Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Any DIY bowl coring tools out there?

Posts

Any DIY bowl coring tools out there?

#1

Steven Antonucci

Any DIY bowl coring tools out there?

steve antonucci

>So I can set the record straight, I am not cheap. I just don't like to pay more than something is worth...

When I look at coring systems, it seems to me that they are very expensive for a bent piece of metal. Without starting WW III, it seems to me that they are not much more than a bent metal knife which can be inserted along a curved path.

So, have any of you made a run at it?

I spent WAY too long removing a core from a few cherry bowls this week with a parting tool, and a series of bent metal rods. In the end, I freed them from the tenon with curved wedges and a big hammer, but I'm thinking that there needs to be a middle ground. Assuming that a system might take 5 minutes to core (a WAG, since I've never used one) and my current method required about an hour, has anyone taken a shot at a homemade coring tool?

Steve

P.S. please don't ask for pictures of my current set up, as I would not recommend it to anyone else- just too much work!

Re: Any DIY bowl coring tools out there?

#2

Re: Any DIY bowl coring tools out there?

Barry Irby

>Steve, I made one. Basically a bent piece of steel I sharpened. I used a piece of pipe with set screws in it for a handle. Similar to the McNaughton ones, but crude by comparison. My pipe was about three feet long, just because that was what was laying around. I did not have a "gate" or fancy tool rest. I put about an four inch radius (8" bowl) on the steel and actually split the cutting tip into a Y shaped fork and sharpened it. Held on for dear life and cored bowls. It was a wild and crazy ride, but it worked better than you might think. I sometimes wonder how I have lived this long, its dangerous being cheap.

I have since bought the McNaughton system. The gate is a major improvement over my free hand approach, and they have modified the gate since I bought mine. I have sent my blades back to see if they are bent correctly. I don't think they are. We had a discussion about this about a month ago here. The knives would have to track on the circumference or perimeter of a circle to be able to cut correctly and mine do not.

Before I bought mine, I looked at the one Oneway makes and decided i could not afford it. I would like to try it out and see how it compares, but I have not. The McNaughton system works well if you get past the learning curve. One of my knives was shaped better than the others and I could reach in the drawer for the post, slap the blade in the handle and core a bowl about nine inches in diameter out of a twelve inch bowl in about five minutes and put it away. I spend more time "aiming" it than I do coring, but that's another topic we have discussed here.

I had a design of my own that I thought was better than the McNaughton or Oneway, and actually talked to a local machinist about making it for me, but did not do it. I might revisit that. I am wondering now what I did with the plans. My idea was to use the existing tool rest and let the tail stock actually hold the tool. Have a pivoting cutter on a plate that has a taper that engages the Morse taper in the tailstock. I think someone makes something similar, but mine was different.

Incidentally, I tried coring burl and also end grain pieces. I have a fear of cutting the core right out and having it go spinning around the shop at about a thousand RP M's. So I sort of sneak up on the last cuts and stop and try to break the core out. If you are turning "side grain" you can snap off the tenon or shaft when it is an 1 1/2 or maybe 2". With burl or end grain, sometimes they won't break out so easily. I have had the experience of ripping the b=plug out of the bottom of the bowl you are trying to core. So, I made a curved chisel. A bent piece of steel that matches the curve of the cutter. When I chicken out, I slide it around through the and use a hammer while I rotate the blank and chisel my way through the last of it. I usually take the blank out of the chuck and set it on the floor for this pounding. The beating usually drive the blank out of the chuck anyway. I mark the orientation so I can put it back exactly as it came out.