Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

A hard one...

Posts

A hard one...

#1

Steven Antonucci

A hard one...

steve antonucci

>I make my own tools, and I thought it would be cool to get a 1/4" x 2" carbide rod to make cutting bits.

I didn't think it would be this impossible to cut the stuff!

I want to cut it in half, then grind cutting edges. Easier said than done. My Dremel with a cutoff bit was comical, and a hacksaw blade didn't even scratch it. Grinding on my belt sander was also a fruitless waste of my time.

So what do I use to cut carbide?

Steve

Re: A hard one...

#2

diamond blade?

Rob Ceraso

>

Re: A hard one...

#3

JL

Re: A hard one...

JL

>Diamonds work nicely. Don't know about your carbide rod, but carbide can get up to 90 on the Rockwell scale. Tool steel is not as hard, as I recall good plane blades are about 60 or so. I think maybe silicon carbide might work, but have never tried it.

Re: A hard one...

#4

Re: A hard one...

William M. Zerby

>Steve,

The only things I know of that works on carbide are Silicon Carbide grnding wheels/stones or diamond wheels/stones(These are either resin bonded, vitrified(new) or electroplated to a substrate). Typicially C3 or C4 carbide run in the 95-97RHC (Rockwell Hardness C scale). At that hardness there is not much that can touch it(since the C scale runs from 0 - 100, with 0 being inifinitey soft and 100 being infinitely hard.) I have been told that 0 represents H2O and 100 represents diamond as practical limits.

Kindest regards,

Bill

Re: A hard one...

#5

Re: A hard one...

tdaniel

>grind a notch in it and put it in a vise and break it off with a hammer.

Re: A hard one...

#6

Re: I'd scrap the carbide idea.

Al Crandall--NE of Indy--

>In addition to being hard, as you have already found out, carbide must be ground with diamond impregnated grinding wheels. There are some friable green wheels out there which will erode carbide, but you won't like the finish they leave on your tool. Since you didn't know about the diamond thing, I'm guessing that you don't have any wheels lying around. They are going to be expensive for the little use you are going to have for them. Carbide will not take as sharp an edge as tool steels. I doubt there is much of an overall benefit, all things considered. Another fact of life is that as hardness increases, so does brittleness. You will need to design your tool with as little unsupported overhang as possible so that it doesn't snap off at the first catch. Torque on a set screw which might be used to hold a steel bit in a tool may be just enough to shatter the carbide when it is subjected to the shock of an interrupted cut.

Re: A hard one...

#7

If you do find a good solution

Guy in Cuba

>let me know. I, too, am looking at making my own tools, as the price of the hollowing cutters are a little high.

How did you intend to attach the cutter? Drill a hole for a set screw or sandwich between bar and washer?

Thanks, Guy

Re: A hard one...

#8

Re: If you do find a good solution

William M. Zerby

>Al, Guy,

I met a gentleman at the AAW Symposium named Mike Hunter. He is a carbide salesman. He told me about a newer carbide type. Apparently carbide is graded by grain size. They had to develop a nano-grained carbide structure to be able to make two-flute drill bits in the .007" diameter range for drilling printed circuit boards. He is making tools that are designed to use these nano-grained carbide inserts. I saw some tooling. It looked very impressive. Especially when he told me he had to dull the cutter with a diamond stone to make it less aggressive! I'll send him an email and ask for permission to post it here.

Kindest regards,

Bill

Re: A hard one...

#9

Re: If you do find a good solution

William M. Zerby

>All,

Mike Hunter's email address is MLH55410@aol.com. If you are interested in carbide tooling for woodturner's.

Kindest regards,

Bill

Re: A hard one...

#10

Mike Hunter

Re: If you do find a good solution

Mike Hunter

>Carbide tooling will work just fine for turning tools. The secret is finding the right grade of carbide and then working with the edge prep to keep it from breaking off. Correctly done ... these tools are as sharp as HSS.

Re: A hard one...

#11

Re: A hard one...

John Lucas

>Steve I think I would go with HSS bits. You can use a dremel with cutoff wheel to either cut the carbide or scatch it and break it with a hammer. You will need a green grinding wheel to sharpen carbide. Your white,pink, blue or gray wheels won't do anything. You can of course sharpen it with a diamond wheel or hone. It takes so little time to sharpen a HSS bit that I don't think it's worth it to go with carbide.

I tried one of the triangle shaped carbide cutters to use as a hollowing scraper. I don't think it worked much better than the HSS and I had to set up another grinder with the green wheel to sharpen it. I had a friend who was going to bring me one of the ceramic cutters they use to see how that would work. I haven't seen him in a while so either he doesn't work there anymore or we just keep missing each other. They do require diamonds to sharpen

Re: A hard one...

#12

Steven Antonucci

Thanks to all...

steve antonucci

>I've sort of given up on it. $5 lesson in "if it works, leave it alone". Up 'til now, I've always used HSS or O1. I was just messin' around, and I learned something...

Good enough is good enough.

Steve

P.S. I also learned that HSS doesn't bend like O1.