Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Push cut vs Pull cut

Posts

Push cut vs Pull cut

#1

Push cut vs Pull cut

tdaniel

>What is the difference? Only where you stand. In either of these cuts the gouge's position in relation to the wood is identical. If you like to have shavings in your face use the pull cut; if you don't like the flavor of the shavings leave the gouge in the exact same position and step around the gouge (put it on the left side of your body instead of the right). This throws the chips away from you but the cut remains the same. Arguments expected>:)

TD

Re: Push cut vs Pull cut

#2

Re: Push cut vs Pull cut

AnthonyY

>Makes sense to me!

Re: Push cut vs Pull cut

#3

Re: Push cut vs Pull cut

Mike Schwing from Md.

>What you say makes sense. I tend to have a more positive, firm bevel rub when using a push cut (which I employ often) than when using a pull cut and I tend to use the push cut usually with the gouge horizontal and the flutes pointing where I want the gouge to go. I mostly use a pull cut with the gouge handle way down and approaching the cutting surface at about 45 degrees of rake (right term?). Simply the technique I've developed comfort with, no real reason, but I do notice a more postive bevel rub with my push cuts, and therefore a very clean cut surface. Still, its hard to beat that handle down, 45 degree cutting angle face for cut quality. I do believe you first detailed that in a way that opened up a whole world of new tool use for me. Thanks.

Re: Push cut vs Pull cut

#4

Re: Push cut vs Pull cut

Bob Clancy from NM

>Hmmmmm.... assuming you're talking about using a gouge like on the outside of a bowl, what I would call a push cut is a nice bevel-rubbing cut with the 'axis' of the gouge pointing in the direction of the cut, cutting near the gouge tip. I'd call a pull cut a more aggressive cut with the gouge pointing the other way, cutting on the left wing of the gouge. Works well on green wood but is pretty aggressive for drier wood.

Am i getting tangled up in the terminology?

Re: Push cut vs Pull cut

#5

Re: Push cut vs Pull cut

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>No argument at all TD! Your definitons are very accurate. I use them both, but I prefer a pull cut most of the time. With an apron and a face shield, the shavings are not a problem, and I think it gives me more control over the gouge - sort of like front wheel drive on a car and all that.

Bill

Re: Push cut vs Pull cut

#6

Re: Push cut vs Pull cut

John Lucas

>Terry I depends a lot on what you are cutting. For platters if I'm cutting toward the center the shavings are pushed away from me. On my hand mirrors when I can use the push cut the shavings go away. If I use a pull cut on the other hand the shavings tend collect in my lap and if Im doing square mirrors the fan like motion blows them up into my face.

Before I had the powermatic with moveable head I would stand on the backside of the lathe and use a push cut. This was gave me great control of the shape but required that I walk back and forth around the lathe to finish certain cuts. With the Powermatic I slide the head to the end and I can use a push cut from center out or center in and depending on how you orient the flute the shavings will go away from you.

That's part of why I'm so interested in Stewart Batty's grind. No matter how you rotate the flute you are still getting the optimum cutting action from the tip and still cutting with a 40 degree edge. This means you can rotate the gouge to either reach into a certain area or throw the shavings somewhere else. Either way you are still getting that same 40 degree cutting action

Re: Push cut vs Pull cut

#7

Roger Dunn

What's a Stewart Batty grind?

Roger Dunn

>John,

For those uninformed souls like me, can you point us toward this grind please?

Thank you

Roger Dunn

Re: Push cut vs Pull cut

#8

Re: Push cut vs Pull cut

John Trant (Baltimore/DC corridor)

>Well, I would beg to differ (at least, the way I do it). When I do a push cut, the flute is nearly horizon and the tip is doing the cutting. With my pull cuts, the flute is tilted upward and I am cutting on the side of the tip. In fact, the flute is often tilted upward (handle down, tool rest below center) by more than 45 degrees. Like Bill G. said, I prefer this cut on the outside of bowls and use the push cut on the inside.

Now you have got me thinking about it so I guess I will never be able to use that cut again. My brain tends to get in the way of processes that have been converted to muscle memory.

John

Re: Push cut vs Pull cut

#9

Steven Antonucci

Never got a catch on a push cut, however...

steve antonucci

>I have in a moment of weakness, lost concentration on a pull cut, and either over rotated or had the handle raised to high, and taken a CHAW out of the outside of a nice form. Not your minor, 60 grit dig, but a finger sized projectile...

So I prefer a push cut, but use both.

Steve

Re: Push cut vs Pull cut

#10

Re: Push cut vs Pull cut

adrien

>I assume this refers to the OUTSIDE of a bowl? 'Cause whenever i've tried a pull cut on the inside, the catch has been awful. Not at the rim, but from about an inch down.....

Re: Push cut vs Pull cut

#11

Re: Never got a catch on a push cut, however...

john Lucas

>Steve I've gotten some great catches with both cuts but rarely happens anymore. I guess it was lack of attention when I was turning early in my years. With Terry's method the gouge is held at such a steep angle that a catch is nearly impossible. You may come out of the cut and loose the line but you won't get a catch. I just can't control the cut as accurately.

With a push cut done properly there is still a possibility of a catch if you have a large protrusion and you end up taking too big a bite. As long as you watch these areas you shouldn't have a problem. Of course I'm probably preaching to the chior here since you use a push cut.

Re: Push cut vs Pull cut

#12

Re: Push cut vs Pull cut

tdaniel

>yes Adrien, I was referring to the outside primarily. I see no difference whatever in whether I am pulling or pushing the tool other than the trash in my mouth thingy. When doing demos I will start a pull cut and then stop the lathe and hold the tool exactly where it was and walk around it and continue the cut as a push cut. The tool did not move at all....just me. Why eat the chips when you can move your body to the other side and still use the exact same cut? I always cut with the handle very low so it might be different for someone using a level handle but I really can't see why it would be. Just thinking out loud.....

TD