Re: When is a blank unfit for a salad bowl?

#11

Re: When is a blank unfit for a salad bowl?

George Van in WI

>Thanks Barry, good common sense.

Re: When is a blank unfit for a salad bowl?

#12

Re: When is a blank unfit for a salad bowl?

George Van in WI

>OK Fun-Gi,

If you come up at the right time for wood you can pick some "Schrooms" at the same time!