Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Hollowing Tools - which one(s)

Posts

Hollowing Tools - which one(s)

#1

Hollowing Tools - which one(s)

Ryan McMullen - Memphis

>I am interested in doing some christmas ornaments and I am in need of some hollowing tools. I am just curious as to which one(s) to get. I have a midi lathe, so I will not be doing any hollowing much larger than the ornaments.

Thanks for any input.

Ryan

Re: Hollowing Tools - which one(s)

#2

Re: Hollowing Tools - which one(s) *LINK*

Sean Troy

>Robert rosand has tools that are great for hollowing small items.


http://www.rrosand.com/index.html

Re: Hollowing Tools - which one(s)

#3

Re: Hollowing Tools - which one(s)

John Lucas

>I will agree. I've been making my own for years and have settled on the Bob rosand style hollowing tools with the HSS cutter. They work great and $20 is a good price.

Re: Hollowing Tools - which one(s)

#4

Brian McKearney

Re: Hollowing Tools - which one(s)

Brian McKearney

>I purchased a set of three Hamlet hollowing tools last Fall from Jacques Coulombe in Canada (similar to the Sorby set offered by Woodcraft). See http://www.jacquescoulombe.com and look for the "Square Hollowing Tools" in the Hamlet catalog (HCT133-135). It's a very nice set and seems to work well, although quite a bit more expensive as compared to making your own. I tried making my own and they worked OK, but I wanted better steel and the Hamlet set fit the bill for me. Packard Woodworks also sells a similar set in their house brand for a little less money than the Hamlet set.

Brian

Re: Hollowing Tools - which one(s)

#5

Re: Hollowing Tools - which one(s)

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I just use an allen wrench with most of the arm cut off and sharpened. I hold it with a drill chuck mounded on the end of a handle. (The drill chuck is from an egg-beater style hand drill that I got when I was about 7 years old.)

Re: Hollowing Tools - which one(s)

#6

Steven Antonucci

Make them-

steve antonucci

>You can buy a 3' section of O1 from Enco for almost nothing. If you want, you can get shorter sections so you don't need to cut it, but it's short work with a hacksaw or dremel with a cutoff.

I shaped it on a belt sander, handle is turned from beefwood (had it laying around). Whole tool was <$5, and I have enough steel to make 10 more tools...

If I need a swan neck tool, I bend it in my bench vise. It requires enough strength to make the tool strong enough for hollowing, but not enough to require a torch to heat it first.

I've made a dozen or more bars of various sizes, and now I acutally care about good looks as well as performance...

Steve


img

Re: Hollowing Tools - which one(s)

#7

Steve, Neat ferrule.

Clem Wixted

>What is it made from?

Clem

Re: Hollowing Tools - which one(s)

#8

Steven Antonucci

Plumbing "part"

steve antonucci

>not sure what it's called, but it was in the plumbing aisle. It is 1/2" and threaded on the hex end, and 1/2" ID pipe on the round side. I turned the "stem" on the handle to 1/2", then chased the threads with a crescent wrench and the fitting. The wood is hard, but the copper is harder, and cut it just like a tap and die would.

Might be what John Lucas mentioned the other day. I think he actually turns down the hex part. I left it, in case I need to remove the handle some day.

Steve

Re: Hollowing Tools - which one(s)

#9

Re: Plumbing "parts" *PICS*

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>I use compression nuts, like John. I usually just file down the tool end, and leave the handle end flat.



Curly Walnut

Here's one I turned all the way to round, but left the handle flat. Hexagonal ferrule didn't look right with an octagonal handle. Well, really I turned the handle, and then reflattened it later. The screwdriver head was a joke. This one ended up a burnisher, with very hard carbide tool, like the one above.



Curly Walnut

Here's another, using a smaller compression nut.



Olive

Here are construction details and dimensions:


Here are three more. The top one was made from a threaded insert. I inserted it half way, and filed the threads off the other end. The second was made from a compression nut, and the third was made from a brass pipe nipple.



Curly Walnut, Manzanita, Cocobolo

Re: Hollowing Tools - which one(s)

#10

Re: Plumbing "parts" *PICS*

Carol Reed, the Router Lady, Dubuque

>What cool graphics! What software are you using for that?

Re: Hollowing Tools - which one(s)

#11

Al Basham Tools *LINK*

David Propst

>I have a few hollowing tools to choose from, including the Kelton system, but the ones I consistently return to are the outrigger articulated tools like the one pictured below. These are made by and can be purchased from Al Basham in NC. You can read a review and instructions on how to use them about them at this link on the Kestrel Creek website.

With a sharp edge and a light touch, these tools are very stable and easy to use.

Best Regards,

David


img

Al Basham Tools

Re: Hollowing Tools - which one(s)

#12

Re: Plumbing "parts" *PICS*

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>Canvas 7.0, from ACD Systems. This is an older version, but the latest version, Canvas X, would have a bit of trouble running on my very old iMac. I use it for all my photo editing as well and have edited newsletters with it, too. As you can see, it easily mixes text, graphics and pictures. There's not much the program won't do for the graphics artist. It runs on PCs, too.

Canvas X

Re: Hollowing Tools - which one(s)

#13

calling William Duffield re: Canvas software

Carol Reed, the Router Lady, Dubuque

>Would you email me directly? I have a few questions. In fact, if you have the time and are willing, I'd love to call you with my questions.

Re: Hollowing Tools - which one(s)

#14

Steve, Do You Then Heat Treat

Tom Colligan, Peoria

>. . . the tool or can you use it as is? Thanks, Tom.

Re: Hollowing Tools - which one(s)

#15

Steven Antonucci

Nope.

steve antonucci

>If I am making them with a piece of cold rolled with a "cutting bit" insert, I will either CA glue or set screw the bit in. If I'm using good steel for cutting bits, there is no need to harden. Bits are available, or can be made easily from O1, or HSS (better). As I have recently pointed out, carbide is out because you can't work with it easily.

In some of the smaller tools, some steel can be bent, but isn't very strong (which is why it can be bent...) While it takes an edge, it will be frequently sharpened. The good news is, that I'm using them for small forms, so there isn't a lot of wood to be removed. By having just "bent rod" tools, the openings for the forms I make can be smaller. The catch is to use the right steel...

I found out the hard way that HSS will not be cold set (the tool in the picture is 3" shorter now), which means I can't just bend it in a vise. I have bent O1 easily, but I've also noticed it bends under turning stresses, so my tools shape is somewhat dynamic. If I heat treated the rods, they may deform less, but I would run the risk of shattering on a bad catch. If they get to bent, I just rebend them in the vise.

Steve

Re: Hollowing Tools - which one(s)

#16

Re: Steve, Do You Then Heat Treat

John Lucas

>Tom I make 2 types of mini hollowing tools. one is a straight piece of cold roll steel with a HSS cutter silver soldered to the tip at a 50-55 degree angle. I make the same thing from just drill rod. I heat it red hot and bend it to the 55 degree angle. Then I reheat it red hot to where it is non-magnetic then quench it. I use 01 steel so I can quench in water. Then I toss the steel in the oven and let it heat to 475 degrees for 1/2 hour per 1/4" of thickness. This takes the brittleness out.

I use a straight tool made from Drill rod to do 90 percent of the hollowing of ornaments and use the bent rod to clean up the inside corners.

For larger hollowing tools I still use the same 1/4" HSS cutters but I use 1/2" or 3/4" cold roll for the rods.

Re: Hollowing Tools - which one(s)

#17

Re: Steve, Do You Then Heat Treat

Spence in Rhode Island

>John, do you let the piece cool off in the oven or remove it after the right amount of time has passed?

In a tool making frenzie here. So far have made a 4 piece cove tool set, a 3 point tool, 1/4" round skew and a 3/8" square scraper for boxes and such.All in HSS. Next on the hit list is a couple of sets of small hollowers with HSS tool bits silver soldered on cold rolled shafts. Was thinking of making some with o1 drill rod just to see the difference. Definately not enough hours in the day for me. LOL

Thanks

Spence

Re: Hollowing Tools - which one(s)

#18

Re: Steve, Do You Then Heat Treat

John Lucas

>Spence Ain't makin' tools fun. It doesn't matter that you can buy better tools, it's just plain fun. I just let the tool cool naturally when I remove it from the oven. When tempering with a torch you need to quench it because some parts of tool are hotter than you want and if you don't quench it the color can keep on running up the tool. With the oven the whole tool is 475 and no hotter so quenching isn't necessary.

For some tools it's better to use the torch and heat the tool an inch or so behind the tip and watch the color progress to the tip until you get a light straw color, then quench. What this does is leaves the tool from that 1" point back to the handle a lot softer so it is less likely to break. I haven't found any difference in actual use in the ones tempered this way or the ones tempered in the oven.

I'm still iffy on the HSS tool for hollowing small things. The drill rod tools are so easy to sharpen and don't dull all that fast. Then the tip of the bent one gets too short I simply heat it, straighten it, bend it and retemper. Takes less time than removing the old tip, cleaning the metal and soldering on a new tip. They do look cool however and the tip does last a long time. With larger tools I drill a hole to accept the HSS and just CA glue, or set screw it in place so replacing these is really easy.

Re: Hollowing Tools - which one(s)

#19

Re: O1 quenched in water?

Al Crandall--NE of Indy--

>John, O1 is an oil hardening steel and should be quenched in oil. It will usually have red paint on it somewhere from the supplier. I quench O1 in olive oil because of its high flash point. If you are using water to quench, you should be using water hardening drill rod which is W1. It will have yellow paint on it.

Re: Hollowing Tools - which one(s)

#20

Re: O1 quenched in water?

John Lucas

>Your right AL. I was typing this while talking on the phone this morning. Someone with no more brains than me should not try multitasking. W1 is water hardening and your right my stock does have yellow ends.

Re: Hollowing Tools - which one(s)

#21

Re: O1 quenched in water?

John Lucas

>I also forgot to mention that when I do heat treat an unknown metal or 01 I use Peanut oil. I've heard it has a higher flash point but don't know that for fact. It has worked well and is much easier to dispose of. Not on your salad of course, unless you need the extra metal in your diet.