Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Pin Oak odor?

Posts

Pin Oak odor?

#1

Pin Oak odor?

Arn

>I recently aquired some green Pin Oak logs from a friend. I know oak is not the best turning wood, but I went for it anyway. I cut them into bowl blanks, coated with Anchorseal and then turned a couple right away. The next weekend I lifted the lid on my shavings barrel and got a most putrid odor that caused me to remove those shavings real quick. I then pulled out some pin oak blanks and they have the same odor, which made it darn hard to get through the turning!

So, Question is: Is this the pin oak or is it mildew or other causing the odor? The blanks are lying on my basement concrete right now, so I suppose they may be getting a fair amount of moisture, but I'm in no hurry for these to dry. Note, I also turned some sycamore that was lying next to the pin oak and it had a similar odor, but not as strong. I suspect the pin oak smell permeated the sycamore.

Re: Pin Oak odor?

#2

Re: Pin Oak odor?

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>Some oak has a bad odor. People think it smells like old urine. There is a nickname for it. "Piss Oak " I don't think the name is limited to Pin Oak. I've been a carpenter for over 30 years. We put up some Oak Paneling once that smelled so bad we had to tear it out and replace it. That was standard 1/4 plywood paneling with Oak veneer on the front pre-finished and fully dry. I guess the smell can be pretty potent. I burn a lot of Oak in my wood stove. It smells pretty bad when it's green, but usually is all right when it is dry.

Re: Pin Oak odor?

#3

Re: Pin Oak odor?

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Has to be a very special piece of oak for me to deal with the odor. PISS OAK is what we call it around here. I can't stand the stuff. Sometimes it smells like urine, sometimes vomit.

Re: Pin Oak odor?

#4

Re: Pin Oak odor?

Dennis Taylor

>the pin oak is very nasty to smell, I had some pieces stored and thought a animal urinated on it, but it just smells, sometimes I don't think it smells so bad, the next piece is terrible and won't finish it...Dennis