Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Is this firewood?

Posts

Is this firewood?

#1

Is this firewood?

Carole in VA

>Black cherry that has a crack following the grain that runs about two thirds the way around the bottom. I have CAed it, but I am wondering if I am wasting my time or if I am taking a big chance on this thing flying apart when I chuck it up. Should I just toss it, or do you guys and gals go ahead and try to finish stuff like this? My instincts are telling me to toss it, but I have another bowl made from this cherry and it is beautiful when it is finished. It has some nice figure that doesn't show in the pics.


img

Re: Is this firewood?

#2

Re: Is this firewood?

Joe Herrmann

>I think I would be more inclined to chuck it and start over rather than taking the chance and having it explode. Life is too short to turn bad wood, especially when there is so much good stuff out there. Sometimes you just have to relegate pieces to the fire pile and move on.

Joe

Re: Is this firewood?

#3

Re: Is this firewood?

Kevin Gerstenecker

>Carole, I think to be on the safe side, I would put this one aside and not try to finish turn it. The potential for this flying apart and causing injury is not worth the risk in my opinion. I know it is tough to part with such a beautiful piece of wood, but it is better than getting hurt. If it hurts to part with it, I will gladly send you a nice Cherry Blank to replace it. See, now wasn't that easy? :-)

Re: Is this firewood?

#4

I vote for firewood

Mike Schwing from Md.

>For the reasons Joe and Kevin have given.

Re: Is this firewood?

#5

Thanks guys

Carole in VA

>I will listen to both you and my instincts. Don't feel like getting hurt. Kevin, thanks for the offer of the blank, but I think I have two more blanks from that log...hope they don't do the same thing. I don't know know if that is a compression crack or a wind check or what, but I seem to run across it a lot in the little bit of wild cherry I have been able to get my hands on.

Re: Is this firewood?

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: Thanks guys

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Carole, all is not lost....cut it up for small boxes, etc. They make nice gifts, and are lots of fun.

Re: Is this firewood?

#7

Is this firewood? ... NOT YET

e

>carole: it probably doesn't have life as a 'functional piece' however .... it has lots of life left as 'something else' ...

sculptural, burned, painted, etc.

i never destroy anything that i've put time into because i never know when i'll need something to experiment with, or transform into a new form.

Re: Is this firewood?

#8

Re: Is this firewood? ... NOT YET

Carole in VA

>e,

I have not hollowed it yet...I am afraid that dense hunk of wood will give way at the crack when I put it in the chuck. When I put the thin CA on it, it seeped out the opposite side of the blank. I am going to just put it on the shelf until I have a little more experience...see if the crack extends any over time. One day when I am feeling brave.... :)

Re: Is this firewood?

#9

Re: Is this firewood? ... NOT YET

Ed Kelle

>Carole,

I had a similar situation Monday. I had some nice sugar maple that I got last year, finally got around to cutting up the blanks and found some nice spalting. I started turning one of the blanks and notices some slight radial cracks. CA'd them and turned some more then sanded. I saw more appearing, so I decided to turn them away and go thru the sanding process again. They later reappeared. By this time I got "aggravated" and left it for the night. The next day I had a lot more and bigger cracks. Obviously this is some flawed wood and there is no way I am putting a heavy blank back on the lathe for hollowing. Its just not wort the risk for me. But I think I will keep it to do some experiments on, with textures, burning or even finishes. If it is going to come apart, its going to do so while its NOT spinning.

Seeing how yours has a big crack running so close to the tenon, doesn't seem worth the risk to me. be brave with a good piece of wood instead

:)

Re: Is this firewood?

#10

Re: Is this firewood?

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Carole, put me in the firewood category. It looks like ring shake, which means that it is very likely going to delaminate under power and fly straight at your head. Yeah you have time in it, but who wants to sit in the ER and ruminate on why they should not have persisted?

Bill

Re: Is this firewood?

#11

Ring shake

Keith Newton

>If your glue-line had been a little tighter, I would have said to go for it, however, that gap looks a little wide.

It looks like you were ready to hollow, and would not be standing in-line, or in the danger zone.

Most of the cherry in my area is afflicted with ring shake, along with the oaks and others. I have been having a discussion with a Ph.D.. wood scientist about the cause of ring shake. I think that it is weather related. He says that it is all bacteria related, and starts in the roots and progresses upward by only a few inches per year.

If you have more that has the shake, and know where it grew, when it was harvested, and at what point within the tree your blank occurred, I would like for you to count some rings for me so I can check the weather records for your locality.

Re: Is this firewood?

#12

That's it!

Carole in VA

>Ring shake! Couldn't for the life of me think of what it was called. I'll just use it to practice burning on.

Re: Is this firewood?

#13

Re: Ring shake

Carole in VA

>Keith, I know that it grew in Accomack County, VA and that it was cut last year. What little I had has been cut into blanks. I am going to try and cut some on the farm this winter. If I do I will make some notes so I can let you know if I find shake. It grows along our hedge rows and fields. The trees are ALWAYS twisty and gnarly.

Re: Is this firewood?

#14

Firewood? Perish the Thought!

Barry Turner

>I say continue to turn it. Stay out of the line of fire and keep the lathe speed low. Even if it eventually does wind up in the firewood box, you will have gained immeasureable experience in dealing with a crack of this magnitude..........and the next cracked bowl you have may be a keeper.

Re: Is this firewood?

#15

That would be...

Paul in Phoenix

>...perfect wood here in AZ with only one crack. It's definitely saveable (is that a word?).

Re: Is this firewood?

#16

Yes...according to Merriam-Webster.

Jay in TX

>

Re: Is this firewood?

#17

Life's Too short Carole :)

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>