Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

insect spray and salad bowls

Posts

insect spray and salad bowls

#1

insect spray and salad bowls

tdaniel

>If a blank is destined to be a salad or fruit bowl and it has beetles, what is the safest way to get rid of the beetles without leaving harmful residues in the wood? We hear this question often. A member of our club suggested using a jarlid of gasoline placed in a plastic bag with the blank and put in the sun. As the gasoline turns to vapor it will kill most anything in the bag. Would any harmful chemicals be left in the wood with this process? Is there anything any better and safer?

TD

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

#2

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

Ron In Drums PA

>How big is the blank?

Can you give it a alcohol treatment?

I tried the plastic bag idea and it didn't work for me. I was using acetone.

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

#3

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

Glenn Hodges

>Terry, with the weather we are having in South Georgia you could put it in a sealed black bag, and place it in the direct sun, and it would cook the critters in a day. Soaking in DNA would do the trick. We used alcohol on cotton in a sealed jar to kill insects in school science classes when I was a teacher. Gasoline will do it, but I would worry about the smell so I would never use gasoline.

Nashville, GA

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

#4

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

Jim King

>Soak it in a chlorine solution over night.

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

#5

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

Ed Karch

>If it will fit stick it in the microwave and cook the protienatious little devels. Bag it in plastic first when it puffs up pull it out then let it cool slowly. repeat as necessary. No chemical residue.

Ed

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

#6

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

RevDoug

>TD, just read in the last day or two to freeze 'em to death. A day or two in the deep freeze will take care of them. I believe I would put the wood in a plastic bag first, in case the little buggers try to escape.

Turn 'em round,

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

#7

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

RevDoug

>Should have added that fumes can get into the wood and remain for quite a while, even coming through finishes. Chemicals designed to kill the varmets can leave residue in order to protect the material for years to come. I believe I would go with freezing, microwaving, or letting them drink themselves to death.

Turn 'em round

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

#8

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

Ron In Drums PA

>You would think,

I did that and placed the bag on a blacktop driveway for a month with tempd in the 90. Didn't work!

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

#9

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

Chris Andrew

>Put the blank in a plastic bag and stick it in your freezer for a couple of days. According to the Extension Service folks, 48 hours at 0 degrees (or less) will kill existing beetles and grubs in the wood.

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

#10

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Terry,

A good soak in mineral spirits will also rid your blank of those pesky little devils.

Gary

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

#11

You know what I am going to say.

Dave Smith, Longview, WA

>Soak the wood in denatured ethanol. There will be no residue from the alcohol. I cannot attest to the residue that may be present from the dead critters.

Boiling the wood will also kill critters. Freezing will kill critters but not necessarily eggs and spores. I have used freezing but I prefer alcohol soaking and boiling in that order. Ethanol is user friendly too.

Dave Smith

Alcohol everywhere but not a drop to drink in Longview, WA.

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

#12

Re: insect spray and salad bowls ????

Ruth Niles

>Come on, guys, with all the wood out there (our "medium" does grow on trees, after all) you really can't get a clean piece for salad bowls and use the buggy stuff for artistic turning? I can see patching holes with coffee grounds or crushed stone but why would anyone want to put all that time and effort into a piece with BUGS?

Sales pitch: "This piece of wood was full of bugs before I turned this divine salad bowl, but don't worry I sprayed, soaked, boiled, bagged and baked those little critters so they're all dead inside this 'food-safe' salad bowl."

Don't get me wrong, I've spent a lot of time soaking punky, spalted wood in a variety of solutions and they do work. But a salad bowl is the ultimate food contact vessel; how many people make their own dressing from vinegar and wine, all that acidity eating at the food-safe finish over the dead bugs.

Sorry, I don't mean to be disrespectful, I just don't get it.

Ruth

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

#13

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

adrien

>Somehow the freezing doesn't make sense as a bug killer. Are there no bugs in Alaskan wood? I'm sure the temperature there can get below freezing.

From the aesthetic point of view Ruth has a point. From the practical standpoint, how many bugs can there be in a half inch thick piece of wood? I'd've assumed the holes the bugs used to get there would've left them exposed to cleaning out. From the way you guys describe 'em, it sounds as if high speed turning would leave a great ring from wall to ceiling and floor as the thousands of grubs go flying!

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

#14

Re: insect spray and salad bowls ????

Don Henthorn

>You nailed it , Ruth.

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

#15

Re: insect spray and salad bowls ????

Ron Parsons SE NM

>Microwave!! If the wood is dry and the bugs are not. The bug should heat first. Hey this could be a good mithbusters!!

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

#16

Duuuhhh.

Barry Turner

>Well.........yeaaaah. Try putting the blank in the microwave. Or pick a blank without worm holes for use as a salad bowl.

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

#17

Carcinogens

Barry Turner

>Lets not forget that gasoline and acetone are carcinogens......not stuff I'd want to dress my salads with. Microwave the critters or freeze them, but it's much safer not to try to kill them with chemicals.

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

#18

Frostless freezer

Bob Hackett

>It`s not so much the cold as the freeze-drying effect that kills them.

Safest way I know of to kill the unwanted livestock short of giving them a haircut on the Conover.

Mainely,Bob

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

#19

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

RevDoug

>Now that you have all these answers, why do you ask?

Turn 'em round

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

#20

Re: insect spray and salad bowls ????

Jim King

>Ruth: I´m with you. Here they look for bugs to serve in the bowls. Why worry about a few that are hiding.

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

#21

Re: Better and Safer

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Burn the bug-infested chunk and then go get yourself a piece of wood that you can concentrate on turning instead of playing wanna-be Orkinman. There's just too much fine wood out there to be messing with bugs in one piece. It's only wood, ya know.

Would you, regardless of what anyone says, like to eat out of a piece of wood that's been fumigated with petrochemicals of undetermined type in addition to the basic benzene which is a proven poisen to humans as well as bugs? Yes, this IS a trick question.

M

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

#22

No trick; thanks for answers....

tdaniel

>Twas not a trick question. Actually what happened was a lady came in and bought a rough turned blank that had spalting and bug holes. The rough bowl was about 19" diameter and she wanted a gloss finish on it so I did not think she planned to use it as a salad bowl, we are talking $600 here. After finishing it for her I found out that she plans to use it as a salad bowl. It has about 30 coats of Watco danish Oil on it (full penetration) so anything in the wood is sealed pretty well, there is no smell and the little holes filled in while sanding with the oil; still, it got me thinking. Most of my turnings sell while still in the rough so I am wondering if I should separate my stacks of rough outs to one for food use and another for non food use? If I do that then I have to explain each time why these are not suitable for a salad bowl, yada, yada. Micro-waving is out as many of these pieces won't fit into a mv, (some won't fit into the freezer either). Thanks to everyone for their thoughts.

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

#23

PS - Gas

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Noticed the same issue on WOW and Jamie Donaldson raised a good point worth repeating here.

Put the wood and gas in a sealed plastic bag in the sun and you've made a crude, but possibly very effective fuel/air bomb.

Jamie didn't think this was such a great idea for killing bugs.

I tend to agree with him.

M

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

#24

Re: PS - Gas

Stuart Johnson

>Mark, thanks for the follow up here. I posted the orginal over on WOW after reading about it here. After seeing Jamie's post I deleted my message and was going to bring it up in the chat session tomorrow night to see what others thought.

I do think Jamie is correct and can just see someone opening the bag up while smoking. On the other hand there might be some bargins at the estate sale.

Re: insect spray and salad bowls

#25

Re: The Dead Man's Lathe

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Not being superstitious or nuthin', but I'll take a pass on those kinds of deals.