Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Question....Respirator..About time?

Posts

Question....Respirator..About time?

#1

Question....Respirator..About time?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>As some of you know, I started woodturning 70 years ago. During much of that time I must have breathed enough dust to fill my lungs 50 times. I didn't have any kind of a dust system until the late 70's. Even then, with the systems available, the fine dust still filled the air, and I breathed a lot of it. Still do. I find it amazing that it hasn't bothered me...until now.

I've just returned from a two month trip. No turning and no coughing. Now that I'm back in the shop, the cough has returned. Not serious, but enough to tell me that I'd better do something about it.

I've decided that if i'm to continue turning it has to be with a respirator. I've heard some good things about a Triton. My question is, is there something better? I'd appreciate comments from some of you who use respirators.

Wally

Re: Question....Respirator..About time?

#2

Re: Question....Respirator..About time?

Philip Duffy

>Wally, Can't say "better" but I recently bought an Airmate and my lungs are running pretty normal, for the first time in 15 years. It is comfortable and the weight on the belt (bigger and wider than issued) makes the pump forgetable. The best thing is; "do something now, before we lose your great talent for a very poor reason"!!

Re: Question....Respirator..About time?

#3

Re: Question....Respirator..About time?

RonZ

>I noticed at the Utah Symposium that there was a lot of coughing going on. It took me two years for it to hit and I felt like I smoked several packs of cigarettes the day before but had none of the enjoyment.

I use the Trend model. My brother is an industrial hygenist and was going to get me some 3M device that looks like the Triton but would probably filter out biohazards, too. I told him that the Trend I have would be more effective. He said that he had the numbers to back up his device. I said mine would be more effective because I wouldn't be wearing his. Its hot as heck here and I couldn't see myself wearing anything that covered my head ears and had to wear a belt pack. I'm very pleased with the Trend and also use a room exhaust [no windows] and dust extractor with a 1 micron bag.

Re: Question....Respirator..About time?

#4

Re: Question....Respirator..About time?

George Van in WI

>Hi Wally, I started having sinus problems and then an infection that lasted 3 months,this spring. After that I wear my Airstream. I have had it about three months and will not turn or sand dry bowls without it. If I were to I would have my sinus' plug immediately. With it I can stay till the batteries run out (8+ hours) I had no problem getting used to the weight and when it's a problem my glasses do not fog up. Great face protection as a bonus.

Re: Question....Respirator..About time?

#5

Re: Question....Respirator..About time?

Robert Simmons, Atlanta

>I got a Triton when they first came out and really liked it. It was a graduation from the Racal-type shield/filter that 3M made and a definite improvement. I'd recommend it as good value for the money.

Robert

Re: Question....Respirator..About time?

#6

Re: Question....Respirator..About time?

Ron in Drums PA

>I have a triton and I'm happy with it. But I have to tell you... it's hot wearing that in the summer!

Re: Question....Respirator..About time?

#7

Re: Question....Respirator..About time?

Chris Wright

>Me = long time smoker & woodturner = not a good combination

Picked up the Trend and it works nicely for me.

Whatever you do go with Wally, it will be worth the price paid. Haven't had a woodworking related cough in the two years I've had the Trend. It has space for 2 batteries and when doubled up I can get about 14-16 hours out of it before recharging. On one battery it's 7-10 hours depending on the charge and the temperature.

Re: Question....Respirator..About time?

#8

Re: Question....Respirator..About time?

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Wally,

Knowing a little something about your shop, and since your primary (if not only) source of dust is sanding at the lathe, have you considered a DC with pick up at your lathe? You can buy a decent 1.5hp DC for the cost of a mid-range respirator. The DC will work for all around the shop, the respirator is a one-trick-pony.

Just a thought.

Mark

Re: Question....Respirator..About time?

#9

Re: Question....Respirator..About time? *LINK*

RPE

>Wally,

If you want to fool with batteries, cords and stuff like that, okay. I use a 3M mask. It is full face, with two filters. It has not only P95 (particulate) filtration, but it also filters out vapors. It provides full face protection (it looks like a Scott Airpack, fits over glasses, doesn't fog glasses. The filters bayonet on the sides near your jaw line. It seals well around your face. You can see well out of it. It has nice wide soft rubber head gear.

I have been using lacquer in a closed environment and was unable to smell the fumes.

You can get one for about $130.

You will need four items to complete a purchase. The Mask, 3m6800 $102; Filters 3m-6001 $9.40, Filter holders, 3m-501 $314; P95 filters, 3m-5N11 $12.32.

Just my thoughts.


http://www.jamestowndistributors.com/find;a;1;ID;,Fullface.Respirators,3M.6000.Fullface.Respirators;eclDrill;876

Re: Question....Respirator..About time?

#10

DC

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Mark, I have a DC with a pretty good pick-up at the lathe, and also an overhead air filter. A certain amount of the very fine dust still is airborn. I wear a mask when sanding, but I'm still breathing some dust. I've had my beard for 30 years and that stays, even though some dust gets by it. My DC is hooked up to my bandsaw, but it doesn't get all of the dust.

Wally

Re: Question....Respirator..About time?

#11

Re: Question....Respirator..About time?

nelson brooks

>Wally , regardless which respirator you buy I would still wear something like a DustBeeGone underneath it because when you take it off all that fine dust is still in the air, I have great dust pick up at my lathe and a overhead JDS filter, the problem is the overhead filter fan keeps the air and dust moving around the shop so now I only turn my overhead on when I leave the shop,so when I take my Triton off I still have good protection with the dustbegone.

Re: Question....Respirator..About time?

#12

Re: Question....Respirator..About time?

Robert Savit

>I have used an airmate, with the fan in the belt pack, for several years. It is excellent at what it does, but very pricey. I also have an unremovable beard, which is why I got the airmate instead of one of the negative pressure respirators that would not seal well around my face. I've heard good things about the Triton, but have never worn one. The airmate is fairly comfortable and not particularly hot to wear, and I understand that the Triton can be, so that may be a consideration. The only downside, besides price, is that you cannot wear an over-the-head pair of earmuffs with the hard hat. I would like to get something like the work-tunes headset, but they're not available in a behind-the-neck configuration. There are some ways around this, but they are quite pricey, also. If this is not an issue for you, and if price is not object, then the airmate might be a good choice. One issue to watch out for, if you do get an airmate--the recharger for the battery can be flaky and US distributors charge a lot for them. I was able to replace mine for a much lower cost by contacting the Canadian company that makes them.

Bob Savit

Re: Question....Respirator..About time?

#13

Re: Question....Respirator..About time? *LINK*

George Van in WI

>Robert, 3M makes ear protectors for the Airstream/Airmate.


3m Ear Protector

Re: Question....Respirator..About time?

#14

Re: Question....Respirator..About time?

George Van in WI

>Robert, the ear protectors would only fit the Airmate 5 hardhat.

Re: Question....Respirator..About time?

#15

Thanks Folks.....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Some very good information here. Since I live in hot Arizona, I think that I'll have to look into the respirators that have a cooling system. My shop gets pretty warm during the summer months.

Wally

Re: Question....Respirator..About time?

#16

Resp-O-Rator is a gem *LINK*

Joe Pack

>Hi Wally.

Too little money and a too fat head have kept me away from the powered respirators. A beard that has been part of me for 25 years keeps me away from masks. The solution for me has been a neat little device, invented by a woodworker, has been the Resp-O-Rator that has you breathing through you mouth much like a diver's snorkel. I have been using this gizmo for almost three years, and have been pleased as punch with it. Lightweight, easy to use, and 1 micron filters, plus a very affordable price, make it easy to recommend. 4 hours of turning/sanding padauk leaves me with a dusty, red face, but I don't inhale a bit of it (you can taste it if you breathe it in). The only part of the gizmo I don't use is the nose plug; I just learned to breathe only through my mouth - took all of 15 seconds to learn to do, plus a couple of inhalations at inopportune times to burn the lesson deeply.

You can see it at Hartville Tool (link below, takes you to a picture also), or at Woodcraft or many other locations. It looks goofy, but the gizmo really does work.


http://www.hartvilletool.com/product/10834

Re: Question....Respirator..About time?

#17

Re: Question....Respirator..About time?

Robert Savit

>Right. The problem isn't the hear protectors, it's trying to get ones with a built in radio.

Bob Savit