Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

You Want Fries With That?

Posts

You Want Fries With That?

#1

You Want Fries With That?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I posdted this on AAW, and I'll be just as interested to see the comments here.

Just amazes me that folks just can't seem to let a little piece of wood dry out naturally. "Nope. I turned this Bad Boy dead wet this morning and I'll have the final coat of finish on him and ready for, um, ah, well whatever, this evening!" Jeez, guys, how much, between hot plates, microwaves, kiln heaters, and a plethora of chemicals, do you all have to spend producing that piece?

LDD, freeze-dried, nuked, boiled, baked, deep-fried, what is so Gawd-awful vital that mandates not letting the poor bowl dry at its own natural pace? Is there some Rule somewhere that I missed that says any particular piece must be finished within some number of hours after the damn tree hits the ground?

No, this ain't rhetorical. I truly don't see what all the rush is about, but I do see a whole lot of effort being put into shortcutting a process that's gonna happen in a month or two anyway.

Life may be short, but not that short.

Mark

Re: You Want Fries With That?

#2

Re: You Want Fries With That?

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Mark, I understand at least what part of that "hurry up and dry" crowd is all about. Part of the crowd is new turners that haven't been involved for more than a short spell in turning green wood. I used to want my roughs dry as soon as possible, too, mainly because I didn't have anything lying around to finish turn. However, simply roughing out 3 or 4 blanks each month within a year leads to having 3 or 4 pieces dry enough to finish turn every month. Takes a while to get there, and the in between is interminable if you have no access to dry blanks that you can turn once to finish.

These days I have an inventory of a hundred or more blanks, probably 50 are ready to finish, probably half of them I'll never get to finish because of other things or my style has changed or they were turned with wood I no longer desire to work with. My inventory is miniscule compared with a lot of folks'.

But the other crowd, while I don't understand what the rush is, I do understand the desire to come up with new solutions to an old problem. Some pretty nifty drying methods have shown up through guys experimenting with different things.

Re: You Want Fries With That?

#3

Re: You Want Fries With That?

Bill Crommett

>There are a couple of other considerations that do not apply to all of you young guys> One is how much grief are you going to leave for the widow to dispose of when that "great event" occurs ? The other consideration is that there is a limit to how much space some of us can allow for drying sacks (I use brown grocery bags). Another one is : "What was this one supposed to be ?"

Re: You Want Fries With That?

#4

Steven Antonucci

I'm an alcoholic...

steve antonucci

>It just seems to me that the alcohol process not only dries faster, but also stabilizes the wood. Believe me, I don't care about losing a bowl or hollow form to a tool mistake, but to have a great form tear itself apart kills me.

I had a three way crotch from a 200+ year old white oak tree that I roughed into a hollow form. It was about 10"x10", and if you've ever turned white oak wet, it's a ton of fun (aside from the tannin stains). However, even after the soaking, I could not prevent this thing from tearing 3- 6"x 1/2" cracks along the flame grain.

Wasn't about the speed, it was about trying to ensure a more stable finished project. My experience is that most of the stuff I soak is better off because I soaked it.

Now if it means that I end up with bowl blanks ready in two weeks, who am I to say no?

steve

Wishing my alcohol bucket was big enough to hold the three 16" cherry roughouts I did this week...

Re: You Want Fries With That?

#5

Re: You Want Fries With That?

John Lucas

>Mark Not only the rush but the expense and time of boiling and alcohol and the smell in the microwave. I think I agree with Mike. If you rough out just 2 bowls a month you'll have plenty to work on by next year.

I can see the rush to a point because sometimes I get a great piece of wood and just want to make something of it. If that's the case I just make a thin wall vessel or thin wall bowl and put it up to dry. it will dry quite nicely in 2 or 3 days.

Boxes on the other hand need dry wood so when I don't feel like roughing bowls I cut the wood up into 3x3 or 4x4 or even 1x1" strips, seal the ends and put it up to dry. After doing this for a couple of years I'm starting to get a fair collection of dry wood in larger sizes.

Re: You Want Fries With That?

#6

Re: I'm an alcoholic...

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I have a large white oak that blew down last winter and it has dozens of turnable crotches. And I also know that left to dry naturally they will tear apart, even if they are green turned to final thickness. So I'm going to boil the daylights out of them and then soak them in alcohol. Not for speed but in an effort to keep them out of the fireplace. (Got plenty of mundane wood for the fireplace.)

Re: You Want Fries With That?

#7

Re: You Want Fries With That?

Earl Eyre

>And then there are some of us who simply have a different style of working and the new ways of speeding up drying allows us to do so. I am retired, this is totally a hobby and I enjoy taking my time on a piece. Rather than turning out a whole bunch of pieces fast, I will work on one turning for anywhere from one day to a week or two, designing to embellishing. I truly enjoy the "creating" and having to rough turn a piece and set it aside for a year would totally stop that process. Using quick drying methods allows me to rough turn, zap in the microwave or soak, finish turn, zap again, and continue working. I can put all my creative juices into that one piece. It's not that I'm any great turner turning out masterpieces, it just that I like to work on a project until it's done and then enjoyment is in taking my time to do it.

Earl

Re: You Want Fries With That?

#8

Re: You Want Fries With That?

George Van in WI

>Mark, I am new to turning a finished product. I say this because I used the last year+ for turning roughed blanks. I had a lot of wood available and no experience with all the tools, grinding, and the PM 3520. I chose to learn while roughing. I practiced with all the tools and made a lot of mistakes on the roughed pieces (design opportunities). I have a lot of fun roughing; looking for the surprises under the bark. Using Anchorseal I had minimal losses from splitting. I now have 500+ dried and drying bowls and I am now starting to finish turn some. I did finish a couple for salad bowls and dried one plate in alcohol. I agree with Mike that some of them I will not be used as my tastes and direction have changed. I can take those to the group along with the green bowl blanks for the raffle and let someone else practice.

I am fortunate to have a lot of trees and a lot of storage space and now I don’t have to worry about dry blanks, although I do still enjoy roughing a few now and then.

I am learning that finish turning the blanks, sanding, and finishing is a new learning experience. Now if, when, OK yesterday when I had a catch and tore a bowl from the jumbo jaws on the last pass where the foot meets the bowl my mistakes are more disturbing!

Re: You Want Fries With That?

#9

Re: You Want Fries With That?

Jim King

>Mark: I am a firm believer in boiling the rough blanks as it gives me a more stable product and a better finish. It seems that boiling takes out all the natural resins and lets the wood dry more easily without stress and definitly a lot faster. As we are located hundreds of miles from the nearest road going anywhere (the biggest land locked city in the world they say) all our turnings leave here by air. As you know an airplane is a vicious dry kiln and a few hours in the lack of humidity in belly of a plane will crack any work that is not perfectly dry. With 90% humidity here everyday we need all the help we can get to get things dry and boiling has been a tremendous help to us. As we make a living doing this the speed at which we can dry and produce high quality products is quite important. In addition many of the more delicate woods and cuts such as crotches dont crack when boiled and as a result we have turnings with beautiful figure that we probably would have lost by simple drying. The speed of drying is nice but also I feel the stability and quality of the product is made better and the extra steps are worth it to us.

Re: You Want Fries With That?

#10

Re: You Want Fries With That?

Ed Karch

>What! Mark you want me to finish that crap I rough turned six months ago before I was a world class turner?? Hand me the alki My client wants it in two weeks.

Ed

Re: You Want Fries With That?

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: You Want Fries With That?

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Mark, that's only the tip of the iceburg...you forgot the texturing, burning, carving, piercing, and whatever else. Speed is not of the essence, whether in time from green to dry, or from learning to turn to creating art.

My question? Is this the BEST you are capable of? or the fastest? No offence intended...of course.

Re: You Want Fries With That?

#12

Re: You Want Fries With That?

Jim King

>You need fast and effective.

Re: You Want Fries With That?

#13

Re: With That?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Ed,

I've got roughs way older than that. Fortunately I left enough on them to now be able to make something other than hockey pucks and mulch.

Re: You Want Fries With That?

#14

Re: With That?

Ed Karch

>Mark

It is not that they aren't finishable, The form and design is so bad I would be ashamed to let them out the door.

Six months ago I had been turning for eight months and the stuff was horrable.

Ed

Re: You Want Fries With That?

#15

Ah, Thoses

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>The very valuable ones! The ones that show you what you've learned and where you are along the road to knowing something about what you do. I have several of those, one of which is nailed to a beam in the shop to remind me.

Of course, if the NFL runs short and calls with the right price . . .

|;-}}}

Re: You Want Fries With That?

#16

Re: You Want Fries With That?

RonZ

>I agree, start off slow doing it right and you'll pick up speed.