Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Goblets

Posts

Goblets

#1

Goblets

Ed Kelle

>I've been practicing on a few goblets lately as well. Finally starting to get a hang of the detail gouge hollowing technique I learned from Keith in Saratoga this spring. I still have some slight difficulty on the center as it gets deeper, over 1.5" deep, but I work out the little bump with a scraper. These are just practice pieces. The thinner cherry on the right was done on the outside with a skew, it got very thin due to a few catches, but I kept plugging away and worked them out. It was green, might warp a bit later on but I don't care. Oil finish as soon as it was done, so hopefuly it will not move as much.

The oak was just some fun with some cracked firewood. Not as easy to hollow.

My biggest issue is just the form of these. Yup, more dumpy bases. I was really working on tool control so I didn't try to make something with a thin stem, but I didn't realize how bad they looked until parted off, of course.

Suggestions for improvements are very welcome. Draw on them if you want. Any links to good goblet design or pics would be a big help. Thanks!


img

Re: Goblets

#2

Re: Goblets

Ruth Niles

>Ed,

Don't be so quick to put your goblets down, dumpy isn't bad. I have a bad habit of looking at a picture first then reading the post.

Anyway, I looked at your goblet on the left and thought "what a great renaissance goblet".

Ok, so it doesn't look like the ones woodturners turn for woodturners; ie, it doesn't have a tall, very thin stem. Don't get me wrong, I love those goblets, especially Stuart Batty's...wow! But yours looks like a "man's goblet", one he can wrap his hand around not two fingers.

Ed, I'd drink an ale with you from these goblets any day. : )

Ruth

Re: Goblets

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: Goblets

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Ed, those don't look too shabby at all....Like Ruth mentioned, sometimes the slender stems are just for"Look at what I can do!" more than anything else. I think goblets are great fun, and good practice. An easy way to make thinner stems: I roll the tool on its side, tool rest adjusted so the cut is right on center. I use a cone to support the goblet for really thin stems, in the demo you attended, I just turned the stem with no support. With a low tool rest, it's easy to turn from large diameter to small, no constant tinkering with the tool rest height. I think the best way to come up with designs is to make sketches of any shape you can imagine, then try to duplicate the ones you like best. Nice work!

Re: Goblets

#4

Re: Goblets

Frank Mutchler in Colorado Springs

>Nice work, Ed. I'm with Ruth. Don't let the "Form Police" dictate what you create.

Re: Goblets

#5

Re: Goblets

Bill Crommett

>I, also like Ruth's attitude !

Re: Goblets

#6

Re: Goblets

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I like the cherry one. Nice curves.

Re: Goblets

#7

Re: Goblets

Tom in Red Deer

>I too agree with Ruth's opinion. The workmanship on these two appers to be excellant. One thing I always try to remember..I turn things that make me feel good, not what makes others feel good. If you saw some goblets from a few hundred years ago, you would see you are not far off the mark at all.

Very well done.

Tom in Red Deer

Re: Goblets

#8

Re: Goblets

Ed Kelle

>Thanks Ruth. Ha, I fooled you though, these are only about 4" tall so I can only get about 3 fingers around the stem. They are sort of like a tall brandy glass I guess. Either way, I'm going to show those and a few others at our turning meeting tonight.

BTW I like your site. I hope to order a few of your stoppers sometime soon. They look really great

I am going to look up Stuart Batty's work, thanks

Re: Goblets

#9

Re: Goblets

Ed Kelle

>Thanks for the tips Keith. I will give them a try. If I can ask another question, I've read about using a gouge to make an initial depth hole ( the push it straight in kind) for hollowing but so far have have not had luck. Which direction should the flute be facing? I have tried 12 o clock with the long detail gouge.

I will try doing a few sketches before turning next time. then it is just up to me to make the work look like the sketch. ooof

Re: Goblets

#10

Re: Goblets

Ed Kelle

>Thanks Frank. I always try to stay one step ahead of the Police ;)

Re: Goblets

#11

Re: Goblets

Ed Kelle

>Thanks Brian, I agree, it is my favorite too. So far that is, I hope to improve on it in the future.

Re: Goblets

#12

Re: Goblets

Ed Kelle

>Thank you Tom. I always try to follow my own style in any of my works. And I think you hit a good point, while I am amazed at some of the new works I see, especially here, I really enjoy old style works. I have a vase I am working on that I am trying to texture and make look antique and weathered. ANd I actually would like to try a pole lathe someday too!

Re: Goblets

#13

Re: Goblets

Tom In Red Deer

>I am going to England next month and a friend there has just built a pole lathe. He says he might let me try it. That would be fun.

I just made a bowl that looks and feels like it is about 100 years old. That was fun.

Tom

Re: Goblets

#14

Re: Goblets

Ed Kelle

>I'd like to see a pic of that bowl when you get a chance

Re: Goblets

#15

Re: Goblets

John Lucas

>Ed I not sure how tall they are but if they were "man" size, say 6 to 8" tall the forms would work well. They would fit in well at a tavern and because of the heft would not knock over easy. These are for drinking brew, not that sissy wine stuff. Of course if they are really small then the thick stem would fit between your fingers better for sipping a fine wine. I don't find them all that clunky. You had fun didn't you? that's all that counts. Besides the style police are after bigger fish.

Re: Goblets

#16

Re: Goblets

Ed Kelle

>Hi John. these are less than manly size, only 4". But I plan on making some larger versions.

Here is a more stout mug that I made last year, made based upon the book The Art of the Lathe. Have 2 more in progress now. Done in cherry and of course I had the endgrain checks in the base which I had to seal with CA. Guess there is no way to prevent this unless I get massivly thick wood which I an split into pith less blanks.

Yea I am having fun with these goblets, so there will be more in the future.

If the style police show up, I can flash my Artistic License and probably get away with just a warning.


img

Re: Goblets

#17

Re: Goblets

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>That mug just begs to have something cold with a nice head in it! And it will keep it colder longer on a hot summer evening.

Re: Goblets

#18

Re: Goblets

Ed Kelle

>93° on Long Island now and I will be taking a nice long hot drive to go to a turning meeting in a nice hot barn. Have an extra cold one for me tonight.