Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Bowl Sanding-Finishing Question

Posts

Bowl Sanding-Finishing Question

#1

Bowl Sanding-Finishing Question

George Van in WI

>I am just starting to finish some bowls, this is the first time I have seriously worked at a finish as I have only completed a couple of bowls and was less than satisfied with the results of my finishing.

In a lot of the demos and instructions, bowls are sanded and finished on the lathe, clamped in the jaws of a chuck. Some of the finishes are rather extensive and take days or weeks. After the finish is complete the bowl is taken from the chuck and mentions is made that only the bottom is left to turn and finish.

Does this mean that with that finishing system that the bowl is reversed; bottom finish turned, sanded, and then finished to the same standard as the rest of the bowl, or is the finish considered less important on the bottom? Or is this for demonstration purposes only? It seem to me that one would be better totally finishing and sanding the entire bowl and then completely apply the finish and cut the finishing time considerably without having to repair any damage in the bottom of the bowl where the foot or base meet from additional turning or sanding.

Re: Bowl Sanding-Finishing Question

#2

Re: Bowl Sanding-Finishing Question

Barry Turner

>Don't make finishing too hard. It's really not. Far too many people make finishing way too complicated. The more steps, the better your chances of screwing up. The secret to good finishing is in the preparation........thorough sanding. Sand through the grits to at least 320 grit. 400 or 600 is better. Make sure your have removed all tool marks and sanding scratches from previous grits. Be careful not to obliterate details with over zealous sanding. Minwax Polyurethane, satin. Brush on a heavy coat, let it soak in for a few minutes (10 or so) keeping dry spots wet. Wipe it off with an old T-shirt. Let dry overnight. Now, wasn't that easy? You can sand lightly with 400 grit or 4/0 steel wool and apply additional coats if you wish, but they really aren't necessary. You can use this same procedure with Waterlox, oil varnish and other finishes. Just play around and pick what you like best.

Re: Bowl Sanding-Finishing Question

#3

Re: Bowl Sanding-Finishing Question

George Van in WI

>Thanks Barry, hope to keep it simple as possible. I have sanded to 600, I will buff between coats.

Re: Bowl Sanding-Finishing Question

#4

Re: Bowl Sanding-Finishing Question

Barry Irby

>Many people like finishing on the lathe because it seems easier than finishing by hand without the lathe holding it and spinning it for you. You have noticed the short coming in the process. Every solution has it's problems. Every weapon generates a counter weapon. Every dog has his....wait, I digress.

I have done what you mention above, and I may still do it on really large bowls. Think about it. If you assume a bowl is approximately some section of a sphere, you could calculate the surface area and then double it to account for inside and out. I think I did this on a fifteen inch bowl and it came out to be about five square feet. I am not redoing the calculation now, but it came out to be a huge area compared to the chuck foot. So, what seems silly on a six inch bowl makes more sense as the bowl grows.

What this has done is generate other solutions. This is where vacuum chucks really shine. Put the first coat of finish on the inside of the bowl and lap it around the rim and partially up the outside, take the bowl out of the mechanical chuck and reverse it onto the vacuum chuck, cut away the chuck foot and complete the bottom and finish it. With a vacuum chuck you can literally sort of casually stick the bowl on the chuck, semi align it, run the lathe slow, and sand, or finish, or rub out the finish while the bowl wobbles around. Of course, you can line it up as carefully as you like and eliminate much of the wobble. The point it that with a vacuum chuck you can quickly re-mount the bowl over and over to perfect the finish and the chuck should not scar of leave any marks on the work.

There are many other ways of doing this also. Jamb chucks come to mind. Turn a blank that fits inside your bowl and put some padding on it and slip your bowl over it and bring the tail stock up to hold it. Then there are donut chucks and Cole jaws, and tape and shrink wrap and on and on. Someone (Was that you John Lucas?) posted about eight pictures about a month ago of various ways of doing this. Of course, I remember turning my first bowl and thinking, "you mean I have to BUY another piece of wood and MAKE a jamb chuck? Who can afford all this crap?" Many of us have dozens of such contraptions now.

Welcome to turning, he who has the most toys wins.

Re: Bowl Sanding-Finishing Question

#5

Re: Bowl Sanding-Finishing Question

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Hi, George, the bowl's bottom should be as nice as the rest, that's where your signature goes. Everyone looks at the bottom.

I may finish the inside completely before reversing to turn the outside, but I don't do any finish turning on the outside until it's reversed on either a jam chuck or vacuum chuck. The outside is turned close to final shape and size, but I save the finish cuts for when it's reverse mounted otherwise you have to blend in the new cuts with the previous cuts, often hard to do if the bowl has warped at all.

Hopefully you have center marks on the bottom of your roughed bowls, so you can line them up centered on the jam or vacuum chuck when finishing the outside and bottom.

To finish turn the outside, I pull the gouge backwards from center, cutting with just the side wing. If you do have to blend in new cuts with a previously cut surface that has warped, turn the lathe speed way down so the gouge follows the out-of-roundness and take fine shearing cuts. David Ellsworth showed our club that trick.

Have fun with all your rough-outs, and good luck.

Re: Bowl Sanding-Finishing Question

#6

addendum

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>George, my point being, and to specifically answer your question (or at least say how I do it), is that finish turning and finishing the outside is a completely seperate step from the inside--I don't try to finish any of the outside while the bowl is mounted for hollowing.

Re: Bowl Sanding-Finishing Question

#7

Re: Bowl Sanding-Finishing Question

George Van in WI

>Thanks Barry, guess I will have to take the time to hook up up the vacuum chuck, just got the E-Z adapter from Packard Friday. I have finish turned and sanded the bowls I have completed to this point on the Oneway jumbo jaws. None are larger than 13”. I understand your point on the larger bowls.

Re: Bowl Sanding-Finishing Question

#8

Re: addendum

George Van in WI

>Thanks Ken. I used the Oneway jumbo jaws for reversing and now see the problem with buttons as they stop me from taking the gouge all the way to the top on the last pass from the foot, forcing me to turn and sand the upper outside and then blend the bottom later. After this when not using the vacuum I think I will try between centers (I did leave a center mark) as I can do the whole outer profile and only have to remove a small tenon when complete. I like your tip from David Ellsworth, I will use it often, should work good with the forged gouge a friend taught me to use.

Re: Bowl Sanding-Finishing Question

#9

Re: My reason for the "Unfinished"

Russ Fairfield

>I sand and polish the wood on the bottom of a bowl, but leave it as either bare wood or nothing more than a coat of wax. The reason for doing this is that I will never have to worry about the finish on the bowl damaging the surface that it sits on.

Remember what everyone says about finishes being "safe" after all of the solvents have evaporated, and that it taking several weeks to months for that to happen? You thought they were talking about being safe for food.

If the bowl hasn't been given sufficient time for all of the solvents to gas off, an uncured finish will be in contact with the top of whatever it is sitting on; or they can be trapped within the shallow recess in the bottom of the bowl. Guess what happens when that bowl with the not yet fully cured finish is set on an antique table with either a shellac or lacquer finish? A large cloudy spot the same diameter as the bottom of the bowl will develop. It only took refinishing ONE table top to make a believer out of me. Fortunately, it was my own table.

Re: Bowl Sanding-Finishing Question

#10

Re: Bowl Sanding-Finishing Question

Sean Troy

>Hey George, no matter how I remove and finish turning the bottom, I still wait and finish the whole bowl at the same time. It just seems to work better for me that way. Have you seen that big Bear around lately? Sean

Re: Bowl Sanding-Finishing Question

#11

Re: My reason for the "Unfinished"

George Van in WI

>Thanks Russ, good point, I will take your advice and be cautious.

Re: Bowl Sanding-Finishing Question

#12

Re: Bowl Sanding-Finishing Question

George Van in WI

>Hi Sean, I saw the vase on your web site, nice job. The bear is around and safe at this time. He is trap smart, must have been transported here from another trouble spot. The DNR finally pulled the barrel trap as he would walk around it. If he tries to break into the neighbor’s house again that may be his last visit.

Re: Bowl Sanding-Finishing Question

#13

Amazing

Bill Howatt

>Nope, not the fact that it can damage a table but that I had never heard of that before and I have been reading various forums for some time. Everytime I think I know everything this happens!

Thanks for the warning, Russ.

Bill

Re: Bowl Sanding-Finishing Question

#14

Re: Bowl Sanding-Finishing Question

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I seal the bowls while they are on the lathe as part of the sanding operation. I've been using shellac (1 lb cut, de-waxed blonde). One of the nice things about shellac is the low odor level. Slop it on and wipe it off. Really highlights problem grain and sanding scratches from previous grits. I normally apply it at the 180 or 220 grit stage. If I have to do a lot of remedial sanding, I'll apply another coat. Then continue sanding to 400.

I apply the final finish off the lathe. I like wipe-on oil or varnish finishes, and it's more convenient for me to finish the bowls in batches. It also makes the can of finish last longer because I'm not constantly opening it.

Re: Bowl Sanding-Finishing Question

#15

Re: Bowl Sanding-Finishing Question

Don Henthorn

>Of course I always do everything bassackwards and the hardest way. I finish the inside and most of the outside while the piece is still on the lathe. Then I part it off and put it in a doughnut chuck and turn the bottom and then finish the bottom blending the sides as I work. Seems to do ok for me.

Re: Bowl Sanding-Finishing Question

#16

Re: Bowl Sanding-Finishing Question

George Van in WI

>Just got in the house, thanks everyone for the replies. I have finish on some bowls, I too sealed some with shellac to hopefully level out the penetration in some of the spalted ones. This week I will get the vacuum chuck made and have the system in operation. I am sure I will find it useful.