Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (long)

Posts

Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (long)

#1

Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (long)

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Many of you know that I am fond of sanding my display pieces to very high grits. When I post my sanding/finishing regimen, someone invariably asks why. A very reasonable question! I thought this would be a good topic for discussion here and would like to ask for your participation, if you have an opinion or observation you feel comfortable sharing.

First, what is a high grit? For this discussion, let's make it anything higher than P600, since this is probably close to the finest paper many turners ever use. Really high? 4000 on the P scale or 12,000 Micro Mesh.

As a child, every year I watched my father sand the brightwork, usually mahogany, on his boat to 1500 before applying a finish. His brightwork was by far and wide the highest quality of any you could find, and he won many awards. Sanding so high brought out the grain like nothing else, so much so that it caused a dramatic reaction from a viewer when compared to something sanded to much less fine a grit. It also prepared the surface for applying a building finish, closing pores and creating such a fine surface that more light reflected off of it back through the finish - true "brightwork". I learned to do the same to the wood on my little Boston Whaler, and then on a pair of Cypress Gardens water skis, and so on, and so on...

So when I started really woodworking, I already knew the "finish goes on before the finish goes on" routine. I also have many years experience in an auto body shop, where sanding is at least as important. So thats it for the background.

Now for woodturning. Sanding to a high grit reveals more of what is underneath that finely sanded surface. That includes any sanding defects from previous grits. Extreme, fanatical attention to sanding detail is needed on the heavier grits, or they will show right through your nicely sanded P600 surface. Move that up to P4000 and you've got really noticeable sanding scratches. It takes a lot of time to do this, which is a definite drawback. If I can sand a piece to 320 in 30 minutes, it might take me 3 hours to bring it up to P4000 with no defects visible. I still think it is worthwhile, because I know it is the best I am capable of producing.

Try this for yourself. Take a board and sand a section to 320, then a section to 600, then 1500 or even go up higher. Put a coat of wax or watco on it. Buff it dry. See the HUGE difference? (of course you do)

Sanding like this on bare wood is no different than sanding out a lacquered finish to produce a high gloss or sheen. Do both and you'll have a workpiece that will stun viewers.

Besides making the grain stand out in ways simply not possible with rougher grits, the finish goes on easier, takes fewer coats, and shines better as well. Why? Finely sanding a surface has the effect of closing the pores or almost burnishing the wood. Don't believe me? Put a piece of thin, unsanded wood on a vac drum. Notice the gauge reading. Turn off the vacuum. Sand that board to a high grit, then blow or brush away any dust. Turn the vac on again. Note the huge improvement in vacuum draw. So with a surface thusly applied, the finish does not sink in to the wood. Yes, Watco and other drying oils harden inside the wood, perhaps making a more durable piece, but my goal is to finish a display piece with a visible finish. I don't really care about it soaking in. Also, finishes shine because they reflect light back to your eye. A finely sanded surface shines on its own, adding to the light reflection going back through the finish to your eye, making your piece look even better.

People will say that finishes won't stick to finely sanded surfaces. Every time someone says that I ask them to provide any scientific proof. I'm happy to change my opinion when provided with proof. So far - none.

I use two different types of fine grit paper - Micro Mesh and more recently Abralon pads. The Micro Mesh has smaller jumps in between grits, and therefore, I believe produces a better surface. But the soft backed Abralon pads (http://turningwood.com/) go much much faster and produce a beautiful, just gorgeous finish. The Micro Mesh seems to last longer, but the Abralon is much less expensive.

Is this method applicable to all turnings? Not in my opinion. A utility piece will quickly become scratched and ugly if finished in such fashion. Much better, IMO, to finish a utility piece up to 220, maybe 320. But display work - you bet I think it is worth it. Examine the bowl in the "Sorry Jamie" post - look at the grain and tell me if you can get that look with 220 or 320.

These are just my opinions, and obviously I have written this as a "pro" high grit opinion. I don't wish or need to convince anyone but I sure would love to hear your opinions and what you do similarly or differently. Thanks!

Re: Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (long)

#2

Re: Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (lon

Ed Kelle

>I'm a sanding freak as well, though I don't have grits as fine as you have. After 220 I have some sanding pads which to up to 1200. I expect that I will be looking into those that you mentioned in the near future. And I need those velcro pads for my still unused sander. My hands are getting tired of all this work.

Re: Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (long)

#3

sanding mouse

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>Mike I ordered some Abralon yesterday. I’ve never used it or micromesh before. Do you have any tips on how to use it? Are you using it wet or dry? If you are using it wet what are you using for the lubricant? I have used automotive wetand dry paper that goes up to 2000 grit.

I have been using my sanding mouse with the detail attachment for doing some of my sanding. It is limited on where it will reach inside bowls, but works quite well on the outside. It saves some time and can work right up the edge of a bead or detail that is hard to get to with a sanding disk. I also use my random orbital sander on the parts of bowls and platters where it can reach. I know all sanding leave scratches, but I think the random orbit pattern doesn’t show up as much. It is faster than sanding by hand. When it comes to sanding I’ll try anything to refine the process, both for speed and quality.

Tom

Re: Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (long)

#4

It All Depends

Jim Shaver, Oakville Ontario

>Hi Mike,

I like your post. Sanding for me is about much of what you have stated, basically though preparing the finish for the finish is a great phrase.

For me it depends on the materials I am finishing and the final "look" I am after.

Say with pens, I usually use materials that are stabilized or man made, so I use a variety of sanding processes, but basically micromesh is my way to go with a final plastic fine abrasive polish. I am not sanding the work to shape as much as I am sanding the finish to polish.

When I am sanding a turning, I usually sand the wood till I can no longer see the marks, for me, starting at about 150 and finishing about 400 grit. I still use some degree of sanding of the finished turning to clean up my shapes, but not a great deal, mostly around 180 grit. Then I apply an oil, maybe a clear coat. Then I begin to fine sand the finish, either with Micromesh or straight to my Beall buffing compounds through to wax. The luster I want also can be achieved with 0000 steel wool after the oil application.

My furniture is different, usually hand planed and scraped, some times sanded, seldom finer than 220 on base woods. I use clear coats as well, wet sanded to 600 or even with 0000 steel wool with a final wax application.

For me the sanding process depends on the "look" I want, so I feel comfortable moving around with the materials for finishing, I have no set rules in my process except for the final look, and getting there can vary depending on how I feel or my materials.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (long)

#5

Some thoughts (long)

John Trant (Baltimore/DC corridor)

>Hi Mike,

This is also a topic near and dear to my heart. My father was an apprentice under a master refinisher in my hometown so "finishing before finishing" was simply how it was done at our house. Period.

I agree with what you wrote both in general and in principal. I feel that most turners do not spend nearly enough time preparing or finishing their turnings. It is beyond me why someone would spend an hour (or many more) turning a vessel and then opts to insult it with a 10-minute finish job. A production turner of utilitarian bowls, yes, but not someone that turns a fine display piece. I have quietly applauded your campaign to heighten our awareness of “good finishing” but since you have expressly brought it up as a discussion thread, I have a few caveats to add to your discourse.

First of all, it has been well know for decades (to me) that sanding to a higher grit inhibits finish and stain penetration. Sand a board of hard maple to 180 grit and sand another to 600 grit. Apply a finish or stain and it will be obvious that the two boards absorbed vastly different amounts of material. In fact, it is standard practice in furniture making (in my shop) to sand the face of the boards to 220 and the endgrain to 400. This will greatly even out the finish-induced color differences between the two grain presentations. Does the finish penetrate enough to stick to the highly sanded wood? Of course it does. Is there a difference in penetration? Of course there is.

Second, I have found that it is more important to sand the wood well than to sand it to a very high grit. In my shop, I opt for the former and leave the high grits to the hardened finish. Too often, I have been confronted by a fellow turner complaining that I have withheld a secret because my finishes are scratch-free but his are marred by ugly scratches even though we both sanded to the same grit. Obviously, he did not sand well. It is very important to remove the scratches caused by the previous grit and to blow out the wood dust/loose grit mixture otherwise you will get errant 150 grit scratches when sanding with 180 or 220 grit paper. Most of us know these rules from our flatwork days but the important rule most have forgotten is to "sand with the grain". In woodturning this means stop the lathe and hand sand for 30 seconds with the grain on the inside and outside of the bowl. Sand until all the scratches are running parallel to the grain. I do this with each grit, spending the most time at the lower grits. Failure to do this at the high grits will require one to sand to the highest grits to hide the cross grain scratches. This may be why some turners swear by the ultra high grits and some of us do not feel that it is necessary if proper techniques are employed.

Third, sanding to a very grit on very hard woods, especially hard oily exotic woods, will result in a very rewarding finish. Sanding to a very high grit on softer woods or very open grained woods will not be so rewarding. Sanding soft maple to any more than P600 is fruitless and simply continues to burnishes the surface. A soft surface cannot be effectively polished. The extreme example is poloshing a gem stones versus jello. A more reasonable example is polishing a fully hardened finish to a high gloss versus trying to do the same with an incompletely cured finishes. Of course, soft maple, an open grained wood like walnut, or even woods that suffer from both characteristics (mahogany) can be well sanded, the pores filled, and the finish polished to any sheen desirable. Now don't get me wrong, I will sand (burnish) turnings of soft hardwoods to P-600 (but rarely on my flatwork) because it evens out the potential finish-induced color differences in the endgrain and the side grain of a bowl or spindle. Bottom line, I agree with Mike that higher grits yeild finer results but our logic is not the same and I do not feel the ultra high grits are necessary to achive these results.

I reject the opinion that one does not need to sand well because they want a rustic look or it is simply a utilitarian bowl (not voice by Mike but have heard too often through the years). Perhaps the highest grit are not necessary but the scratches must be reduced so as to be invisible to the eye. Cross grain scratches are never OK. Scratches are simply a mark of sloppy work. It is the attention to details the brings in the big bucks for turners like Mike and the many others on the WC.

Finally, my advice is to sand well (to a reasonable grit as dictated by the wood), apply many coats of the finish well, and rub out the finish before polishing.

A related pet peeve is the “quick and dirty” finishes that plague the average woodturner. Yes, these finishes are quick but hardly worthy of our best work. But that is another thread completely and will be discussed some other day.

I enjoyed venting. Good thread Mike!

John

Re: Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (long)

#6

JL

Re: Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (lon

JL

>I posted this a while back on the Hand Tools side. The picture is a side x side x side SEM photomicrograph of some maple sanded to 100, 220 and 400 grits. I haven't had the time to do further work on this. If you want, I can take the grit size up a bit further. I was planning on a little project comparing sanding and finishing for flatwork.


img

Re: Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (long)

#7

Re: Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (lon

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>A very interesting and informative thread. I agree with Mike, although I don't sand with a grit higher than 1500. I also agree with John. How you sand has a great deal to do with the final results. Wood likes to be sanded with the grain.

I'd like to add that preparing the wood before sanding is a very important part of the process. Sharpen your tools before making the final cuts. Learn how to make sweeping cuts with the bowl gouge, with the bevel facing up and cutting near the nose. Make final cuts with the grain. Learn to carefully shear scrape with the grain to remove all damaged surfaces, such as end-grain tear. Wood that has been properly turned in the final stages will allow you to eliminate using the heavier grits, making sanding easier and more effective. Don't over-use sandpaper. Over use will tend to burnish the wood, which hardens the surface, making it more difficult to remove sanding scratches from previous grits.

Wally

Re: Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (long)

#8

Re: Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (lon

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>Awsome picture JL and a great discussion overall! I think you all have nailed down the important parts, so I'll just say thanks!

Re: Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (long)

#9

Re: Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (lon

Frank Martin

>Mike,

good discussion. as I continue to learn and build my skills, one of the hardest lessons I've had to learn is patience. Sanding well takes patience, sanding well enough to hold up as you move up through the grits takes lots of patience. In the responses above, two points really hit home for me. One was the need to stop the lathe and sand with the grain to get the last scratches out, especially at lower grits. The second was that the smart turner will have patience and do a really good job at the lower grits so that nasty surprises don't turn up as you go higher and force you to go back. I've had problems with both of these.

My current regimen doesn't yet go to Micro Mesh or Abralon, but I do sand most pieces up to 1000 grit, finish and then Beall buff with good results.

Bottom line, I'll agree with Mike. If its a piece you are proud of, then take the time to finish it well, and you'll be even more proud.

frank

Re: Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (long)

#10

Brad Vietje

Hobby or Profit ?

Brad Vietje

>Here's another P.O.V...

As an amateur, who occasionally sells work through galleries, I can afford the time that such attention to detail requires. If I opt to spend 15 hours of sanding and buffing and sanding and buffing to get the most perfect finish I can achieve on a delicate hollow form or seminal work, so be it.

The problem comes when you try to make a living at turning, and time becomes money -- big money in some cases. My point is that as an amateur, I can take all the time in the world to produce a great-looking finish, but unless I get my pieces into the highest-priced galleries, I'll never be able to pay myself for all the work.

If you have to turn out a high-quality product to pay your bills and feed your family, some middle ground may be more practical. I can produce a great finish, and have, especially for contests or juried shows -- but no doubt I'd starve if I needed to make a living doing so.

Sometimes I hear comments from amateurs or part-timers like myself, grumbling that they can do as well as some of the pro's out there. Sure enough, because we don't have to account for our time quite the same way.

Just more fodder for consideration,

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT

Re: Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (long)

#11

Re: Discussion fodder - Newbie Questions

Dave Fuqua

>Great thread. I have been acquiring some of the higher grits and 'practicing' (read that as not being entirely satisfied with the results of my technique) different finishing methods -- some from Wood Central posts, some from books, and some mad scientist experiments.

My sanding questions are: What is your preferred method of cleaning/preparing the work in between grits? Do you use a compressor to blow out the fine dust? How about soft cloth with mineral spirits (seems to work OK for me)? Scotch bright pads? I have heard of people using a lot of different methods and was just curious if you had a preference and if so does it vary from wood to wood -- soft wood versus hardwood, green versus dry, dense oily wood versus lighter not so oily woods?

The reason I ask is that I often waffle and can't decide when to move up to the next grit. When I manage to clean it well I get a better look and feel for how smooth it really is.

I have a million other questions about finishing and dealing with end grain, bark inclusions, sanding/finishing segmented turnings with wildly varying wood grains, but those can wait. . .

Thanks,

Dave

Re: Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (long)

#12

Re: Discussion fodder - Newbie Questions

John Trant (Baltimore/DC corridor)

>I personally use compressed air to clean my vessels between grits but that is because I now have my Dad's old compressor. Prior to its aquisition, I would simply wipe it well with a dry rag. Checking your progress with mineral spirites is a great method to verify that you have accomplished your task (irrespective of your method of sanding).

John

Re: Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (long)

#13

Re: Hobby or Profit ?

John Lucas

>Brad You nailed it. I plan on running a test to see if going to a higher grit will help my turnings (art turnings that is) but so far I've found that with the lacquer finish I use, 400 grit is fine followed by the the lacquer aplications and beal system. My customers are always commenting on the high quality of my finish.

On my hand mirrors I simply can't afford the time to go higher except on rare pieces that do sell for more money. On wine stoppers I only sand to 320 because the finish that I use doesn't seem to know the difference between 320 and higher. I did polish some ebony to 1500 grit one time but the wood looked like plastic so I knocked it back down and finished that wood with an oil and 600 grit paper.

With my woods and my finish I haven't found it necessary to go to the higher grits but I never take anyone's word at something because I feel you have to test things under your own circumstances. Therefore, hopefully this weekend, I will take a couple of pieces of wood and sand different sections to higher grits and then apply the finish and see for myself. Then if it does make a difference I will have to weight the cost effectiveness of using the higher grits and paying myself for the time. Thanks for bringing this up Mike because it's something I've been meaning to do.

Re: Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (long)

#14

May I offer a "friendly amendment"

John Trant (Baltimore/DC corridor)

>I believe you are absolutely correct if you would permit me to amend your discussion to the production turners (a large subset of professional turners). Those turning out architectural features or functional bowls (i.e., the same shape over and over again) will find ways to do things faster and "good enough". Power sanding with oil is an excellent example for salad bowls and a coat of paint over minimally sanded architectural pieces is another.

However, many of the turners we often think about are not production turners (with the exception of the likes of Nick Cook, Richard Raffan and some of our own WC'ers). The reknown professional turners that make one-of-a-kind pieces or thematic series of pieces (i.e., artsy fartsy display pieces) will use the utmost care in both preping and finishing. I am thinking of the likes of Stuart Mortimer, Trent Bosch, Mark Nantz, Al Stirt, Cindy Drozda, Binh Pho, etc, etc, etc. Of course, their prices demand the extra minutes (not hours)of sanding and the few extra hours (spread out over days) for finishing.

John

Re: Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (long)

#15

Brad Vietje

Way Cool !

Brad Vietje

>Cool !

I used to do a LOT of TEM work, but only a little Scanning Electron Microscopy. I'm assuming these are side-grain samples sanded with the grain ? It would be oh-so-cool to also look at end grain pieces, say the top surface of a wine stopper, to see how that looks.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT

Re: Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (long)

#16

Re: May I offer a "friendly amendment"

John Lucas

>John I forgot to mention paint. I find it a complete waste to sand beyond 220 for painted wood. I don't know if the paint bonds any better to 220 vs 1500 but it sure goes on smoother. I had heard this from a friend who is an architectural turner. I had to make a dozen platters that were to be painted by brush because I didn't have a sprayer back then. I sanded some to 220 and some to 600. The paint went on smoother on the 220. Not sure why, could be my brush, my technique or even the particular paint but I had trouble with the paint not spreading as even on the 600 grit.

Re: Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (long)

#17

Re: Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (lon

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Fantastic subject/Thread, Mike. Long overdue.

As you know, sanding is one of my things too. I grew up around an auto body paint shop as well. I spent many hundreds of hours ROS and Wet sanding paint and primer.

I agree with the contention that sanding to high grits does not effect adhesion of finishes to the wood surface. It does effect pennitration. Unless the finish beads up, it is pennitrating.

I will add a caveat to your comment about 10 minute finishes. IF you sand to a high quality finish, there are many quick/simple (10 minute?) finishes that will look good (maybe not as good as some that take longer, I will grant you). On many exotics, a simple wax finish will look great.

HOWEVER, we must all remember that there is no finish that will hide a poorly sanded finish.

In my opinion, you can take any bowl - any bowl - to a great sanded finish in under 90 minutes. I power sand all my bowls on the lathe, up through the first couple of coats of lacquer. Wood is sanded up to at least 800 grit. 60 (if necessary), 100, 150, 220, 320, 400, 600, 800, (1000, 1500.....). Each grit is no more than 50% higher (numarically) than the one before, and in general only takes about 50-75% of the time to sand as the grit before. Since I turn mostly segmented, the grain is already running the same direction as the rotation of the lathe, so my sanding time may be different that others.

On sanding finishes to high gloss - I am not so sure that there is a difference in the results between sanding up through the grits to MicroMesh 12000, and sanding to P-1500/2000 and then hand buffing it with a swirl remover like 3M Finess-IT. But hand buffing with the swirl remover is sure faster.

I will continue to follow this tread with interest.

Mark

Re: Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (long)

#18

Re: Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (lon

DWFII

>One question I have always had is...once a feller sands to say, 2000 Abralon, does an abrasive based shellac "finish" (I can't think of the product name--comes from Australia or NZ) do any good?

For that matter does a buffing with white diamond do any good...make the surface any smoother, take it any further?

DW

In the High Desert of Central Oregon

Re: Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (long)

#19

JL

Re: Way Cool !

JL

>Fine, you section one and send it to me. I'll look at it. For that matter, I can look at just about any thin section. I basically need a piece that is about 1/16" thick. Mark the side that you don't want "scanned". Largest size to mount on a stub is about 3/8" x 3/8".

Re: Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (long)

#20

Yup, I'm one of those...

Peter Teubel

>...who asked why. Thanks for the explaination, Mike. Makes sense and I will try that method on some of my pieces. Thanks for taking the time to post the info!

Re: Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (long)

#21

Re: Yup, I'm one of those...

Steve Worcester

>Gosh, where do I begin.

In the "pro" turning ranks, I would have to divide those folks into two categories (sanding-wise).

Utilitarian and non-utilitarian, or as my flat work buddy calls it- laying around the house stuff.

Something that is going to be used for food or everyday use, would rarely get sanded above 400. Some of it has to do with the finish they use, mostly oil-based food safe type products, where penetration is important, and the increase in time is not going to provide any better of a visual appeal. Yes, time is money, but it would not be time (money) well spent.

As for the non-utilitarian types (art for art sakes?) the type who turn hollow forms, sculptures, etc., the maker takes considerable time to ensure a scratch free finish, and go through the extra time to make sure there are no scratches. I take my cue from a fellow Texan (and friend) Gary Sanders, who's lidded boxes, are of impeccable finish. I know that he will sand down to 1 micron if need be. (Beyond where Micro-Mesh goes).

But each person needs to decide on an individual piece basis, what they are looking for. I have seen big name turners who demand big dollars for their "art" type work, and there are very visible scratches in the pieces. Obvious that they do not take the time to use means available to them to find and eradicate the pesky scratch marks before they move on.

One of the common misconceptions though is that tool marks and tear out can all be removed with sandpaper. David Ellsworth early on told me that he can pick up a piece and feel how much sanding was done, vs the quality of the tools' cut. It is more evident in the woods we have in the US which are much softer than those on other continents. An Ash, Maple, etc, with the varying grain densities between early and late wood, will start to carve out on the softer portions of the cross grain and you will start to feel valleys across the grain if you have had to sand longer than need be.

As for painting, if I am going to paint something, up to 220 is fine, because any marks up to that point are usually filled in with the medium.

Personally, I will rarely sand anything below 600 grit, even salad bowls. I feel that the product and the customer deserve it. But then again, all of the work I have in galleries are made to lay around the house. ;)

Steve Worcester

WWW.TURNINGWOOD.COM

Re: Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (long)

#22

Keith Tompkins

Re: Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (lon

Keith Tompkins

>HI Mike, great post....I sand all my turnings to 600 wet or dry, or even finer. The difference between 220 and 600 is clearly obvious, especially when the first finish coat is applied. I carry sanding between grits a step further, wetting the piece between each grit, which raises the grain along with any deeper scratches.I don't power sand, just a hard foam pad beneath the sandpaper. I keep it moving, which helps prevent the paper from making circular rings on the work.My lacquer finishes are sanded to 2500 grit, then buffed. Most turners don't stain their work, so that aspect is not too important.

Does it really work? I handed one of my pieces to a well known gallery owner.....they handled the piece for what seemed minutes. Suddenly in a very quiet voice: "Oh my God! This can't be wood!"

Re: Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (long)

#23

One thing stands out in this discussion

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>The thing that really struck me as I was reading this thread is that everyone that knew how to sand and finish had learned how before they started turning. Flat-work, boat-building, automotive finishing, etc.

This is consistent with what I've seen in work done by people in our local woodturning club. The ones who's only experience with wood is woodturning struggle mightly with sanding and finishes. The ones with many years of fine woodworking experience produce good finishes as a matter of course.

Great discussion!

Re: Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (long)

#24

Re: One thing stands out in this discussion

Mike Schwing from Md.

>That is a very astute observation Brian. Worthy of some discussion at our next club meeting, I think.

A few months ago I performed a finishing demo for our club, which mostly consists of turners with even less time in turning than I have. I showed them how to quickly sand up a very satisfying finish, and how to eliminate scratches using all of the techniques everyone here has elaborated in this thread - power sanding, lathe speed low, sander high. hand sanding with the grit, wiping down between, etc.. and then how to apply and buff a lacquer based finish quickly (soon to be subject of another printed article, I think). Each month since the turnings at our show and tell have improved their finish quality dramatically. (I am secretly absolutely tickled that I've helped them), and every month someone comes up and tells me about how much more satisfying their turning has become due to that one simple demo. This and your observation about this thread makes me believe that few turners have the backgrounds that allow them to create satisfying finishes without some directed learning.

In fact, it all makes me wonder if simply "sanding" would be a symposium breakout session that folks would consider attending.

Re: Discussion fodder - sanding to high grits (long)

#25

Re: One thing stands out in this discussion

James McClure

>Great topic Mike.

I'm curious about opinions on using buffing systems (such as Beall and others). There hasn't been much said about them in this thread. I am not sure where they rate on the sanding grit scale, but the tripoli, white diamond, menzerna, and other compounds have abrasive qualities. I have had very satisfactory results sanding to 320 grit then buffing with tripoli and white diamond.