Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Sorry Jamie

Posts

Sorry Jamie

#1

Sorry Jamie

Mike Schwing from Md.

>But the blue background simply looked better than gray. With my standard background it was largely impossible to discern the shape of the bowl pictured. Kind of like the contrast, to be honest.

Anyway, this is a tall black cherry bowl, about 12" wide x 10" tall. I made it very egg shaped, but the narrow end of the egg unlike Bill Neddow's fabulous egg shaped bowls which are generally much wider eggs, modeled I figure on the fat side of an egg. I debated putting a lip or decoration on the rim and decided to simply roll it in. Since this will be a display piece I figured a tiny little raised foot would set it off the table nicely. Not an easy form to work with! Just a tiny bit off and the egg illusion disappears totally. Sanded to 4000 with abralon discs and then waxed. All comments welcomed. Please feel free to critique.


img

Re: Sorry Jamie

#2

Re: Sorry Jamie

David Galloway

>Nice Mike. I was was just doing a hollow form in cherry before coming back to the office. I absolutely love cherry although it can but a bit testy. Nice work. I love the simplicity of the piece and the form.

David Galloway

Re: Sorry Jamie

#3

Re: Sorry Jamie

Don Henthorn

>Mike, while I get fun out of looking at your far out stuff, for something that I would have to look at for a time I would surely pick something like this. Great form I like the wood.

Re: Sorry Jamie

#4

Re: Sorry Jamie

JamieDonaldson

>Mike- there is no published law against using a blue or other colored background so long as it properly represents the subject matter and doesn't detract the viewer's attention away from the subject. There are vast differences between photo techniques used for advertising vs. documentation, and my emphasis is toward a literal rendering of a turning, rather than creating a scene to surround and detract from a turning. In other words,KISS should apply here! You're forgiven this time, but only because this bowl is well illuminated and doesn't look to be made of BLUE wood due to light bounce from the surroundings. But don't make a habit of this BLUE stuff!

Re: Sorry Jamie

#5

Re: Sorry Jamie

JamieDonaldson

>And BTW- an outstanding bowl AND photo!

Re: Sorry Jamie

#6

Re: Sorry Jamie

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Mike,

I love blue!! But I like this cherry bowl even better!! The form is wonderful, the graina nd the shape were made for each other, I really enjoy seeing a classic form like this, in it's natural and pure state.

take care,

Jim

Re: Sorry Jamie

#7

Re: Sorry Jamie

Bill Neddow

>Actually, Mike, I do modle my bowls on the small end of the egg, just as you have. It is just a smaller "slice" of the egg, as the bowls tend to be wider. This is a fabulous job. The lines are just right, and you have pushed the "envelope". I had one bowl, not quite as tall as this, at the West Coast Roundup in Vancouver last year and Bill Luce commented that I had probably made it as tall as it was possible to go and still have a nice shape. I thought so too. You have proven us both wrong. Well, out to the shop to push the limits some more. That's what makes it fun. Not only a great shape, but a great piece of wood.

Re: Sorry Jamie

#8

Re: Sorry Jamie

Rick Allen

>Nice bowl Mike. But you already knew that. There is one little thing which bothers me. The pith is off centered. It could be that this was necessary to center the grain. Or it could be that the patern when looking into the bowl is a bit lopsided.

I was wondering about the experince of turning. Was this a bowl that was pleasing to turn. Were you able to get the flowing curves off the tool with bevel rubing making nice curls through out?

Very nice effort. I don't care for the intense blue background. But blue makes a nice accent for cherry. Many folks are fond of filling cracks and such with black epoxy or something. But as you can see from the picture filling a feature in cherry would benifit from an intense blue as a filler.

On a scale of 1 - 10, 1 being a first bowl and 10 being, (do any of us really want to make a perfect bowl?) I see this as a 9.7

Thanks

Richard

Re: Sorry Jamie

#9

Re: Sorry Jamie

Ed Kelle

>Totally cool Mike. Nice shape and I am amazed at how thin you got it. And I thought the big one I did was thin, jeez this makes it look like mine needs weight wachers.

You sure were able to get close to the pith without any cracks. Congrats.

Fantastic work as always. I like the use of the blue background.

Re: Sorry Jamie

#10

Thanks everybody

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Gynia - you caught something that bothers me, too. Honestly, it was a total oversight. I simply forgot to balance out the grain before screwing on the faceplate. Some things can only be gained through experience I don't yet have - automatically checking for things like that.

Was this fun to turn? Sort of. Challenging for sure. Much different that turning a salad bowl, as there are all sorts of pleasing shapes for salad bowls. Far as I can tell, only one pleasing egg shape, that of an egg. This would have been impossible for me to turn even a year ago as I didn't have the soft touch needed to make absolutely fine cuts with a gouge. Instead I would have used the Ellsworth gouge in shear scraping mode, which still produces more tearout than preferred and sanding the piece would have destroyed the demanding profile.

When turning a typical salad bowl, I don't need to concentrate on form, they just sort of flow on their own, but to create a conscious shape, much more attention is required.

Shavings? Cherry is funny stuff. Some creates nice shavings, some dust. Some a little of both. This was one of those that did both. Exterior was dust, interior was thick shavings. It was fun to notice that I could make continuous finishing cuts from rim to bottom on the interior, due to the oneway bowl steady I recently acquired.

Thanks for making me think!

Re: Sorry Jamie

#11

Re: Sorry Jamie

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

>Hi Mike,

Nice work. I particularly like the grain orientation. Very well handled.

Thanks for the pic.

Mike

Not even seen my shop in the last week in Apex, NC...

Re: Sorry Jamie

#12

Brad Vietje

The Contrast Works Well

Brad Vietje

>Hey Folks,

Jamie's comments about photography have helped a lot of turners here elevate their photo results to the sort of photos that only professionals were turning out a few years ago. For this his constant photo coaching deserves our united thanks. However, the topic is still a subjective one, and Jamie's voice (and opinion) are still those of only one fellow, albeit a very well informed one at that.

I think the neutral toned backgrounds will tend to produce the most consistantly pleasing results, and if you were to select just one background color, that would be the best bet. However, for people who have a lot of experience and a real keen sense of getting the lighting and the reflections under control, a background that contrasts in color value, as well as greyscale, can be used effectively.

My personal view is that for many woods, a background slightly on the cool, bluish side of gray, will contrast nicely with the warmer tones of most woods better that a flat, neutral gray. Thus, Jamies admonishment to stay away from this blue background falls a little flat for me -- in this case, it looks nice.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT

Re: Sorry Jamie

#13

Re: Jamie was right!

Bruce McElhaney Spring Lake, MI

>I worked as a professional photographer for many years, and I have to side with Jamie. I think the bright blue background overpowers the bowl. If you see the background Before you see the subject, then the photo is compromised, IMO.

The background is pretty enough, but that's exactly the problem! Unfortunately, the bowl in this photograph is upstaged by the bright background. The background should be secondary to the main subject. In this case a more neutral background would have been a better choice, IMHO. BTW, very nice bowl.

Re: Sorry Jamie

#14

Jamie and Bruce are right!

John Trant (Baltimore/DC corridor)

>I agree with Jamie and Bruce. Red and blue are a bad combination, especially in slides. It may be OK for some when presented on a computer CRT (transmitted light) or when it is not so luminous (the American flag) but it is a problem for most of us when projected (reflected light). Red and blue are complementary colors and the eye has trouble focusing on both so for many of us, slides with lots of "red on blue" tends to appear out of focus and tiring to look at.

Before I get a lot of comments from all the former Art 101 students, I wish to remind you that the color wheel for reflected colors (pigments) is different from the color wheel for transmitted light.

I have been to too many scientific presentations where the slides had bright blue backgrounds with bright red lettering. The slides were absolutely unreadable even though I am sure they looked great on the computer CRT.

John

Re: Sorry Jamie

#15

Re: Jamie was right!

Mike Schwing from Md.

>I agree with you guys about the overpowering blue background. BUT, I first shot about 20 pics with a grey background, the one I use as standard. The problem with it was while the color looks great, it was nearly impossible to discern the profile of the workpiece. In fact, here it is! I simply (and this could be due to my red-green colorblindness or any other factor) could not see the edges of the bowl clearly with this color combination. The pic also looks washed out to me for some reason.


img

Re: Sorry Jamie

#16

True, the bottom 1/3 is obscured by the background

Jay in TX

>

Re: Sorry Jamie

#17

Re: Jamie was right!

JamieDonaldson

>These 2 colors are mid-density, or similar in color contrast in different areas of the spectrum. The wood would display better against a black or white background because of the increase in contrast between subject and background. The ability to selectively modify areas of an image thru hue or saturation controls was not readily available back in the good ol' film/print days. Oh well, they say it's progress!